Queensland police regret making Indigenous leader leave Adani mine site during protest

Police recognise incident was traumatic for Adrian Burragubba, who was pressured to leave at the request of Adani

The Queensland police service has made a “public statement of regret” to Wangan and Jagalingou man Adrian Burragubba, in relation to an incident where he was pressured by officers to leave traditional lands at the request of the coalminer Adani.

The cultural leader brought a complaint to the Queensland human rights commission after police broke up a protest camp opposing Adani’s Carmichael coalmine in August last year.

At the time Burragubba said Wangan and Jagalingou (W&J) traditional owners had sought to “re-establish tribal control” of their lands and were blocking road access to the under-construction coalmine.

Before launching the protest, lawyers acting for Burragubba wrote to senior police officers outlining their legal rights under native title legislation to establish a “cultural camp” on the land, over which Adani holds a pastoral lease.

“Prior to our occupation we sought legal advice as to the exercise of our co-existent common law native title rights,” the legal letter said.

“We therefore refuse to leave while ever we are peacefully and lawfully exercising our native title rights.”

Police told Burragubba they had obtained different advice – that he required permission from Adani to occupy the land, and that he could be charged with trespass if he did not leave voluntarily. He and others later left the site.

It is understood Burragubba is the first Indigenous person to assert his cultural rights against a state agency since the introduction of the Queensland human rights act was passed in 2019.

In the statement of regret sent last month, assistant commissioner Kev Guteridge said police recognise that Burragubba represents a group of W&J traditional owners “aggrieved by Adani’s occupation of the land”.

“We acknowledge that the incident on 28 August, 2020, was traumatic for Mr Burragubba and his extended family, and caused embarrassment, hurt and humiliation.

“We recognise that there are complex legal issues and cultural sensitivities relating to this matter. We recognise the complexity of these matters and will commit to take into account the issues raised in this complaint in future responses.”

The statement did not contain any direct admission or statement that police or Adani were ultimately wrong in asserting that W&J traditional owners were trespassing on the pastoral lease site. Those rights remain in dispute.

However the police statement raises the prospect that, if traditional owners now sought to re-establish a camp blocking road access to the mine, Adani or the police may have to seek a complex legal ruling on whether they can be forcibly removed.

Burragubba said he was not sure at this stage whether he and others would resume the camp, but that W&J people were “free to come and go unhindered”.

“We have notified the state, we’ve notified the government, we’ve notified Adani, we’ve notified the police [that W&J people will occupy the land]. At this point I can’t say whether we’re going to take action again to stop the mine.

“The police refused to listen to our legal advice and that was the problem, they took it up for Adani. We have a legal right to be on pastoral leases. We have a legal right to coexist with pastoral leases. Essentially Adani doesn’t have a right to [make accusations of trespass].

“We are not happy that Adani keeps using the police and the government and the laws to prosecute us and persecute us and cause harm to us.”

The Queensland police have previously been accused of acting to “shield” Adani’s corporate interests after a crew of French journalists were arrested and given restrictive bail conditions while making a documentary about the controversial coalmine.

When the documentary was released, the journalist Hugo Clément detailed how police had them “under surveillance” and sought to repeatedly block filming near Adani’s Abbot Point coal terminal.

Police were contacted for comment.

Adani said in a statement that Burragubba’s son, Coedie McAvoy, had undertaken cultural practices on the company’s pastoral lease twice since September last year.

“We have corresponded with him in writing to advise he was able to access the pastoral lease for this reason,” the company said.

“We are very supportive of traditional owners undertaking cultural activities and as a responsible landholder we will continue to ensure that when people do wish to access our site, they are able to do so in a planned, safe, and respectful manner that ensures both [Adani] and anyone on the property are compliant with the law.”

Ben Smee

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Indigenous owners launch fresh legal challenge to Adani’s Carmichael mine
Wangan and Jagalingou opponents, who say project would override native title on most of their land, dispute Queensland mining minister’s approval of leases

Joshua Robertson

07, Dec, 2016 @2:19 AM

Article image
Indigenous envoy challenges Siemens in Germany over Adani mine
Indigenous representative will tell Siemens it is wrong to say traditional owners support Adani’s Carmichael mine

Graham Readfearn

04, Feb, 2020 @3:37 AM

Article image
Anti-Adani activists vow 'direct action' against mine contractor Downer
Galilee Blockade says campaigners will occupy work sites, chain themselves to machinery and clog phone lines

Joshua Robertson

24, Mar, 2017 @9:07 PM

Article image
Queensland approval of Adani plan ‘unlawful’, say environment groups
Activists consider legal challenge, saying rules related to source aquifer have been compromised

Ben Smee

22, Jun, 2019 @8:00 PM

Article image
Indigenous owners threaten legal action unless Adani abandons land access deal
Wangan and Jagalingou demand company withdraw its application to register a land use agreement that has been thrown into doubt by a landmark WA case

Joshua Robertson

07, Feb, 2017 @4:52 AM

Article image
Most Queensland voters oppose taxpayer support for Adani coalmine – poll
59% give thumbs down to state or federal assistance for Carmichael mine as state government faces factional fight over whether to give project a royalties holiday

Katharine Murphy Political editor

25, May, 2017 @9:12 AM

Article image
Queensland delays Adani mine indefinitely, citing fears for endangered finch
Environmentalists hail decision – but it offers company a clear path to approval

Ben Smee

02, May, 2019 @11:33 PM

Article image
Ian and Greg Chappell call on Adani to abandon Carmichael mine project
Former Australian test captains say opposition to mine in Australia could affect sporting ties with India, in letter directly appealing to Adani boss

Joshua Robertson

16, Mar, 2017 @1:46 AM

Article image
'Adani is a vote changer': Greens muscle in on Queensland's marginal seats
As the party home in on three electorates, they say a Greens MP could play a pivotal role in a hung parliament where One Nation has leached away major-party votes

Joshua Robertson

09, Nov, 2017 @11:28 PM

Article image
Details of royalty deal for mega mine are still being negotiated with Adani, says Queensland
Palazczuk government and mining giant apparently at odds as Adani says ‘there are no ongoing negotiations’ on Carmichael scheme

Joshua Robertson

02, Sep, 2017 @10:30 PM