‘Shit area, shit house’: Queensland police officer allegedly told not to waste time investigating woman’s death, inquiry hears

Survey of 53 QPS officers revealed ‘prettier’ domestic violence victims more likely to receive attention from police, inquiry hears

A senior Queensland police officer reportedly told a co-worker that police did not investigate the suspicious death of a domestic violence victim because she and her husband were a “pair of scumbags who live in a shit area in a shit house”, an inquiry has heard.

At the commission of inquiry into Queensland police responses to domestic violence on Wednesday, Mark Ainsworth, a consultant and former police officer, revealed a female officer recounted the story during a survey he undertook of 53 police officers across the state. Ainsworth was commissioned as a “contract investigator” by the inquiry to examine whether any cultural issues within Queensland police were affecting domestic violence investigations.

The inquiry heard the female sergeant was concerned about suspicious circumstances surrounding the woman’s death in 2019, including that the woman and her husband had several domestic and family violence orders in place during their relationship.

Ainsworth said the female officer told him that the district duty officer had dismissed her concerns, saying they would not be investigating the death of the victim, who was from a low socio-economic area.

“They’re a pair of scum bags who live in a shit area in a shit house and police wouldn’t be wasting their time on investigating the death,” she recalled being told.

Up to 98% of interviewees surveyed by Ainsworth said domestic violence training was inadequate and a “tick the box exercise”, with little face-to-face training.

The inquiry heard one officer surveyed said recruits were taught by senior colleagues “how to take shortcuts and avoid the frustrations of completing voluminous amounts of paperwork”.

They said within six months on the job, officers “learned how to manipulate aggrieved persons at DV matters in order to avoid doing DV orders”.

Other officers also reported a “lack of respect” towards victim-survivors, with “prettier” victims “given more attention from police than others”, Ainsworth said.

The inquiry heard officers surveyed reported that some officers would avoid responding to domestic violence incidents “at all costs” and some officers shutting “their eyes as much as they can” so they don’t have to deal with the evidence.

Other officers reported the difficulties police face when interacting with domestic violence services, particularly with locating emergency accommodation for victims, the inquiry heard.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

Ainsworth said police told him one service suggested a woman sleep at the police station for the night and in another case, that a woman should sleep in her car.

The Queensland police service (QPS) said they are encouraging and supporting officers to give evidence to the commission of inquiry.

“QPS looks forward to continuing to work with the commission of inquiry and receiving its recommendations,” a spokesperson told Guardian Australia earlier this week.

Public hearings continue in Brisbane on Friday before moving to Mount Isa next week, with the inquiry set to hand down its final report in October.


Eden Gillespie

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Queensland police told victim her assault complaint was not ‘valid’ after speaking to perpetrator, inquiry hears
Commission of inquiry into QPS response to domestic and family violence hears from women who say police did not take them seriously

Eden Gillespie

26, Jul, 2022 @8:45 AM

Article image
Queensland corruption watchdog has ‘largely abandoned responsibility’ for complaints against police, inquiry hears
Crime and Corruption Commission investigates less than 1% of complaints with vast majority handled internally by QPS

Eden Gillespie

02, Aug, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Police visited Ayr home hours before fire that resulted in woman’s death
Queensland crime and corruption commission to investigate officer interactions with victim and her partner before house fire

Eden Gillespie

12, Aug, 2022 @5:43 AM

Article image
‘Watershed moment’: horror and hope from inquiry into Queensland police
Shocking allegations from officers and other witnesses must drive serious change in force’s domestic violence response, advocates say

Eden Gillespie

12, Aug, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Queensland police officer minimised domestic violence despite ‘punch-sized’ bruises, inquiry hears
Inquiry told threat to decapitate a dog and ‘clear photographic evidence’ of assault on woman downplayed

Eden Gillespie

14, Jul, 2022 @8:18 AM

Article image
‘Nobody knows about it’: Queensland police inquiry criticised for tight submission deadline
Domestic violence campaigners say new three-week timeline is better but still ‘not good enough’

Eden Gillespie and Ben Smee

08, Jun, 2022 @7:29 AM

Article image
Queensland police officer receives suspended jail sentence for leaking woman's details to violent ex-husband
Neil Punchard pleads guilty to nine counts of computer hacking in crime that victim says was a ‘betrayal’ and left her feeling unsafe

Ben Smee

14, Oct, 2019 @6:01 AM

Article image
Advocates criticise decision not to ask Queensland police boss to face domestic violence inquiry
Experts baffled by absence of commissioner, police minister and police union head among dozens of witnesses called

Eden Gillespie

05, Aug, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Queensland police misidentify domestic violence victims as attackers, inquiry told
Inquiry hears no effort was made to communicate with deaf woman wrongly identified as a perpetrator

Eden Gillespie

19, Jul, 2022 @10:01 AM

Article image
The startling evidence of racism Queensland police couldn’t shrug off | Ten years of Guardian Australia
Leaked audio from Brisbane’s watch house outraged Australia. Reporters Eden Gillespie and Ben Smee reflect on the game-changing scoop – and a ‘blue wall of silence’

Caitlin Cassidy and Marni Cordell

14, May, 2023 @3:00 PM