Map reveals Australian hotels used for immigration detention, but secrecy means it’s incomplete

Exclusive: With almost no publicly available information about ‘Apods’, researchers say the lack of transparency is concerning for human rights

Researchers have mapped dozens of hotels used for immigration detention by the Australian government, the first nationwide visualisation of a practice that has operated largely in the shadows.

But the data remains incomplete.

For two decades, the Australian government has run a network of semi-secret “alternative places of detention” – often hotels in major cities – at times detaining more than 3,000 people, but with almost no publicly available information about them.

The locations of the “Apods” are not listed publicly by the government, and a freedom of information request for the information was refused this year because the department said it did not have a “list” of where they all are.

Independent government agencies have consistently raised concerns about the conditions in Apods and the length of time people are held in them, sometimes approaching two years.

“The hotels used for immigration detention have been found to lack dedicated facilities for exercise and recreation, there is often limited access to fresh air or outdoor space, and there have been media reports of maggoty food,” the human rights commissioner, Lorraine Finlay, said. “The human rights and health impacts of hotel detention are serious and well documented.”

Department officials have told the parliament that, between 2018 and 2021, at least 170 places across Australia were designated as Apods. The commonwealth ombudsman reported 77 hotels were approved as Apods as at 31 July this year, with seven in current use.

Researchers from Macquarie University and the University of New South Wales’ Kaldor Centre for international refugee law have relied on court documents, freedom of information requests and responses to Senate estimates questions to build a coast-to-coast interactive map of where centres are.

But the researchers argue the secrecy surrounding Apods means the list of Australia’s hidden detention centres is incomplete: they have been able to identify only 34 hotels formerly used as Apods.

“The lack of transparency about these closed-detention facilities is concerning in regard to the rights of those held within hotel rooms, some for more than 600 days,” Dr Andrew Burridge, from Macquarie University’s school of social sciences, said.

“Those detained within the hotels though medevac transfers have described these as prisons and sites of torture.”

The deputy director of the Kaldor Centre, Associate Prof Daniel Ghezelbash, said the research demonstrated the need for transparency around current and past use of hotels for immigration detention.

“While the Commonwealth Ombudsman and the Australian Human Rights Commission do monitor conditions at these facilities, the Australian public has been kept in the dark about the locations and scale of the use of hotels for immigration detention. This is not acceptable in a democratic society,” he said.

Ghezelbash said it was welcome that the new government had released significant numbers of refugees and asylum seekers from hotels into community detention in recent months.

Australia’s Migration Act requires that all non-citizens in the country without a valid visa be detained. Apods were first introduced in 2002, as a more accommodating alternative for children, families or vulnerable people who could not be adequately cared for inside the more restrictive confines of immigration detention centres. The policy allows for hospitals, aged care homes, or, increasingly, hotels, to be designated by the immigration minister as an Apod.

At the peak of the practice, when detention centres around the country were overfilled in 2013, more than 3,500 people were held in Apods in Australia and on the Christmas and Cocos/Keeling islands. The use of Apods has since reduced significantly, to about 500 people in 2015 and 88 people now, according to government figures.

In October, the Australian Human Rights Commission and the commonwealth ombudsman took the rare step of issuing a joint public statement saying that Apods were only suitable for short-term detention of less than four weeks.

The average time in detention was 69 days, the statement said, but the longest a person had been held continuously inside a hotel Apod was 634 days.

Apods operate largely unknown, occasionally flaring into public awareness when they are the site of protests – such as Brisbane’s Kangaroo Point Central and Melbourne’s Mantra, or when they are the centre of a big Covid-19 outbreak – such as inner Melbourne’s Park hotel.

The Park hotel in Carlton, which has since been sold and renamed, attracted global scrutiny when the world’s No 1 tennis player, Novak Djokovic, was briefly held there, before being removed from Australia because he was unvaccinated.

His presence in the hotel drew attention to the fact that dozens of refugees and asylum seekers, most of them medevac transfers from Australia’s offshore detention regime, had been held in the hotel for months, some for more than a year.

The legality of Australia’s practice of designating certain sites as Apods is under scrutiny in the federal court. Iranian refugee Moz Azimitabar is suing the federal government for his allegedly unlawful detention over 14 months in the Mantra and Park hotels in Melbourne.

A spokesperson for the Australian Border Force told the Guardian the government was “committed to a managed and equitable system of migration, consistent with our international obligations and respect for the human rights”.

The spokesperson said it was the government’s intention that the use of hotel-like accommodation as an Alternative Place of Detention (Apod) should only occur when necessary and for the shortest period of time required.

The department respected people’s right to protest, the spokesperson said, but would not tolerate violent or aggressive demonstrations.

“For operational, security and safety reasons of detainees, service providers and members of the public, and especially the privacy of detainees, the Department will not publicly disclose a full list of Apods.”


Contributor

Ben Doherty

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australia holding people in immigration detention for record 689 days on average, report finds
Human Rights Watch says the average is 12 times longer than the US, showing ‘how completely alone Australia is in the world’

Christopher Knaus and Ben Doherty

16, Feb, 2022 @12:49 AM

Article image
Kurdish refugee sues Australian government for alleged unlawful imprisonment in Melbourne hotels
Mostafa ‘Moz’ Azimitabar seeks damages for detention over 14 months in case that could carry implications for hundreds of asylum seekers

Ben Doherty

29, Jul, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Dutton's bid to ban mobile phones in immigration detention centres could be unconstitutional
Civil society and human rights organisations warn phones are a ‘lifeline’ and any ban would damage refugees’ mental health

Hannah Ryan

24, Jun, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
Refugee brings court case over threat of Covid-19 in Australian detention
Challenge seen as test case for other asylum seekers living in close confines and comes as medical experts urge reduction in numbers held in detention

Ben Doherty

22, Apr, 2020 @3:35 AM

Article image
UN urges Australia to release dangerously ill refugee who has ‘given up on living’ after eight years
UN human rights committee says Kaveh, who lies emaciated in a Melbourne hospital, should be moved to community detention

Ben Doherty

11, Aug, 2021 @2:54 AM

Article image
'Am I illegal? Am I different?': the future is uncertain even after detention
Despite being granted refugee status after spending time in Nauru, Betelhem Zeleke remains on a bridging visa

Alexandra Spring

09, Dec, 2020 @7:00 PM

Article image
After eight years in Australian detention, the only refugee family held in Darwin centre remains in legal limbo
Held in small cabins behind the airport, Hajar Maghames says her family has ‘no resources left to withstand the oppressive situation’

Saba Vasefi

11, Aug, 2021 @5:03 AM

Article image
Iranian refugee Mehdi Ali released after nine years in Australian immigration detention
Mehdi, who became the public face of refugees and asylum seekers detained at Melbourne’s Park Hotel, is being resettled in the US

Ben Doherty

03, Mar, 2022 @9:10 PM

Article image
The ‘farcical’ drug scanners locking out Melbourne immigration centre visitors
Regular visitors say Serco guards using overly sensitive detectors are making them jump through hoops or refusing them entry to see friends and family

Helen Davidson

12, Dec, 2018 @5:00 PM

Article image
‘My only desire is to hold my son’: the grief of indefinite detention
Masoumeh Torkpour, from Iran, has spent more than eight years in Australia’s immigration detention system. But her circumstances prevent her gaining a visa – or returning home

Saba Vasefi

18, Jul, 2020 @8:00 PM