‘It’s wrong’: Adem Somyurek tells Ibac he ‘lost all perspective’ in factional battle

‘You can condemn me in the strongest possible terms,’ former Victorian Labor minister tells hearing

A former Victorian government minister has admitted signing off timesheets that allowed a staff member doing factional work to be paid with taxpayer funds – but Adem Somyurek has denied trying to hide that other employees were performing similar tasks.

Somyurek told the Independent Broad-based Anti-corruption Commission he agreed it was wrong and he had lied when he signed a timesheet approving the payments to a casual staff member he knew was doing work on behalf of the faction at the time.

The commission is investigating whether public resources were misused as part of a widespread branch stacking operation within the moderate faction of the Victorian Labor party branch. Branch stacking is not illegal but is a breach of party rules.

Text messages were shown to the commission that indicated Somyurek was aware that a staffer for the faction, Salazar Youhorn, was required to sort out “member discrepancies” within the Cambodian community at the office of the MP Meng Heang Tak in July 2019.

Ensuring the accuracy of member details was a central part of factional work, the commission has heard.

But on the day the work was being done in Tak’s office, Somyurek signed a time sheet saying Youhorn had instead been doing a “project” in his office. The parliamentary employment timesheet, a copy of which was shown during the hearing on Tuesday, specified “payment must not be claimed for party political activities”.

Somyurek agreed with a suggestion from counsel assisting the commission, Chris Carr SC, that signing the form “was a lie”.

“I’m not going to be cute about it ... yeah, it’s wrong,” Somyurek said.

Soon after, when Carr asked “what about that is not corruption”, Somyurek responded: “Yeah, OK.”

Carr told Somyurek that Ibac had uncovered dozens and dozens of similar timesheets relating to employees signed by Somyurek with a box checked indicating other duties and then specifying “working on project”.

In a separate example involving Youhorn, both Somyurek and Tak paid him for work he supposedly did for each of them on the same day in June 2020, according to two timesheets showed at the hearing.

“There’s obviously a confusion,” Somyurek said. “I can’t see anything sinister in it.”

Another staffer paid by Somyurek, Jacob Cripps, had given evidence to the commission he was specifically told not to show up to Somyurek’s electorate office. Carr said Cripps had given evidence the job “was effectively just a charitable thing that he would be given free money by the taxpayer because he was going through a hard time”.

Cripps was paid after Somyurek signed a timesheet similar to the dozens of others uncovered by Ibac, Carr said.

Somyurek vehemently denied the staffer would have been told not to show up to work or expected not to do any work.

But he said the staffer was given the job because he had been sacked by another faction for switching allegiances to Somyurek’s faction.

Carr also asked Somyurek about Dr Hussein Haraco, who was paid by Somyurek’s office for multiple days while working from home because of Covid-19 restrictions last year, but allegedly did not log on to his computer on those days.

In a phone call intercepted by Ibac in June 2020, Somyurek told Rick Garotti, a factional ally close to Haraco, that he wanted Haraco to be careful, given that Ibac had started its investigation.

He said he wanted Haraco to be careful with “everything”, including logging on, but denied a suggestion from Carr that this was because he was trying to conceal from Ibac the factional work his staffers were doing.

“When Ibac goes into something they’re going to get everything,” Somyurek said on Tuesday. “You can’t hide.”

The Ibac commissioner, Robert Redlich QC, responded: “I wish that was true, Mr Somyurek – you would be surprised how limiting the legislation is.”

Earlier on Tuesday, Somyurek said he “lost all perspective” during a fierce factional battle and should be “condemned” for his behaviour during the period.

But he reiterated that he did not sanction widespread rorting of public funds.

In a recording of a March 2020 conversation played during Somyurek’s evidence, the upper house MP was told by an unidentified Labor staffer working on behalf of the faction that she suspected signatures on some membership forms had been forged.

“Fuck,” Somyurek responds, before asking, “Do people check that much?”

Carr asked whether this indicated Somyurek felt “no compunction” about the forgeries, to which Somyurek agreed, saying the only other possibility was that he thought the Labor staffer was being pedantic.

He said that ultimately he accepted his behaviour during this period had been blinded by a factional battle with the socialist left. “I had lost all perspective, and you can condemn me in the strongest possible terms,” he said.

Somyurek also agreed that earlier in the same discussion he had agreed to pay the membership fees for “Somalis”, in breach of party rules. There was a discussion during the same conversation about who would pay for the fees for members from Indian ethnic backgrounds.

“I’m not trying to say this was anything pure or proper, I’m not trying to justify it,” Somyurek said.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

Somyurek, who indicated during his evidence that he was working on a book about his time in politics, was again told multiple times by Carr andRedlich to directly answer questions.

He has made repeated mention of the difference between publicly funded staff performing factional work during part of their rostered hours, as opposed to doing full-time political work, as was uncovered during the Red Shirts scandal.

Carr described this as Somyurek’s “proportionality analysis” to determining what was corrupt, saying it was his position that “as long as it’s only days here or there, there’s no corruption involved”.

Email: sign up for our daily morning and afternoon email newsletters

App: download our free app and never miss the biggest stories

Social: follow us on YouTubeTikTokInstagramFacebook or Twitter

Podcast: listen to our daily episodes on Apple PodcastsSpotify or search "Full Story" in your favourite app

Somyurek also repeatedly emphasised that there simply was not enough factional work that needed to be completed that would justify the hiring of people on publicly funded salaries purely for that purpose.

But Somyurek agreed with Redlich that he never told his staff “thou shalt not do factional work during working hours”, partially because he thought it was permitted under laws governing the use of parliamentary staff, and that it was common within politics.

Somyurek’s evidence began on Monday when he accused the Victorian premier, Daniel Andrews, of dismissing his concerns about Labor’s red shirts scandal.

This was a $388,000 scheme involving the misuse of parliamentary allowances to pay Labor’s political campaign staff before the 2014 election.

Somyurek described the red shirts scandal to Ibac as “a gold standard rort”. He said that when he raised his concerns with Andrews, who was then opposition leader, he responded with “words to the effect ... [do] you want to win an election or not, basically”. Somyurek said he had given evidence regarding this meeting with Andrews to a parliamentary committee in 2017 or 2018.

Asked about the claims on Tuesday, Andrews said Labor had made “a number of important rule changes” since the Victorian ombudsman’s investigation into the scheme.

He said the party was “deeply regretful” of the red shirts affair, had already accepted responsibility for it and that he would appear before Ibac if asked to.

Somyurek’s evidence continues on Thursday.

Contributor

Nino Bucci

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Adem Somyurek ‘living proof’ of the consequences of Labor’s ‘unethical culture’, Ibac commissioner says
Former Labor minister has continued giving evidence to Victorian anti-corruption commission hearing into branch stacking

Nino Bucci

11, Nov, 2021 @8:51 AM

Article image
Patronage and branch stacking: five things we learned from Adem Somyurek’s Ibac evidence this week
Former Labor factional convener’s week before corruption inquiry revealed his own role and implicated Daniel Andrews

Nino Bucci

12, Nov, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Daniel Andrews defends decision to demote but not sack Adem Somyurek
Victorian premier says stripping business minister of his portfolio for bullying was appropriate punishment: ‘He has paid a very heavy price’

Melissa Davey

29, Jul, 2015 @2:58 AM

Article image
Daniel Andrews won’t stand down over reports Ibac is investigating his role in firies dispute
Victorian premier insists he has behaved ‘appropriately at all times’ including in his dealings with the firefighters’ union

Nino Bucci

06, Oct, 2021 @11:56 AM

Article image
Victorian ministers breached codes in ‘shocking’ misuse of public funds to fuel branch stacking, Ibac finds
There is not enough proof Adem Somyurek and Marlene Kairouz committed criminal offences to recommend prosecution, Victorian investigators say

Nino Bucci

20, Jul, 2022 @12:54 AM

Article image
‘Rerouting’ stamps and phantom staff: Victorian Labor’s excruciating week at Ibac
MP Anthony Byrne’s evidence to the Victorian inquiry into Labor branch stacking has already brought up numerous allegations

Nino Bucci

15, Oct, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Anthony Albanese stands by branch stacking MP Anthony Byrne amid Ibac revelations
Byrne, the Labor member for Holt, told the anti-corruption hearing he authorised taxpayer-funded office staff to complete political work

Sarah Martin and AAP

12, Oct, 2021 @3:43 AM

Article image
Victorian MP employed ‘factional operatives’ for taxpayer-funded political work, Ibac hears
Adem Somyurek tells inquiry it was widespread practice for staff to perform electorate work when there was nothing else to do

Nino Bucci

08, Nov, 2021 @8:23 AM

Article image
Adem Somyurek sacked as Victorian Labor minister after explosive allegations of branch stacking
Daniel Andrews labels MP’s conduct and comments ‘completely deplorable’

Luke Henriques-Gomes

15, Jun, 2020 @12:57 AM

Article image
Church and states braced for biggest battle on euthanasia
With politicians in Victoria and New South Wales pushing for new laws and Western Australia planning a state-wide debate, those who argue assisted dying for the terminally ill can never be safe are facing their toughest fight yet

Gay Alcorn and Melissa Davey

26, Jun, 2017 @6:00 PM