Ibac branch stacking inquiry told publicly funded staffer spent 80% of time on factional work

An executive assistant in Adem Somyurek’s office tells commission she was told to work on ALP factional activities instead of minister’s portfolios

A Victorian ministerial staffer being paid by the taxpayer spent as much as 80% of her days doing factional work as part of a vast branch stacking operation, the Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Committee has been told.

Ellen Schreiber, who was employed as the executive assistant in the ministerial office of Adem Somyurek between January and August 2019, said that instead of dealing with work associated with Somyurek’s small business or local government portfolios, the minister advised her and other members of his staff to work on factional activities of the moderate faction.

Ibac is investigating branch stacking and the misuse of public resources within the Victorian branch of the Australian Labor party. While branch-stacking breaches Labor party rules it is not illegal and does not itself amount to corrupt conduct.

The inquiry is examining whether Victorian MPs engaged in corrupt conduct while in public office by directing ministerial or electorate office staff to perform political work when those staff were paid with public funds.

Schreiber said most of her factional work involved the processing of memberships and vetting of those processes by other factions, and that this became more intense as a branch stacking campaign “ramped up” in mid-2019.

She said if the moderates could raise objections to the members recruited by other factions – such as that they had been registered under a different address to that in which they were registered to vote, or that they were not recorded as attending a branch meeting – it meant the admission of those members could be delayed.

“Everyone was doing it, but not to the level and the scale [of Somyurek],” she said.

“Adem had a point to prove, and it was in retaliation, every time. If Adem put 30 [members] through a branch meeting, the left [faction] would come back with 30. So it was tit for tat.”

When questioned as to whether Schreiber was ever given a directive to not do factional work when she was employed as a ministerial staffer, she said that, to the contrary, Somyurek would often give her work to complete for the faction that he expected by the end of the day.

It was common for her to work with staffers from the ministerial office of Marlene Kairouz to complete these tasks, she said, and they often accessed a member database using another Labor staffer’s log-in details to perform these functions.

In part, performing party work rather than ministerial work was made easier because of the understanding that Somyurek had “small” portfolios, Schreiber said.

She agreed with a contention put to her by Chris Carr SC, counsel assisting Ibac, that she was performing this work not because of any allegiance she had to Labor, but because that is what she was told her job was.

She never raised concerns about the work herself because she wanted to keep her job, and believed she would rise quickly through the party – despite not having a university degree – because she had seen other women, including MPs, promoted because of their gender, rather than their talent.

Schreiber left Somyurek’s office to work in the electorate office of Anthony Byrne in August 2019. She told the commission that Somyurek offered her a role with the Construction Forestry Maritime Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU) soon after, working as the “right hand” of the Victorian state secretary John Setka.

At the time, Setka featured in a series of media reports that he said were “politically motivated”, and Schreiber said Somyurek told her it would look good for Setka to have a young woman working for him.

When she declined the job, she said Somyurek “was mad like a cut snake, he spat venom at me” and called her a “fucking idiot” who was going to fail in her career. She said she was “put in the freezer” after that, and was unable to take part in the political work she enjoyed.

The Ibac commissioner, Robert Redlich QC, indicated that lawyers for Somyurek wished to cross-examine Schreiber on parts of her evidence, but that cross-examination was not part of public hearings on Tuesday.

Earlier on Tuesday, Remy van der Wiel QC, acting for Somyurek, cross-examined Byrne about the evidence he had given on Monday.

Byrne admitted being involved in branch stacking, including having an office “kitty” he used for party memberships, and implicated a number of other Labor figures in the activities.

Van der Wiel asked Byrne about a series of text messages exchanged between Byrne and Somyurek that related to their dealings as factional allies in Melbourne’s south-eastern suburbs.

Byrne denied suggestions by van der Wiel that the exchanges indicated that he, rather than Somyurek, was in control of the faction.

“Counsel, you would have had to be on the dark side of the moon to not know who was in charge,” Byrne responded at one point.

Redlich asked Byrne that given the Victorian branch of the ALP had been aware of branch stacking for decades, and was more recently warned against the misuse of public resources after the Red Shirts scandal, did the party not have “sufficient will” to eradicate the “cultural practice”.

Byrne agreed and said he had cooperated with Ibac – to the point of raising serious questions about his own political future – in the hope the party would reform.

The hearing continues on Wednesday.


Nino Bucci

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Victorian MP employed ‘factional operatives’ for taxpayer-funded political work, Ibac hears
Adem Somyurek tells inquiry it was widespread practice for staff to perform electorate work when there was nothing else to do

Nino Bucci

08, Nov, 2021 @8:23 AM

Article image
Anthony Albanese stands by branch stacking MP Anthony Byrne amid Ibac revelations
Byrne, the Labor member for Holt, told the anti-corruption hearing he authorised taxpayer-funded office staff to complete political work

Sarah Martin and AAP

12, Oct, 2021 @3:43 AM

Article image
Patronage and branch stacking: five things we learned from Adem Somyurek’s Ibac evidence this week
Former Labor factional convener’s week before corruption inquiry revealed his own role and implicated Daniel Andrews

Nino Bucci

12, Nov, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Victorian MP’s husband paid taxpayer-funded salary for factional work, Ibac hears
Kaushaliya Vaghela agreed with Ibac investigators that her husband ‘predominantly’ did factional work while paid as electorate officer, sending one email in a year

Nino Bucci

01, Nov, 2021 @9:19 AM

Article image
Victorian Labor may face national intervention over branch-stacking allegations
Intervention, which could happen as early as Tuesday, follows allegations the rightwing powerbroker Adem Somyurek took part in substantial branch stacking

Katharine Murphy and Daniel Hurst

15, Jun, 2020 @11:40 AM

Article image
Labor revokes 1,700 Victorian memberships in response to branch-stacking scandal
Party’s national executive endorses 37 recommendations in review by Steve Bracks and Jenny Macklin

Paul Karp

27, Nov, 2020 @7:55 AM

Article image
Labor branch stacking: Victoria administrators recommend ban on cash payments for memberships
Steve Bracks and Jenny Macklin seek new mechanism to ensure all ALP members pay their own fees

Katharine Murphy

09, Sep, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
Victorian government loses second minister, Robin Scott, following branch stacking scandal – politics live
Adem Somyurek sacked and Robin Scott resigns from ministry, as state records 12 new Covid-19 cases. Follow the latest updates live

Naaman Zhou (now) and Amy Remeikis (earlier)

15, Jun, 2020 @9:39 AM

Article image
‘It’s wrong’: Adem Somyurek tells Ibac he ‘lost all perspective’ in factional battle
‘You can condemn me in the strongest possible terms,’ former Victorian Labor minister tells hearing

Nino Bucci

09, Nov, 2021 @9:30 AM

Article image
‘Rerouting’ stamps and phantom staff: Victorian Labor’s excruciating week at Ibac
MP Anthony Byrne’s evidence to the Victorian inquiry into Labor branch stacking has already brought up numerous allegations

Nino Bucci

15, Oct, 2021 @7:00 PM