‘A step too far’: Liberal senator James Paterson speaks out against India travel ban

Influential Coalition parliamentarian says he worries about the precedent set

The influential Liberal senator James Paterson has warned that Australia has crossed an “enormous threshold” by criminalising its citizens returning from India, coming out against the travel ban.

Paterson’s contribution comes before the federal court’s hearing of a challenge against the ban, set to expire on Friday, and puts him in good company with many Coalition backbenchers who have spoken out against the ban.

The health minister, Greg Hunt, formally enacted the ban on 30 April in an attempt to lower the Covid-19 infection rate in Australia’s hotel quarantine system, which was experiencing a spike in cases due to the escalating crisis in India.

In a midnight press release, Hunt trumpeted that the ban was enforceable with fines of up to $66,600 and five years in prison – penalties legislated in 2015 when the Biosecurity Act passed parliament.

The India ban was supported by advice from the chief medical officer, Paul Kelly, which judged it an appropriate restriction, despite warning that in the worst-case scenario it would result in Australians dying in India.

On Sunday evening Paterson, the chair of the parliamentary joint committee on intelligence and security, said the medical advice was “not given lightly” and nor was the minister’s decision.

“I hope, however, that it never happens again,” he told Sky News. “I think an enormous threshold has been crossed that I really would’ve preferred wasn’t crossed.

“Criminalising Australians returning to their home country is a step too far. I worry about the precedent that sets about the value of Australian citizenship and Australian passports.

“Like many other things [done by the government] in this crisis it was an extreme measure, like many of the measures state governments have taken to lock people in their homes.

“And I hope we never see them again in peacetime or in any other context.”

There are 9,500 Australians stranded in India due to the ban, the number of vulnerable Australians there has risen to 950 and at least one man has died since the ban was enacted.

When the travel ban expires on Friday, repatriation flights will resume at the rate of one a week for the rest of May, to be supplemented by three assisted commercial flights into New South Wales, Queensland and Victoria.

Before the ban there were eight repatriation flights scheduled for May, meaning that fewer Australians will return home from India than was planned before the pause.

Gary Newman, a 73-year-old man stuck in Bangalore since March 2020, has brought a federal court challenge against the ban.

On Monday the court will consider the first two arguments: that Hunt had failed to ensure the ban was “no more restrictive or intrusive than is required”; and that the enabling act could not override Australians’ right to come home without clearer words the provisions could exclude citizens.

The case also seeks to argue the ban is disproportionate and Australians have an implied constitutional right to enter Australia, which will be heard at a later date.

Last week Coalition MPs criticised the ban as “extreme” and “heavy-handed”.

Fiona Martin, the Liberal member for Reid, a Sydney electorate with a substantial Indian community, told Guardian Australia the travel ban and related legal penalties were “quite heavy-handed”.

“There are a lot of Australians stuck in India that we should be bringing home as a priority,” Martin said, adding it was her “hope” repatriation flights would begin “as soon as possible”.

The Liberal MP Dave Sharma also raised concerns. “There is little doubt this is an extreme measure and that it is causing significant hardship to the Australian Indian community,” the Sydney MP said.

“It can only be justified on the basis of the unprecedented outbreak in India under way and the significantly heightened risk which this poses. I fully expect these restrictions will only be temporary and that enhanced powers will be used only sparingly and as a last resort.”

The Queensland National senator Matt Canavan told the ABC the decision was “wrong” because “we have an obligation to help Australians”.


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australia’s medical chief Paul Kelly says he gave no health advice to jail India arrivals
Comments come after foreign minister says decision to criminalise Australians returning from India was made ‘on the basis of advice from the chief medical officer’

Katharine Murphy, Daniel Hurst and Sarah Martin

03, May, 2021 @1:21 AM

Article image
Morrison says NT military buildup ‘designed to pursue peace’; ACT reports Covid case in returned diplomat. As it happened
Follow the latest updates

Nino Bucci (now) and Matilda Boseley (earlier)

28, Apr, 2021 @8:31 AM

Article image
Pipeline factory near Ningaloo Reef reportedly scrapped – as it happened
NSW reports no new locally acquired Covid cases; NSW and Victoria to ease restrictions; federal parliament returns for the final sitting week of 2020. This blog is now closed

Michael McGowan now and Amy Remeikis earlier

07, Dec, 2020 @8:17 AM

Article image
Western Australian Liberal senator Ben Small resigns over dual citizenship
Small breached section 44 of the Australian constitution by also holding New Zealand citizenship, but still plans to contest the upcoming election

Christopher Knaus

15, Apr, 2022 @4:17 AM

Article image
Australian man launches legal challenge to India travel ban, as number of vulnerable citizens rises
Gary Newman, an Australian in Bangalore, files suit against Greg Hunt for failing to consider alternatives before pausing flights from the Covid-ravaged region

Paul Karp and Sarah Martin

05, May, 2021 @8:45 AM

Article image
Australia’s India travel ban: how other countries are managing their returning citizens
More than 9,000 Australians are stranded in India due to the Coalition’s harsh measures. Here’s how the US, Canada, UK and New Zealand are treating travellers arriving from India

Melissa Davey

06, May, 2021 @2:26 AM

Article image
Greg Hunt accuses ABC's Michael Rowland of 'identifying with left' over Liberal logo questions
The health minister attacked the ABC presenter’s motives after being asked about vaccine tweet with party logo

Amanda Meade

10, Feb, 2021 @12:25 AM

Article image
‘Disowned’: family says pleas for help ignored as Australian man dies of Covid-19 in India
Daughter of 59-year-old criticises consular officials’ response and says her mother has been abandoned by her own government

Elias Visontay with wires

08, May, 2021 @5:44 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison says India flights won’t resume before 15 May but medevacs possible
Amid mounting pressure over Australia’s hardline approach, PM says he’s ‘very confident’ repatriation flights will be restored after Covid travel ban expires

Katharine Murphy Political editor

06, May, 2021 @12:54 AM

Article image
Liberal Stephen Parry to resign over dual British citizenship
President of the Senate announces resignation after being told he is British by UK authorities

Amy Remeikis

01, Nov, 2017 @5:13 AM