‘What the hell is an HSC exam?’ Poet Ocean Vuong pokes fun at perplexed Australian students

Renowned author shares Instagram messages from year 12 students who complained about his ‘confusing’ text in English exam

The acclaimed Vietnamese American poet Ocean Vuong has hit back with humour after perplexed Australian year 12 students bombarded him on social media complaining about his “confusing” text in their final English exam.

More than 60,000 New South Wales HSC students sitting their English paper one exam on Tuesday were given excerpts to analyse from Vuong’s award-winning 2019 debut novel, On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous.

The non-linear coming-of-age novel draws on Vuong’s own family story. It is told from the perspective of a character called Little Dog, the son of Vietnamese immigrants to the US, and is framed in the style of a letter to his illiterate mother.

One of the extracts given to the HSC students feature Little Dog plucking grey hairs from his grandmother’s head as she regales him with stories, while another involves the protagonist engaging in a romance with a book.

After the exam, the author, who has received a 2016 Whiting award and the 2017 TS Eliot prize for his poetry, received a deluge of messages to his Instagram from baffled students asking what his text means.

Sharing the messages on Instagram stories, Vuong wrote back to one student: “Meaning… I, too, am haunted by it.”

So an Ocean Vuong excerpt was included as part of a standardized test in Australia and now ppl are DMing him complaints !! pic.twitter.com/RDGuSxmJm5

— Cass Balzer (@crassblazer) November 10, 2021

Vuong took the complaints in his stride, posting a picture of a dog with the caption: “yo, what the hell is an HSC exam and why are all of y’all failing it?”

He also shared more messages, along with ripostes.

“UR TEXT WAS GOOD BUT SO CONFUSING,” wrote one student.


“So u da one that got us all fucked up,” wrote another student.

“Don’t let ’em tell you literature can’t change lives,” Vuong responded.

Another message appeared to blame Vuong for scuppering their chances at higher education: “Ur text was in our major exams in Australia.. Those exams determine our entry into university ... WTF WAS UR TEXT.”

Vuong responded: “Yikes, next time quote from the opening chapter of William Empson’s ‘Seven Types of Ambiguity’ on the slipperyness of language and its destabilized meanings as a convincing and robust alternative answer. Good luck, blokes.”

When a student’s mother joined the post-exam pile-on (“Can you send me more information? My son tried to write about your text today and he still didn’t know what it’s about”), Vuong exclaimed: “Guys, they got the MOMS out here digging hard in my DMs. Don’t y’all have Spark Notes in Australia?”

Later, Vuong posted another Instagram Story saying: “For what it’s worth, I didn’t get into ‘uni’ either out of high school. I went to a local community college where I did some of my best learning (I was introduced to Foucault and Annie Dillard in Comp 101!).”

In 2017, Indigenous writer Ellen van Neerven received abusive messages on social media from NSW HSC students after her poem Mango was featured in the English paper one exam. The NSW Educations Standard Authority called on the students to apologise.


Janine Israel

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
War baby: the amazing story of Ocean Vuong, former refugee and prize-winning poet
His grandfather was a US soldier who fell in love with a Vietnamese farm girl. But then Saigon fell and the family was blown apart. Ocean Vuong poured it all into Night Sky With Exit Wounds, winning him a Forward prize – and comparisons with Emily Dickinson

Claire Armitstead

03, Oct, 2017 @5:29 PM

Article image
Ocean Vuong: ‘As a child I would ask: What’s napalm?’
How did a Vietnamese refugee come to write what many are hailing as the great American novel?

Emma Brockes

09, Jun, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
$625,000 'genius grants' go to Ocean Vuong and six other writers
The MacArthur Foundation honours, which encourage winners to ‘continue to innovate’, also won by Valeria Luiselli, Lynda Berry and Emily Wilson

Alison Flood

25, Sep, 2019 @2:04 PM

Article image
Night Sky with Exit Wounds by Ocean Vuong review – migration, America and Vietnam
Borders and identities blur in this hotly tipped collection from a young poet who moved to the US as a child

Sandeep Parmar

20, Jul, 2017 @12:59 PM

Article image
Night Sky with Exit Wounds by Ocean Vuong review – violence, delicacy and timeless imagery
The poet’s debut reveals a master of juxtaposition willing to tell difficult stories with courage

Kate Kellaway

09, May, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
Ocean Vuong: ‘I was addicted to everything you could crush into a white powder’
The poet and novelist’s latest collection is his first book to be published since the death of his mother. He talks about loss, addiction and performing literary drag

Lisa Allardice

02, Apr, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous by Ocean Vuong review – portrait of the artist as a teenager
A Vietnamese-American poet’s debut mines his extraordinary family story with passion and beauty

Tessa Hadley

14, Jun, 2019 @6:29 AM

Article image
Indigenous poet Ellen van Neerven abused by year 12 English students
Writer faces racist and vulgar posts on Facebook after her poem Mango is used as a sample text in Year 12 exam

Michael McGowan

16, Oct, 2017 @10:53 PM

Article image
TS Eliot prize goes to Ocean Vuong's 'compellingly assured' debut collection
Night Sky With Exit Wounds, the debut collection by a poet who is the first literate person in his family, hailed as ‘the definitive arrival of a significant voice’

Sian Cain

15, Jan, 2018 @7:30 PM

Article image
Kate Tempest: 'There is a damaging and poisonous racism at root in Australia'
British poet delivers passionate speech at Sydney writers’ festival and urges ‘empathy, humility, reparation and change’

Steph Harmon

19, May, 2016 @8:13 AM