Crime scene clean-up: a victim’s family wants Queenslanders to be spared the trauma

Calls for state to follow SA and WA, where families aren’t responsible for organising forensic cleaning after loved ones die

Shelley Allison will never forget the look on her dad’s face after he walked out of the house where her daughter Haley was murdered. “Before the crime scene clean-up, my father had to do a walk-through of the house and I never understood why,” Allison says. “This big man, he went white … It was heartbreaking.”

The family were still coming to terms with Haley’s death when they learned, in the midst of their grief, that they were responsible for organising the cleaning of the gruesome crime scene.

Now they’re advocating for change so other families are spared the unsettling task of organising such cleaning as they mourn the death of a loved one.

Haley Allison was 26 when she was strangled, stabbed 10 times and set on fire by her ex-partner, Jason Michael Spina, in her family home in Caboolture, north of Brisbane, in December 2009.

Spina was sentenced to life in prison for the murder, with a postmortem finding Haley’s wounds were so deep they penetrated her chest and exited her back.

After Haley’s death, police told the family to hire a forensic cleaning service. They could send an invoice and paperwork to Victim Assist Queensland and be reimbursed, the officer said.

The grieving family were busy planning a funeral, so other relatives spared them the task of organising the cleaning.

“I was only 16 at the time and it was a very traumatic experience,” says Haley’s cousin Josie Spicer.

“[The cleaning service] neglected to clean upstairs and we found the murderer’s burnt skin in the shower … and my cousin’s blood on some photo frames.

“I can’t imagine how you can look at that and think that that’s at all acceptable. It just compounded the trauma that we experienced.”

Haley’s family were on holidays at the time of her murder. They’ve since sold the home where she grew up.

“We moved into my husband’s parents’ place for six months before we bought another house … We’d wake up, we still do now, in the middle of the night screaming,” Allison says. “It’s affected the whole family.”

The family wants Queensland to follow South Australia’s lead, where police engage companies to clean homicide crime scenes and the commissioner for victims’ rights is invoiced directly for the costs. There are similar processes in place in Western Australia.

“There’s so much going on already after a tragedy,” Spicer says. “Having to call someone and ask them for like their pricing and their availability to clean up your loved one’s remnants shouldn’t be in the equation at all.”

Prof Grant Devilly, a clinical psychologist at Griffith University, says he was surprised to learn victims of crime need to organise forensic cleaning in Queensland.

“I would have expected there was more support with the forensic clean-up service, whether that’s done by the coroner’s court or police,” Devilly says.

“As long as the family is involved, that seems to be a much more preferable circumstance.”

Queensland’s attorney general, Shannon Fentiman, says funding of up to $50,000 is available to family members of homicide victims that can be used to cover the cost of forensic cleaning.

Fentiman did not comment on whether the state would consider changes to the system to follow South Australia’s model.

“We understand that organising forensic cleaning can be a difficult and incredibly distressing task,” Fentiman says.

“That’s why we provide financial assistance to help victims to recover from the physical and psychological impacts of violent crime through Victims Assist Queensland.”

Fentiman says families can also access support through the Queensland Homicide Victims Support Group, which may be able to assist in the process of organising cleaning, as well as other expert emotional support.

A Queensland police spokesperson says authorities “may recommend forensic cleaning occurs following an act of violence in a residential or commercial setting”.

“As victims may feel overwhelmed and vulnerable … officers may suggest they speak with a support service or Queensland police around how to engage a forensic cleaner,” the spokesperson says.

“A victim may also decide to nominate another member of the family to manage this process at this time.”

Interactive

Spicer says the family is speaking out because they remember Haley as someone who was “infuriated by injustice” and would raise her voice “no matter the cost to her”.

“The way I remember her and try to keep her her alive is even when I’m scared or if there’s someone else who is being treated poorly, I try to speak up. This is an extension of it,” she says.

“The government is not going to be able to protect us from the emotions that come from losing someone, but they can mitigate adding to the harm.”

• In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is on 13 11 14 and the national family violence counselling service is on 1800 737 732. In the UK, Samaritans can be contacted on 116 123 and the domestic abuse helpline is 0808 2000 247. In the US, the suicide prevention lifeline is 1-800-273-8255 and the domestic violence hotline is 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). Other international helplines can be found via www.befrienders.org

Contributor

Eden Gillespie

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Disgusting stench’: the Queenslanders fighting for clean, fresh air
Residents say they are ‘sick and tired’ of foul smell that hangs over their Ipswich homes and have called for public health inquiry

Eden Gillespie

01, Dec, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Evidence refutes claims of youth crime wave, former Queensland children’s court boss says
John Robertson warns lumping together all children in contact with the justice system risks undermining community safety

Ben Smee

09, Mar, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Queensland to ban Nazi swastikas and strengthen hate crime laws
Palaszczuk government accepts and will implement 17 recommendations of report including banning hate symbols and addressing online vilification

Eden Gillespie

26, May, 2022 @2:23 AM

Article image
‘A crime not to go home’: 24-hour curfews forcing Queensland children to live with violent offenders
An increasing number of young people have been made subject to harsh restrictions as part of their bail conditions

Ben Smee

16, Jun, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Queensland government to moving to establish peak youth justice body as crime issues dominate
Exclusive: Palaszczuk government expected to begin process of establishing peak body amid pressure to crack down on youth crime

Eden Gillespie

16, Nov, 2023 @7:34 AM

Article image
Dozens of vulnerable children allegedly preyed upon in Cairns, upending Queensland’s youth crime debate
Police operation Uniform Kalahari reveals horrific alleged abuse and challenges popular narrative about the state’s youth crime ‘crisis’

Nino Bucci and Ben Smee

24, Sep, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
‘Everybody has had a gutful’: online anti-crime groups propel Queensland to a political reckoning
People with pitchforks on social media pages are raising fears of vigilantism but others say they want real solutions, not just more kids in jail

Ben Smee and Aaron Smith

25, Feb, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
Australians urged to ditch ‘tough on crime’ mindset for youth justice as it does not work
As Queensland cracks down on young offenders, experts fear ill-informed public sentiment is influencing policy

Ben Smee

25, Jan, 2023 @1:00 AM

Article image
Stuck in limbo, Katarina Carroll was a scapegoat for Queensland’s anxieties over youth crime
Despite hand-wringing over youth crime, data shows domestic violence – which the outgoing police commissioner had hoped to tackle – is the real threat

Ben Smee

20, Feb, 2024 @2:00 PM

Article image
Victims of crime seek tougher youth sentencing in Queensland, but could that make things worse?
A youth justice debate reignited by a tragic hit-and-run weighs harsher punishment against community intervention

Eden Gillespie

18, Jun, 2022 @8:00 PM