Bruce Lehrmann retrial won’t proceed after prosecutors drop charges for alleged rape of Brittany Higgins

Decision announced by director of public prosecutions means retrial of Lehrmann, who pleaded not guilty, will not go ahead

Prosecutors have dropped charges against Bruce Lehrmann for the alleged rape of Brittany Higgins, saying a retrial would pose an “unnacceptable risk” to her health.

The ACT director of public prosecutions, Shane Drumgold, announced the shock move on Friday morning, exercising his discretion to discontinue proceedings.

Lehrmann had maintained his innocence to allegations that he raped Higgins, a colleague and fellow political staffer, in the office of the then-defence industry minister, Linda Reynolds, in March 2019. He pleaded not guilty to one charge of sexual intercourse without consent, denying that any sexual activity had occurred.

Drumgold said he still believed there was a reasonable prospect of conviction at a second trial.

But he said he had to consider the public interest in proceeding, given a retrial would pose a “significant and unacceptable risk to the life of the complainant”.

“I’ve recently received compelling evidence from two independent medical experts that the ongoing trauma associated with this prosecution represents a significant and unacceptable risk to the life of the complainant,” he said. “The evidence makes it clear that this is not limited to the harm of giving evidence in the witness box.

“While the pursuit of justice is essential for my office and for the community in general, the safety of a complainant in a sexual assault matter must be paramount.”

Higgins’ close friend Emma Webster said Higgins was in hospital and receiving treatment and support.

In a statement, Webster described the past two years as “difficult and unrelenting”.

“While it’s disappointing the trial has ended this way, Brittany’s health and safety must always come first,” she said.

“Brittany is extremely grateful for all the support she has received, particularly from our mental health care workers.”

The decision means the retrial of Lehrmann, expected in February, will not proceed. Guardian Australia has approached his legal team for comment.

Drumgold paid tribute to Higgins, saying she had withstood attacks of a kind he had never seen during his lengthy career in the law.

“During the investigation and trial, as a sexual assault complainant, Ms Higgins has faced a level of personal attack that I have not seen in over 20 years of doing this work,” he said. “She’s done so with bravery, grace and dignity and it is my hope that this will now stop.”

Sign up for Guardian Australia’s free morning and afternoon email newsletters for your daily news roundup

The first trial heard from 29 witnesses over almost three weeks, and the jury took another week for deliberations. It was abandoned after a juror brought in outside research papers on sexual assault.

The chance discovery of one research paper led the ACT chief justice, Lucy McCallum, to declare a mistrial. She had repeatedly told jurors not to bring in outside research.

The first research paper discovered by sheriff’s officers attempted to quantify the prevalence of false complaints of sexual assault. It also included an analysis of the reasons for false complaints and why some are sceptical of true complaints. McCallum said the paper could have been used to influence jurors either way in the case.

A retrial had been planned for February. The ACT typically uses video recordings of a complainant’s first evidence and cross-examination in any retrial. But it had emerged that a legal loophole prevented that in the Lehrmann case, because Higgins had given evidence in-person, and not by remote video link.

The ACT attorney general, Shane Rattenbury, has since moved to reform the law to allow for video recordings to be used in such circumstances. The bill was to be debated in the first sitting of the ACT legislative assembly next year.


Christopher Knaus

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brittany Higgins rape charge: Bruce Lehrmann to stand trial in June
Tentative date set for defendant who denies one count of sexual intercourse without consent

Paul Karp

18, Nov, 2021 @12:03 AM

Article image
ACT prosecutors consider evidence in Brittany Higgins alleged rape case
Brief sent to DPP on Liberal staffer’s allegation she was sexually assaulted by colleague in parliamentary office

Paul Karp

21, Jun, 2021 @7:44 AM

Article image
Brittany Higgins to take stand in Bruce Lehrmann rape trial
Former Liberal staffer to give additional evidence to court alongside her complaints to police and a reporter about the alleged 2019 sexual assault at Parliament House

Paul Karp

21, Sep, 2022 @3:04 AM

Article image
Integrity watchdog to examine allegations of police misconduct during Bruce Lehrmann case
ACT attorney general says complaints surrounding prosecution of Brittany Higgins allegation referred to federal integrity and corruption commission

Christopher Knaus

09, Dec, 2022 @8:54 AM

Article image
Prosecutor alleges police ‘aligned with defence’ in Bruce Lehrmann case and claims ‘inappropriate interference’
Exclusive: Letter from Shane Drumgold to ACT police chief, obtained under FOI, calls for inquiry into ‘political and police conduct’ during investigation of Brittany Higgins claimss

Christopher Knaus

08, Dec, 2022 @4:15 AM

Article image
Inquiry into handling of Bruce Lehrmann case has scope to probe any ‘political influence’
ACT government confirms retired Queensland judge Walter Sofronoff will lead independent inquiry

Christopher Knaus

01, Feb, 2023 @3:44 AM

Article image
Push for ‘victim advocates’ to support alleged rape survivors in court following Bruce Lehrmann trial
Former federal court judge says independent advocates needed to ‘hold the hand of the victim-survivor at the time of greatest trauma’

Christopher Knaus

02, Dec, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Afternoon Update: No retrial for Bruce Lehrmann; Chris Dawson sentenced; and viva magenta colour of the year
ACT prosecutors drop charges against Lehrmann citing risk to health of Brittany Higgins posed by a second trial

Antoun Issa

02, Dec, 2022 @5:45 AM

Article image
Ten and News Corp aim to prove Brittany Higgins’ rape allegations in defamation case
The media outlets, which are being sued by Bruce Lehrmann, say their teams took great lengths to verify the story

Christopher Knaus

08, Mar, 2023 @2:34 AM

Article image
Brittany Higgins proceeds with formal complaint about alleged rape
Former Liberal staffer calls for police to act swiftly, saying she wants alleged perpetrator to face ‘full force of law’

Katharine Murphy and Christopher Knaus

19, Feb, 2021 @8:01 AM