Labor must not betray Indigenous voters by delaying voice to parliament, Keating and Pearson say

Former prime minister and Indigenous leader say that if the ALP wins government, it must hold a referendum in its first term

Paul Keating and Noel Pearson have said that if Labor wins government, it must not postpone a referendum on a voice to parliament, lest it repeat the mistakes of the past and betray its base of loyal Aboriginal voters.

In a wide-ranging conversation in Sydney on Wednesday, the director of the Cape York Institute and the former prime minister discussed a voice to parliament, constitutional recognition and treaty-making.

Keating said Labor should be “on the front foot” on negotiating a treaty with Indigenous people, and noted that the point of the voice to parliament was to “provide a measure of empowerment” that had been lacking since the abolition of ATSIC under the Howard government.

“The centrality of these ideas feed the truth of the [Labor] party’s existence, feeds its soul. Otherwise you live a lie,” Keating said. “I tried in the Redfern speech to articulate the lie, but we shouldn’t be living the lie … we’re still living the lie.”

Pearson said constitutional recognition was necessary first, and warned Labor not to postpone a referendum until a second term of office.

Former PM Paul Keating
‘We’re still living the lie,’ says Paul Keating. Photograph: Darren England/AAP

Pearson, one of the key architects of the Uluru statement from the heart, said there has not been a public policy issue as “protracted” as the constitutional recognition of Aboriginal and Islander people, noting that in the 14 years since the commitment to recognition was made at the 2007 election, there have been four parliamentary processes and three public inquiries, but no real progress.

“[John] Howard went into the 2007 election with that commitment. Kevin Rudd immediately said he would do the same. And the unfortunate thing was, when it was clear that Rudd was going to prevail at the election, he said we will deal with this in the second term. He never got a second term.

“And I fear that the opposition now is in danger of repeating the same mistake, deferring the question of putting recognition to the Australian people in a referendum to a second term and we’ll repeat the mistake of 2007, 2008.”

Pearson said he had come to terms with “the bitter truth” that “17 long years of a failed experiment in my strategy of reaching out to the political leadership of the right had availed us of nothing in the end”.

He hoped that Labor would hold a referendum in its first term, but said Aboriginal people had been let down in the past.

“There’s probably no other group in Australia that more faithfully votes for Labor than Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders, yet the Labor party’s respect for that base is often found wanting and they would abandon us – they have abandoned us in the past, like Bob [Hawke] did with national land rights in the 1980s – at the drop of a hat,” Pearson said.

“The constitutional recognition of a voice would not prevent the parliament from reshaping and redesigning the voice and amending its provisions. But it will always maintain an obligation on the part of the parliament to have a voice. And that’s why the voice is so important.”

Keating and Pearson were in conversation at the Judith Neilson Institute for journalism and ideas on Wednesday, to launch Pearson’s collection of essays, Mission.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

Keating recalled that in 1998, Labor had offered Pearson the seat of Lawler, saying he felt at the time that Pearson had all the qualities of a future prime minister.

“I’d said to many people that in the primary requirements of leadership, particularly of an organisation such as the Labor party, in the years after I immediately left, I believed you were the most qualified person to basically lead the country,” he said to Pearson.

But Pearson said he didn’t have the “self-belief” at the time to consider it was “a serious idea”. In the book he writes: “I should have tried the political path to power inside the tent, but I hesitated. I did not possess the vantage of self-belief to see its viability. I only see it now in hindsight.”


Lorena Allam

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Noel Pearson has 'real optimism' Coalition will create Indigenous voice to parliament
Cape York leader says it is still possible the body could be inserted into the Australian constitution

Paul Karp

29, Nov, 2019 @12:18 AM

Article image
Noel Pearson says ABC is a racist broadcaster 'willing the wretched to fail'
Indigenous leader attacks media’s ‘mutual racism’ while delivering a tribute to former prime minister Paul Keating

Christopher Knaus

21, Nov, 2016 @4:59 AM

Article image
Coalition playing ‘spoiling game’ with Indigenous voice to parliament, Noel Pearson warns
First Nations leader concerned opposition’s calls for more details on referendum is a diversion that threatens chance for reconciliation

Lorena Allam Indigenous affairs editor

23, Jan, 2023 @2:15 AM

Article image
Labor still hoping for bipartisan position on Indigenous voice to parliament
Linda Burney says she will try to be constructive during the co-design process, but ‘it needs to get cracking’

Katharine Murphy Political editor

22, Oct, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Senator takes aim at ‘bullies’ as voice row escalates – as it happened
This blog is now closed

Mostafa Rachwani and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

29, Nov, 2022 @7:58 AM

Article image
Labor plans to hold referendum on Indigenous voice to parliament in 2023
No final decision has been made but Uluru Dialogue co-chair says government is keen to hold the vote ‘as soon as possible’

Paul Karp

06, Jul, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Labor promises to ‘move quickly’ on Indigenous voice to parliament referendum if elected
Party accuses Coalition of ‘ignoring the needs’ of Aboriginal people as it releases First Nations policy

Lorena Allam Indigenous affairs editor

18, May, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Noel Pearson says Turnbull lying over Indigenous voice to parliament
Indigenous leader says the prime minister signalled he supported the proposal and ‘encouraged’ him on the issue in 2015

Michael McGowan

06, Nov, 2017 @1:42 AM

Article image
Voice referendum bills still on track for parliament, Labor says, despite impasse in negotiations
Albanese government hopes to progress two bills in the coming parliamentary fortnight as working group advice is finalised

Josh Butler and Lorena Allam

16, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Pat Dodson urges Coalition to 'deal with' Indigenous voice to parliament and referendum
Labor senator says he wants to work with Ken Wyatt to address these ‘systemic and seminal issues’ in government’s first term

Lorena Allam

05, Jun, 2019 @12:53 AM