‘Debilitating’: health impacts of smoke from Australia’s black summer bushfires revealed in study

Only one in five people sought medical attention but half reported anxiety, depression and sleep loss

The film-maker Shaun Humphreys vividly remembers the miserable summer of the 2019-20 bushfires.

His house, in a north Canberra suburb, was far from the burning fires, but the surrounding smoke was thick and stifling.

“When it first hit and we weren’t so savvy at managing the house and making sure that every window was completely airtight … you could see the smoke inside.”

Shaun Humphreys and Lilia Boag Humphreys walk to the shops in smoke-filled Canberra in December 2019
Shaun Humphreys and Lilia Boag Humphreys walk to the shops in smoke-filled Canberra in December 2019. Photograph: Shaun Humphreys /SRH

Hunkered down with his partner, the film-maker Vivienne O’Connell, and teenage children, Humphreys and his family bought air purifiers and watched “movies that remind[ed] us of the cold”.

“We just found it completely debilitating,” he recalled. “It got so bad that we ended up going and sleeping in our little film studio for a couple of nights, because it had air conditioning.”

#Timelapse from last night looking towards #Booroomba #orroralvalleyfire #bushfiresAustralia #canberrafire #namadgi #bushfires We left as we could see the dreaded #smoke rolling in. #sonya7iii pic.twitter.com/7mglXc6Vfh

— Shaun Humphreys (@shaunh) January 28, 2020

While the impact of directly surviving bushfires that threaten life and property has been reasonably well researched, less is known about the effects of exposure to bushfire smoke, said Prof Iain Walker of the Australian National University.

Walker is the co-author of a new study that has found the physical and mental impacts of exposure to smoke from the black summer fires was likely greatly underestimated by official health statistics.

The study, published in the journal Frontiers in Public Health, surveyed 2,084 adults affected by the bushfires close to Canberra.

Virtually all of them – 97% – said they had experienced at least one physical symptom attributed to the smoke. Half of respondents reported symptoms of anxiety and depression, as well as sleep loss.

Only one in five people sought medical attention for their symptoms, suggesting the breadth of health impacts was far greater than the number of cases officially recognised by the health system, Walker said. “A much wider segment of the population was exposed to bushfire smoke than bushfires directly.”

“People with any previous experience of bushfires reported more symptoms [both physical and mental] than those who hadn’t,” he added.

In addition to the stress of nearby fires, bushfire smoke disrupted routine activities such as the ability to exercise or travel outside, Walker said. “All of those have secondary effects on health and wellbeing.”

The most commonly reported physical symptoms were eye or throat irritation, and cough.

Between 15 December and 15 February, roughly a quarter of days in Canberra had “extremely poor” air quality levels as a result of bushfire smoke, while the other three-quarters had air quality classified as “poor” or worse. On the worst days, hourly levels of PM2.5 particulate matter peaked at almost 50 times the threshold for “poor” air quality.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

A royal commission last year estimated that the 2019-20 fires caused an estimated 445 deaths and hospitalised at least 4,000 people across the country.

“Then there’s the long-term impacts,” said Jo Dodds, the president of advocacy group Bushfire Survivors for Climate Action. “I have friends who have not been able to breathe comfortably since the fires hit.”

Dodds formed the group after a 2018 bushfire tore through her town of Tathra, on the New South Wales south coast. For hours, she watched as a fire on her street destroyed the homes of her neighbours. “The loss of the sense of safety in your home or in your community is huge,” she said.

With Australia predicted to experience more frequent and severe fires as a result of the climate crisis, Walker said the country needed “to seriously address the capacity of the health system generally in order to be able to meet … peak surges in demand”.

“That might mean – as has happened with Covid – that the health system finds ways to create surge workforces or other surge capacities.”

Dodds said: “If you haven’t been affected by bushfire yet, then you will be, one way or the other: whether it’s the smoke, or knowing someone who was impacted, or losing something yourself.

“That should lend urgency to everybody who wishes it to be otherwise,” she said. “It’s still important that we all call for urgent action on reducing emissions, because without that, we’re going to see even worse fires and even worse impacts on communities.”


Donna Lu

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Canberra experiences worst air quality on record as bushfire smoke from south coast sets in
Residents of Australia’s capital are told to stay indoors and brace for more smog in the coming days

Graham Readfearn

01, Jan, 2020 @8:49 AM

Article image
Australian weather: extreme heat sends bushfires raging across south-east – live
Mercury to surge past 40C across parts of NSW as emergency services battle 49 blazes and warn Sunday’s conditions will be ‘as bad as it gets’. Follow all the developments as they happen

Christopher Knaus

11, Feb, 2017 @6:58 AM

Article image
Threat remains for Canberra bushfires as NSW issued with smoke health warning – as it happened
Fires continue to burn around the ACT, causing severe smoke and dust haze in Sydney. This blog is now closed

Graham Readfearn

02, Feb, 2020 @5:40 AM

Article image
The big smoke: how bushfires cast a pall over the Australian summer
City-dwellers are experiencing the ominous effects of the catastrophic fires that have ripped through bushland in New South Wales and Queensland

Naaman Zhou and Josh Taylor

05, Dec, 2019 @4:59 AM

Article image
Smoke from Australia's bushfires killed far more people than the fires did, study says
Exclusive: Poor air quality also contributed to more than 4,000 hospital attendances, new research in Medical Journal of Australia shows

John Pickrell

20, Mar, 2020 @7:00 PM

Article image
Sydney's Star casino fined $5,000 for breaching public health orders – as it happened
Thirty-five outbreaks found in aged care services in Victoria as Sydney on high alert over Crossroads hotel cluster. This blog is now closed

Michael McGowan (now) and Calla Wahlquist (earlier)

13, Jul, 2020 @9:33 AM

Article image
Sixth Dorothy Henderson Lodge resident dies from Covid-19 – as it happened
Baptistcare confirms 90-year-old man dies after contracting the virus as total confirmed cases across Australia approaches 6,000. This blog is now closed

Michael McGowan (now), Josh Taylor (earlier), and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

06, Apr, 2020 @11:08 AM

Article image
Australia fires: NSW, Victoria and Canberra bushfire alert as hot, dry weather sweeps in
Total fire bans in place and emergency services on alert as weather tipped to fan bushfires

Josh Taylor

31, Jan, 2020 @12:43 AM

Article image
Canberra fires: capital of Australia faces out-of-control bushfire – as it happened
Orroral Valley fire downgraded from watch and act to advice level as Scott Morrison tells National Press Club there’s much to learn from this summer’s fires. Follow live news and latest updates

Michael McGowan (now) and Luke Henriques-Gomes (earlier)

29, Jan, 2020 @3:02 AM

Article image
Bushfire fears as south-eastern Australia swelters through record heat
Emergency services say NSW and ACT ‘extremely vulnerable’ to bushfires as temperatures set to exceed 33C in Sydney, Canberra, Melbourne and Adelaide

Naaman Zhou

13, Dec, 2016 @4:05 AM