Queensland police told victim her assault complaint was not ‘valid’ after speaking to perpetrator, inquiry hears

Commission of inquiry into QPS response to domestic and family violence hears from women who say police did not take them seriously

A victim-survivor was told by a Queensland police officer to focus on being a “good mother” after reporting a “significant assault” by her ex-partner, a commission of inquiry has heard.

The inquiry into Queensland police service’s (QPS) responses to domestic and family violence on Tuesday heard multiple accounts from disillusioned victims who said their complaints had not been taken seriously.

Joanna Mason, a victim-survivor and advocate for Resound, said when she reported her assault to police, an officer initially advised her to leave her home and take her child with her.

But after police spoke with the perpetrator, who denied the allegations, an officer told Mason her complaints were not “valid” and they couldn’t take further action, she said.

“It actually validated his behaviour and made him feel that he was able to keep behaving in that way without any recourse,” Mason said.

“It often felt … like it wasn’t being taken very seriously and … like I was the one being made to justify my actions … rather than looking at the source of the issue, the person perpetrating the violence.”

The inquiry heard from another victim who waited two-and-a-half years to have a strangulation matter resolved in court and said police had failed to take out a domestic violence order on the night of her assault.

The woman, who was quoted in a written submission by the Red Rose Foundation, said the magistrate at the application hearing was “extremely perturbed” by the lack of action by police after seeing photographic evidence of her injuries and medical reports.

The chief executive at the Red Rose Foundation, Betty Taylor, said when the woman later reported a breach of the domestic violence order, she was told it wasn’t a “significant breach” but an “administrative” one.

“I was disillusioned and frustrated as a result of the experience and it only heightened my concerns that no one was taking my case seriously, and that I was just as vulnerable at that point as I had been on the night of the strangulation,” the victim said in the submission.

In a separate instance, Taylor said a pregnant victim suffered a miscarriage when she was flown to Brisbane after being strangled in remote Queensland.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

Taylor, who sits on the state’s Domestic and Family Violence Death Review and Advisory Board, called for a strangulation unit within the QPS, saying police responses to domestic violence have been “inconsistent”.

She said all of the deaths she has reviewed have been “predictable and preventable” and that perpetrators often exhibit a clear pattern of high-risk behaviour, including strangulation and signs of coercive control.

“The things women tell us more than once is, ‘I thought that was the moment I was going to die. I really thought that,’ and their partners have said to them, ‘Oh, you made it through,’ or, ‘Do you want to die?’,” Taylor said.

Mason said she spoke to 40 victims for her submission to the state’s women’s safety and justice taskforce, which recommended the commission of inquiry into QPS.

Her submission said victims’ experiences with police were “overwhelmingly negative” and included examples of police failing to take action and officers putting victims at risk by exposing their details to perpetrators.

Victims complained about officers “acting like they didn’t believe them or don’t want to hear what they have to say” while being manipulated by the perpetrator, Mason’s submission said.

The QPS are not commenting on specific issues raised in the inquiry but say they have been supporting officers giving testimonies during the public hearings.

A spokesperson said the QPS “looks forward to continuing to work with the commission of inquiry and receiving its recommendations” and that they are “committed to strengthening and improving” responses to domestic violence.

Public hearings continue in Brisbane this week, with the inquiry due to report back in October.


Eden Gillespie

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Shit area, shit house’: Queensland police officer allegedly told not to waste time investigating woman’s death, inquiry hears
Survey of 53 QPS officers revealed ‘prettier’ domestic violence victims more likely to receive attention from police, inquiry hears

Eden Gillespie

28, Jul, 2022 @8:39 AM

Article image
Queensland police’s reputation on the line as commissioner returns to domestic violence inquiry
Katarina Carroll’s first appearance was something of a public relations disaster – her second is being viewed by many as an interview to keep her job

Ben Smee

04, Oct, 2022 @4:30 PM

Article image
Six Queensland police officers accused of domestic violence within two weeks, inquiry told
Crime and Corruption Commission says one case involved allegations of strangulation and rape

Eden Gillespie

01, Aug, 2022 @10:44 AM

Article image
Queensland corruption watchdog has ‘largely abandoned responsibility’ for complaints against police, inquiry hears
Crime and Corruption Commission investigates less than 1% of complaints with vast majority handled internally by QPS

Eden Gillespie

02, Aug, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
‘Watershed moment’: horror and hope from inquiry into Queensland police
Shocking allegations from officers and other witnesses must drive serious change in force’s domestic violence response, advocates say

Eden Gillespie

12, Aug, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
‘Nobody knows about it’: Queensland police inquiry criticised for tight submission deadline
Domestic violence campaigners say new three-week timeline is better but still ‘not good enough’

Eden Gillespie and Ben Smee

08, Jun, 2022 @7:29 AM

Article image
Advocates criticise decision not to ask Queensland police boss to face domestic violence inquiry
Experts baffled by absence of commissioner, police minister and police union head among dozens of witnesses called

Eden Gillespie

05, Aug, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
The startling evidence of racism Queensland police couldn’t shrug off | Ten years of Guardian Australia
Leaked audio from Brisbane’s watch house outraged Australia. Reporters Eden Gillespie and Ben Smee reflect on the game-changing scoop – and a ‘blue wall of silence’

Caitlin Cassidy and Marni Cordell

14, May, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Queensland police misidentify domestic violence victims as attackers, inquiry told
Inquiry hears no effort was made to communicate with deaf woman wrongly identified as a perpetrator

Eden Gillespie

19, Jul, 2022 @10:01 AM

Article image
Queensland to push on with criminalising coercive control despite questions over police culture
State government committed to introducing legislation by end of 2023 but police need ‘extensive training’, attorney general says

Ben Smee and Eden Gillespie

12, Sep, 2022 @5:52 AM