Indigenous inmate sues ACT government over ‘vile and racist’ image allegedly drawn by prison staff

Lawyers say whiteboard image of man hanging was a ‘disrespectful, degrading and hurtful parody’

A vulnerable Indigenous inmate who prison officers allegedly depicted hanging from a noose on a prison whiteboard is suing the Australian Capital Territory government, alleging the drawing was a “vile and racist caricature” of “another Indigenous person they wished to see die in custody”.

In May 2018, correctional officers at the ACT’s jail, the Alexander Maconochie Centre, allegedly drew what appeared to be a game of hangman on a staff whiteboard. The man depicted hanging from the noose was an Indigenous inmate who has mental health issues and has previously attempted suicide.

A boat is shown sailing past with one of the passengers saying “yay”.

In proceedings lodged in the ACT supreme court, the man’s lawyers, Ken Cush & Associates, say the whiteboard and the hangman picture were used as a “vehicle to ridicule, degrade, disrespect, and vilify the plaintiff amongst the correctional officers and detainees in the AMC”. They say the image was a “humiliating, disrespectful, degrading and hurtful parody”.

The drawing remained on the whiteboard for some time, and photos were taken and distributed across the prison, including to other detainees, the statement of claim alleges.

The lawyers allege those responsible knew or ought to have known that the man was a vulnerable Indigenous person due to his mental health issues and previous suicide attempts, and that subjecting him to ridicule and humiliation was “likely to cause him harm, distress, and aggravate or exacerbate his pre-existing mental health conditions”.

Image on a whiteboard drawn by prison staff at the Alexander Maconochie Centre in May 2018, with a statement
Image on a whiteboard drawn by prison staff at the Alexander Maconochie Centre in May 2018, with a statement. Photograph: Supplied

The case alleges the government and the prison staff responsible failed in their duty of care to the detainee and their duty to prevent him from suffering harm. It is also alleged they failed to protect his human rights, which are upheld in the ACT by a dedicated Human Rights Act.

When it was built, the AMC was intended to be the nation’s first human rights compliant prison.

The case alleges the correctional officers’ actions, which the government is vicariously liable for, caused the man mental harm and exacerbated existing mental health issues.

It is alleged the actions of the staff responsible were deliberate, a gross violation of their duties, a perversion of their authority, and were spiteful and arrogant.

The officers responsible were never punished for their actions, the case alleges, and the drawing constituted “a vile and racist caricature of the plaintiff as being another Indigenous person they wished to see die in custody”.

The ACT corrections minister Mick Gentleman’s office said he could not comment on the matter because it was before courts.

But the government’s defence in the case, filed on Friday, reveals it has not been able to identify who drew the image. The government admits the drawing depicted the plaintiff, but says it does not know whether the staff knew of his mental health issues or previous suicide attempts.

The government also denied the staff responsible intended for the picture to be distributed through the prison community or use the whiteboard as a means to humiliate and vilify the detainee.

“The defendant denies that the plaintiff suffered injury, loss and damage by reason of its breach of duty of care as alleged,” the government’s defence says.

The ACT also denied it was “liable to the plaintiff for damages, aggravated damages, exemplary damages”.

Julie Tongs, the chief executive of the Winnunga Nimmityjah Aboriginal health centre, said the drawing was “absolutely disgusting” and the inmate who saw it has since suffered severe mental health issues.

“It’s a perversion of their authority, and it should never have happened,” Tongs said.

The ACT corrective services commissioner apologised for the incident in 2018 but Tongs said that didn’t go far enough.

“Sure they said they’d done the wrong thing, but why would you even do it?” Tongs said. “Why would you even go there, if you weren’t thinking that? And why would you leave it on the whiteboard?”

She said the man who saw the drawing has since suffered serious mental health issues, fearing for his life in custody. He has now been moved to a different facility.

“At the end of the day they’re human beings, and the majority of them are there because they have got mental health issues of addiction.”

She is now calling for a broader investigation into the AMC.

“Nothing less than a Royal Commission will suffice. It’s time that people right across the country and the world see what really happens in a so called human rights compliant prison here in the ACT,” she said.

“The whole system, it’s a failure. They need to do things differently. And they need to change the way that they do it.”


Christopher Knaus and Lorena Allam

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Indigenous incarceration: turning the tide on colonisation's cruel third act
In a new Guardian series, we explore what can and is being done to change the statistics that shame Australia

Calla Wahlquist

20, Feb, 2017 @3:08 AM

Article image
NSW police watchdog seeks power to investigate deaths in prison
‘Prompt and independent review’ is only way to overcome ‘resentment and sorrow’ among Indigenous Australians, MPs told

Michael McGowan

07, Dec, 2020 @5:59 AM

Article image
Indigenous prisoner restrained by 14 officers before death in custody, footage shows
Inquest shown ‘distressing’ images of Wayne Morrison, who was left unresponsive after altercation at Adelaide’s Yatala prison

Lorena Allam

27, Aug, 2018 @9:40 AM

Article image
Western Australia rolls out lifesaving hotline to address Indigenous deaths in custody
State adopts royal commission recommendation requiring police who detain an Indigenous person to call the Aboriginal Legal Service

Calla Wahlquist

01, Oct, 2019 @2:01 PM

Article image
Victorian coroner changes how Indigenous deaths in custody are investigated
Aboriginal legal services say they don’t have enough funding to meet the new commitments

Calla Wahlquist

22, Sep, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
The story of David Dungay and an Indigenous death in custody
Guardian Australia has followed the case of the 26-year-old Dunghutti man since his death in Long Bay jail in 2015. Here’s what has happened so far

Helen Davidson

11, Jun, 2020 @7:45 AM

Article image
More than half of 147 Indigenous people who died in custody had not been found guilty
Guardian Australia investigation finds that 56% were on remand, died while fleeing police or during arrest, or were in protective custody

Calla Wahlquist, Nick Evershed and Lorena Allam

29, Aug, 2018 @6:00 PM

Article image
ACT prison officers' drawing of Aboriginal inmate 'racist and hurtful'
Image of man hanging, described by minister as ‘offensive’, forces apology from head of ACT corrective services

Lorena Allam

12, Mar, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Yes, we jail too many Indigenous Australians – but what happens next is worse | Megan Williams
Even more worrying than the incarceration rate is the number of people who die within days of being released

Megan Williams

21, Feb, 2017 @10:45 PM

Article image
Indigenous leaders accuse ACT of trying to cover up strip-search of sexual assault survivor
‘You can only imagine the horror, the screams, the degrading feeling,’ woman writes in letter about ordeal

Christopher Knaus

11, Mar, 2021 @4:52 AM