Nationals harden stance against Indigenous voice after receiving more detail on proposal

Party leader David Littleproud says there is ‘no position where the Nats would change their minds’

The federal Nationals have hardened their opposition to an Indigenous voice to parliament, after Anthony Albanese confirmed the body would reflect a report created under the former Coalition government.

The party’s leader, David Littleproud, said there is “no position” where the Nationals’ decision would change now, after coming out against the voice last month.

Some in the Nationals have claimed a lack of detail about the constitutional change had partly driven their opposition, but Littleproud said information since provided by the government had “re-enforced” the party’s decision to oppose it.

He said the Nationals were opposed to the broad principle of the voice, instead imploring the government to create local solutions for rural and remote communities, rather than create a new representative body.

“The representative model has been tried and failed. The existing bureaucracy should be going out to those communities,” Littleproud said.

“There’s a vast scale of geography and a differences of need in communities. It can’t be done with representatives, it needs government to take this by scruff of the neck, and get the departments out there.”

Littleproud’s cementing of the Nationals’ opposition came after another state branch of the party split from its federal colleagues.

Ben Franklin, a New South Wales Nationals MP and Aboriginal affairs minister, on Thursday said the state’s Coalition supported the voice, in principle. This followed a similar move by the party’s Western Australian branch.

“We support in principle enshrining an Aboriginal voice in the Australian constitution,” Franklin said on Thursday.

“We know that it’s critical for Aboriginal voices to be considered at the heart of government and that’s why we’ve expressed our in-principle support.”

While the NSW and Western Australian branches have publicly snubbed the position of their federal colleagues, the Victorian Nationals have backed the decision to oppose.

There is also division inside the federal party itself with Andrew Gee pledging to support the voice, while Sam Birrell reserved his position and stopped short of endorsing his colleagues’ opposition.

“The federal Nationals’ position on the voice is determined by our party room and we celebrate and respect the Nationals’ diversity of views on many issues – that’s healthy for our democracy,” Littleproud said after being asked about Franklin’s comments.

“This matter is incredibly sensitive and requires respect and a calm conversation.”

Albanese said last week that the government’s proposal would reflect the 2021 Co-Design Process Report, written by Prof Marcia Langton and Prof Tom Calma.

That report was twice presented to the former Coalition government’s cabinet by then-Indigenous Australians minister Ken Wyatt. It laid out detailed options for the voice, including membership and interaction with government.

Littleproud said the confirmation of co-design report’s proposal had “re-enforced the Federal Nationals’ party room decision”. He instead called for more local solutions.

“Canberra should be going to them … sitting around their town halls and campfires,” Littleproud said.

“We must be agile enough to tailor specific solutions for specific communities.”

Littleproud said he believed that the voice model set out in the report would work for people living in urban cities, but claimed it would not work for those in regional, rural or remote areas.

The co-design report suggests there be two members from each state and territory, along with for the Torres Strait Islands and a third member “for remote representation” in NSW, the NT, Queensland, WA and South Australia.

Counter to suggestions from former party leader Michael McCormack that the Nationals could reconsider its opposition , Littleproud said the decision was final.

He said there was no “malice” in their opposition, and praised Albanese and the Indigenous Australians minister, Linda Burney, for being “open and honest” with their proposals.

“The broad architecture is where our issues are, and the broad detail is locked in,” Littleproud said.

“There’s no position where the Nats would change their minds.”

Wyatt called the Nationals’ decision “disappointing”, accusing them of “laziness” in not considering reports on the voice created under the former government.


Tamsin Rose and Josh Butler

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Matt Kean urges federal Liberals to support Indigenous voice to parliament
NSW treasurer says referendum is an ‘opportunity to unite the nation’ and the party’s backing would ensure broad support for yes vote

Michael McGowan

06, Dec, 2022 @12:08 AM

Article image
The rhetoric around the Indigenous voice to parliament shows it’ll be a rough campaign
If this week was an indication of the level of the debate, then Australia is in for a torrid time when referendum process begins in earnest

Lorena Allam

02, Dec, 2022 @1:30 AM

Article image
David Littleproud is a ‘kindergarten kid’ whose Nationals will be ‘left behind’ on voice, Noel Pearson says
Jacinta Nampijinpa Price caught in a ‘tragic redneck celebrity vortex’ and ‘punching down on other Blackfellas’, Cape York leader says

Daniel Hurst and Amy Remeikis

29, Nov, 2022 @12:00 AM

Article image
Nationals’ stance on Indigenous voice a ‘slap in the face to black people’, Aboriginal leader says
Laura Hand-Ross says party’s opposition to constitutional recognition is an ‘insult’ that has caused disquiet in the community

Fleur Connick

07, Dec, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Nationals MP Andrew Gee quits party citing its opposition to Indigenous voice
The member for Calare, who will now sit as an independent, said he ‘fundamentally disagreed’ with party’s position

Paul Karp

23, Dec, 2022 @12:43 AM

Article image
‘Not on the agenda’: NSW minister rules out state treaty with First Nations people
Ben Franklin says Coalition has no plans for a formal pact despite backing federal voice to parliament

Tamsin Rose

08, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Afternoon Update: Landmark gender equality bill; Nationals oppose Indigenous voice; and Bob Dylan’s ‘fake’ signature
Labor passes its Respect@Work bill to address workplace culture and is set to pass the industrial relations bill after David Pocock gave his support

Antoun Issa

28, Nov, 2022 @6:14 AM

Article image
Why do the Nationals oppose the Indigenous voice and do their arguments stand up to scrutiny?
David Littleproud says the move would add more bureaucracy while Uluru campaigners believe it would mean practical improvements to lives

Lorena Allam

29, Nov, 2022 @4:44 AM

Article image
Guardian Essential poll: support for Aukus and Indigenous voice declines
Anthony Albanese improves in personal measures, including honesty and vision, despite waning support for major policies

Paul Karp Chief political correspondent

20, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Peter Dutton is giving Albanese a lose-lose proposition as his shadow campaign against the Indigenous voice to parliament escalates | Paul Karp
The opposition leader’s comments foreshadow an ugly referendum campaign on the voice to parliament

Paul Karp

18, Jan, 2023 @2:25 AM