Residents of Sydney’s Covid hotspots call out ‘double standard’ of recreation rules

Canterbury-Bankstown mayor doesn’t ‘begrudge’ people in east going to the beach but 5km rule means most waterfronts are out of bounds for his residents

Hopes that Sydney’s harshest restrictions in Covid hotspots could be eased have been dashed by the New South Wales premier, despite criticism from western suburbs mayors upset by packed eastern suburbs beaches over the weekend.

The greater Sydney lockdown allows for outdoor recreation including swimming but residents in local government areas of concern are subject to tighter stay-at-home rules. They can leave home during the day for exercise – and recreation from Monday if fully vaccinated – as long as they stay within 5km and inside their LGA.

For residents of the 12 LGAs of concern – which are in the west and south-west of the city – the 5km rule means most beaches and accessible waterfronts are out of reach, while public pools elsewhere in the city are currently closed in line with Covid restrictions.

Gladys Berejiklian, when asked on Monday if she would consider opening public pools in western and south-western Sydney, suggested the health advice did not allow for such a measure. “Unfortunately there are a lot of decisions that are difficult to take,” the premier said.

Berejiklian suggested many in the LGAs of concern could still access natural waterways.

“There are waterways all across greater Sydney, all across parts of Sydney. In addition to beaches there are river fronts and other waterways, but we have to take the health advice, especially until we get to the 70% double dose, as difficult as it is,” she said.

The Cooks and Duck rivers, which run through some of the LGAs of concern, have in recent years been recognised as some of the most polluted waterways in the state.

Berejiklian said she was “looking forward to us being able to open up and provide those freedoms” outlined in the roadmap after 70% of the adult population is double dosed but “until that time all of us have to stay the course”.

“We have seen what the ravaging effect of this virus is, how contagious it is. Nothing would give me more joy than relieving the stress and pressure families are under, individuals are under,” she said.

As temperatures reached the high 20s over the weekend across most of Sydney, social media was flooded with pictures of heavily populated beaches. While there are no suggestions beachgoers were breaching Covid rules, the images were poorly received in the western suburbs.

Khal Asfour, the mayor of Canterbury-Bankstown, said he didn’t “begrudge” some residents who were able to reach beaches legally but local community leaders were angered by a “double standard” when it came to recreation.

“It is the hypocrisy,” Asfour told Channel Nine. “We can’t go to our lovely parks, the recreational areas by the Cooks River or the Georges River. If we were out there yesterday we would have had the cavalry brought in.”

Asfour welcomed the freedom for fully vaccinated residents that came into effect from Monday. It allows groups of five to gather outdoors within 5km across greater Sydney but just two people or a household group to gather for recreation for two hours if they live in an LGA of concern.

He said more expanded freedoms were needed and clarity must also be provided as to whether residents of hotspot LGAs would gain liberties outlined in the NSW reopening roadmap.

“All we’re asking for is equality, fairness when decisions are made but unfortunately the premier doesn’t seem to know what it is like here on the ground,” Asfour said.

Tony Burke, the federal Labor MP for the western Sydney electorate of Watson, was critical of images of people without masks who appeared to be on beaches but were relaxing rather than exercising.

“It’s impossible to look at that and not say it isn’t one rule in my part of Sydney and a completely different rule on the coast. I’m fine with the health advice. I just … fail to work out how a park in western or south-western Sydney is incredibly dangerous and a park next to the water or a beach is not.”


Elias Visontay

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Covid case linked to Sydney’s anti-lockdown protest investigated for breaching self-isolation rules
NSW police say a 35-year-old man fined ahead of last Saturday’s rally was not at his residence and found at another household in western Sydney

Michael McGowan

30, Jul, 2021 @6:48 AM

Article image
NSW Covid roadmap explained: what can residents do when state reaches 80% double-dose vaccination and beyond?
Here’s what we know about the next two stages of reopening in New South Wales

Elias Visontay

27, Sep, 2021 @5:27 AM

Article image
Will Sydney’s Covid lockdown work and how different are restrictions to Melbourne’s ‘ring of steel’?
State premiers including Victoria’s Daniel Andrews have criticised the lockdown settings in NSW as too laxFollow today’s live coronavirus newsNSW restrictions; NSW hotspots; border restrictionsVic hotspots; Vic restrictionsVaccine rollout tracker; get our free news app; get our morning email briefing

Elias Visontay

29, Jul, 2021 @4:11 AM

Article image
Lucky break or gold standard? How NSW got Covid under control
After outbreaks in Sydney threatened to spoil the state’s summer, health authorities once again seem to have contained a flare-up without resorting to a city-wide lockdown

Melissa Davey

26, Jan, 2021 @8:57 PM

Article image
‘Pure gaslighting’: regional NSW residents furious as Covid spreads after vaccines redirected to Sydney students
As lockdown extends to Central Coast and Newcastle, those who had their vaccination appointments cancelled express anger

Elias Visontay

05, Aug, 2021 @7:53 AM

Article image
NSW Covid update: daily cases surge to 633 as Gladys Berejiklian dismisses calls to tighten lockdown rules
Non-urgent elective surgery at private hospitals postponed as staff redeployed to public system that government admits is ‘under stress’

Elias Visontay

18, Aug, 2021 @10:29 AM

Article image
Some of Sydney’s worst-hit areas exceed 80% first vaccine doses as NSW records 1,220 cases
Gladys Berejiklian has not confirmed if hotspot local government areas will enjoy the same freedoms when the state reaches 70% vaccination

Anne Davies

07, Sep, 2021 @5:19 AM

Article image
ICU specialists call for plan to fly interstate staff to NSW to relieve Covid strain on hospitals
Critical care advisory group ‘incredibly concerned’ by the idea of ditching nurse-to-patient ratios and wants a plan in place, should the situation worsen

Elias Visontay

07, Sep, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Northern beaches residents told to stay home as cluster jumps to 17 cases
Residents asked to work from home for three days while others in NSW advised to avoid the area

Michael McGowan and Ben Smee

17, Dec, 2020 @8:29 PM

Article image
'Everybody is very worried': testing times for residents of Sydney's Covid-19 hotspots
Wary locals are aware of Victoria’s deadly second wave of coronavirus and fear NSW could be heading down the same path

Naaman Zhou

30, Jul, 2020 @5:30 PM