Coalition avoids meltdown over emissions target – but at what price? | Katharine Murphy

Scott Morrison will be relieved the Nationals have limped across the line on net zero by 2050, but the detail of what was negotiated with Barnaby Joyce is yet to be seen

Barnaby Joyce came back to the leadership of the National party in the middle of the year believing that he was the leader to stop Scott Morrison landing a net zero commitment.

Joyce said as much publicly shortly after regaining the top job. In mid-July, he declared there would be zero chance of the Nationals party room agreeing to net zero.

On Sunday, the Nationals leader found out he was wrong.

In fact, the opposite was true. Joyce was just the stroke of fortune the prime minister needed. He was exactly the Nationals leader Morrison required to get his climate pivot over the line.

Going into Sunday’s crucial meeting, the Nationals’ numbers were said to be nine yes, eight no, and four swing votes.

By the end of of a two-hour partyroom conversation, a majority of colleagues were in favour of the net zero transition, provided Morrison followed through on the various high-level policy undertakings.

There wasn’t a formal vote in the room, but a tally was kept.

Joyce acknowledged the majority position in favour when he spoke at the end of the debate.

According to multiple sources, at that point the deputy prime minister also revealed his own position.

Joyce told his colleagues he was not in favour of net zero.

This is, of course, pretty extraordinary.

What this means is the Nationals leader – Australia’s deputy prime minister – is now fronting a Nationals partyroom decision that he personally doesn’t agree with.

It’s not just Joyce. Two other Nationals ministers – Bridget McKenzie and Keith Pitt – were also serious net zero sceptics, if not outright opponents. (Some say McKenzie was recorded as a no vote on Sunday, although recounts of her remarks to colleagues are hard to follow.)

Shortly after the leader’s contribution, George Christensen (another no to net zero) who dialled in remotely, wearing a T-shirt with “Support Coal” emblazoned on the front, said words to the effect that he would reconsider his position in the government. Matt Canavan, who fought Sunday’s landing point tooth and nail, was also full of fighting words.

So where have we ended up?

Joyce told waiting reporters the Nationals had agreed to a “process” for net zero.

This means Morrison has landed his net zero agreement in time for the Cop26 in Glasgow, provided the prime minister delivers on undertakings set out in a four-page high-level policy document – which at the moment has no dollars spelled out.

Morrison worked over the weekend with Joyce, the agriculture minister, David Littleproud, and the treasurer, Josh Frydenberg, on the shape of an agreement. There is still more work to do.

The Nationals want an extra position in cabinet – which means the return of Pitt (who was half sacked by Joyce when he returned to the leadership). They also want safeguards around regional jobs, and investment in new industries and infrastructure.

The Nationals had wanted Morrison to agree to a safety-valve mechanism where Australia would abandon its net zero commitment if regular reviews about the impact of the transition showed that regional Australians had gone backwards.

But the Liberals are drawing the line at that. The Liberals are happy to have reviews, but not happy to adopt a conditional commitment to net zero.

After all, Morrison told a meeting of the Liberal party room meeting just last week that Australia would go to Cop26 promising a net zero commitment as a nationally determined contribution – not just airy political rhetoric.

If Morrison were forced by the Nationals to walk that undertaking back, the prime minister would face a boilover in his own partyroom.

A number of Liberals wanted Morrison to land a higher emissions reduction target for 2030 as well as the mid-century commitment, but the Nationals vetoed an increase in the medium-term target straight out of the blocks.

As it stands, Morrison will go to Glasgow with a new projection showing Australia will reduce emissions by 2030 by more than the agreed 26 to 28% – but not with a new target, which is what key allies including the United States and the UK wanted Australia to deliver.

While all the frenzied political debate in Australia has hinged around 2050, in Glasgow all the substantive focus will be on 2030 – a reality that amply demonstrates just how Australia stubbornly lags the global reality.

So a deal for net zero is all but done.

Morrison will be relieved that Sunday didn’t end up in total mayhem, with ministerial resignations and the Coalition in meltdown. He’ll be relieved that a project he started shortly after Donald Trump lost the US election remains on track.

The prime minister has told the Nationals he’ll be going to Glasgow on Thursday with his mid-century commitment – come what may.

But Australians will have to wait a couple of days to learn the price of majority Nationals’ support.


Katharine Murphy Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Nationals agree to net zero target by 2050 despite Barnaby Joyce’s opposition
Agreement is conditional on cabinet submission reflecting negotiations between Scott Morrison and Joyce, who refused to reveal if he supported the target

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent and Katharine Murphy Political editor

24, Oct, 2021 @8:51 AM

Article image
News Corp and business council backflips on climate don’t mean mission accomplished, Labor warns
Chris Bowen warns battle for emissions reduction is not yet over, and says Coalition has ‘one last chance’ on new roadmap

Daniel Hurst and Katharine Murphy

13, Oct, 2021 @3:57 AM

Article image
‘Utterly his own right’ for Scott Morrison to commit to net zero, Barnaby Joyce says
Liberals and Nationals increasingly confident the Coalition is moving towards agreement on climate pivot

Katharine Murphy Political editor

19, Oct, 2021 @2:11 AM

Article image
Michael McCormack says agriculture could be excluded from 2050 net zero emissions target
Deputy PM says he’s focusing on now, not 2050, as Coalition’s climate skirmishes go on

Amy Remeikis

07, Feb, 2021 @2:32 AM

Article image
Barnaby Joyce says Nationals won’t commit to net zero carbon emissions without seeing ‘menu’
Deputy PM says push towards 2050 target is like being served ‘sautéed gherkins and sashimi tadpoles’ at a restaurant

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

18, Jul, 2021 @3:26 AM

Article image
Federal funding for Australian farmers could be open to environmental challenge, experts warn
Amid call for land-clearing law reparation, lawyers say global agreements may not always permit such assistance

Gabrielle Chan

14, Oct, 2021 @2:16 AM

Article image
Victoria’s most infectious day in over a year; NSW records 1,281 cases, five deaths – as it happened
Follow all today’s news

Michael McGowan (now) and Matilda Boseley and Royce Kurmelovs (earlier)

06, Sep, 2021 @8:24 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison says he wants to explain emissions plan to Australians before ‘people overseas’
PM implies he won’t attend Glasgow climate summit, saying people in the Hunter, Queensland and Victoria’s west are his first responsibility – after he’s met with the Nationals

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

05, Oct, 2021 @12:35 AM

Article image
Coalition faces net zero ‘plan’ fallout; vaccine booster shots approved – as it happened
International travel exemption scrapped for vaccinated Australians; 16 Covid deaths in Victoria and NSW; national child abuse prevention strategy announced. This blog is now closed

Caitlin Cassidy and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

27, Oct, 2021 @7:47 AM

Article image
‘Go grab a rifle’: Barnaby Joyce says the only way to meet methane reduction targets is to start shooting cattle
Scott Morrison and his deputy prime minister disagree over key methane emissions target ahead of Cop26

Sarah Martin, Peter Hannam and Adam Morton

28, Oct, 2021 @7:25 AM