Turnbull blames 'rightwing media' for dumping from NSW climate change board

Former PM claims NSW Coalition government was influenced by News Corp when it reversed his appointment to new Net Zero Emissions and Clean Economy board

Malcolm Turnbull claims the New South Wales Coalition government was influenced by a “concerted and ferocious” rightwing media campaign led by News Corp after it reversed his appointment to lead a new climate change body.

The state’s energy and environment minister, Matt Kean, issued a statement on Tuesday morning saying the former prime minister had been dropped as the chair of the Net Zero Emissions and Clean Economy board.

The appointment had been approved by cabinet on Monday last week, but was publicly questioned by the deputy premier, John Barilaro, after Turnbull backed a call for a moratorium on new coalmines and mine expansions in the state.

On Tuesday, the Daily Telegraph newspaper splashed with an “exclusive” story headlined “Malcolm’s coal war” that accused Turnbull of “Nimby activism” against a proposed expansion of the Mount Pleasant coalmine in the upper Hunter Valley.

It published three stories and an editorial critical of Turnbull’s appointment to the board and his stance on coal. One included details of a submission from Malcolm and Lucy Turnbull against the Mount Pleasant expansion. The Turnbulls have a farm nearby and had been open about their opposition to the project.

Turnbull told Guardian Australia the government overturning his appointment followed a “concerted and ferocious campaign” against him by the Daily Telegraph and other rightwing media. He said News Corp had worked up its story with “none other than One Nation’s Mark Latham”, who was quoted saying Turnbull should not have the board role.

“This is essentially the Coalition continuing to be held hostage by the right wing, which is sustained and empowered and amplified by the rightwing media,” he said.

“You’ve got this sort of rightwing climate change denying echo chamber, which speaks to a lot of people who are National and Liberal party members and doesn’t really speak to a big part of the community overall. It’s a feedback loop, and it’s dragged the Liberal and National parties further to the right.”

Latham told the Daily Telegraph the Mount Pleasant coalmine expansion would create 400 ongoing and 500 construction jobs. Turnbull said this was “complete and utter rubbish” as demand for coal was declining, and any expansion would mean a loss of jobs elsewhere.

“Nobody with an understanding of the situation in or outside government doubts these facts,” he said.

Turnbull last week backed a report by the Australia Institute calling for a moratorium on coalmine proposals and approvals, describing them as “out of control” in the upper Hunter. He said he was speaking in a personal capacity, and not as the board chair.

Turnbull said mines were devastating the landscape, shortening lives by reducing air quality and, given the declining global demand for coal as the world move to tackle the climate crisis, potentially leaving taxpayers with a huge environmental remediation bill.

Asked about this on Tuesday, Turnbull said: “I don’t resile from anything I’ve said.”

Barilaro last week issued a statement saying Turnbull had a “damaged ego” and needed to “set aside his war on the Coalition”. But Turnbull said he had a “very cordial” and “good humoured” conversation with Barilaro after his coal moratorium call.

“This [the board] was a part-time role which I was asked to do. I didn’t seek it. I agreed because we need to move as quickly as possible to a net zero emissions economy,” Turnbull said. “Unfortunately there are vocal forces in our country, particularly the fossil fuel lobby and the Murdoch media, who are absolutely opposed to that.

The editor of the Daily Telegraph, Ben English, said he was “saddened to hear that Malcolm Turnbull has once again decided to blame others for his own misfortune”. He said the newspaper had “done nothing more than cover a story of importance to everyone who lives in NSW”.

“This is nothing personal, even if Mr Turnbull would like to claim it is,” English said in a statement.

The decision to drop Turnbull comes as the Coalition faces a battle to hold on to the state seat of Upper Hunter triggered by the resignation of the Nationals MP Michael Johnsen.

On Sunday, federal Labor MP Joel Fitzgibbon, a vocal coalmining supporter, tweeted a photo with Barilaro and Latham at an NRL “voice for mining family day” in Newcastle.

Plenty of cross-party support for the Hunter’s coal mining industry at the @NSWMC round today. Couldn’t quite get the same unanimous support for the @NRLKnights #nrlknightsdragons #voiceformining @JohnBarilaroMP @RealMarkLatham pic.twitter.com/ukZceY0XoJ

— Joel Fitzgibbon (@fitzhunter) April 4, 2021

Announcing Turnbull had been dropped from the role, Kean said it was important the focus was on “facts, technology, science and economics”, not personality.

“Malcolm Turnbull, AC, has contributed much to our country and I know will contribute more into the future,” Kean said. “However, no person’s role on the board should distract from achieving results for the NSW people or from the government’s work in delivering jobs and opportunities for the people of NSW.”

Speaking at a press conference, the NSW premier, Gladys Berejiklian, said Turnbull was “a great Australian and a great contributor” but “unfortunately for everyone” his appointment was “proving to be a distraction”. She did not directly answer when asked if Turnbull would be replaced by a clean energy advocate, deferring to Kean.

Barilaro later told Guardian Australia that Turnbull had “severely misinterpreted” his role as chair of the advisory board.

“Under no circumstances did this appointment provide him with a mandate to criticise the mining industry and, as a result of his comments, the NSW government has decided not to proceed with the appointment,” he said.

The deputy premier said he had “copped a lot of flak” for supporting the coal industry. “I wear that proudly,” he said on Tuesday. “People try to slander us by calling us the ‘COALition’. I am perfectly comfortable with that because I know how important this industry is to the people of NSW and the wider Australian economy.”

There is a growing global push for countries to phase out coal. Thirty-six countries have joined the powering past coal alliance, promising to end coal burning for electricity by 2030 in developed nations and reduce it by 80% globally. The UN secretary general, António Guterres, last month said phasing the fossil fuel out of power generation was the single most important step to tackle the climate crisis.

The NSW opposition leader, Jodi McKay, said the decision to appoint Turnbull was “monumental failure of judgment”.

On Twitter, she wrote: “How on earth did it even come to this? John Barilaro backed Turnbull’s appointment in cabinet. This should never have been a political appointment and was always going to be divisive.”

How on earth did it even come to this? John Barilaro backed Turnbull’s appointment in Cabinet.

This should never have been a political appointment and was always going to divisive.

A monumental failure of judgment by John Barilaro. https://t.co/h97M2BRqng

— Jodi McKay (@JodiMcKayMP) April 6, 2021

Kean said a new chair would be announced “in due course”, and until then the NSW chief scientist and engineer Hugh Durrant-Whyte would act in the role.

The board has been created to help oversee the delivery of clean energy legislation that passed parliament with multiparty support in 2020 despite vocal opposition from One Nation.


Adam Morton Environment editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
John Barilaro attacks Turnbull over 'war on Coalition' and says NSW 'firmly committed' to coal
NSW deputy premier says ‘there will be no moratorium on coal in the Upper Hunter or anywhere else in the state’

Adam Morton Environment editor

31, Mar, 2021 @8:57 AM

Article image
The Nationals’ victory in Upper Hunter byelection may owe more to Berejiklian and Hanson than John Barilaro | Anne Davies
More Labor voters prefer the premier than Jodi McKay, while One Nation’s spirited campaign in the NSW seat doomed Shooters, Fishers and Farmers to electoral failure

Anne Davies

23, May, 2021 @4:40 AM

Article image
Upper Hunter byelection results: Labor concedes to National party in crucial NSW vote
Nationals candidate Dave Layzell is ahead with 31.22% of first-preference votes

Australian Associated Press

23, May, 2021 @2:29 AM

Article image
NSW considers laws to stop courts and planners blocking coalmines on climate grounds
Move comes after Minerals Council attacked planning decisions that cited carbon emissions as a reason for rejecting or imposing conditions on a mine

Lisa Cox

01, Oct, 2019 @6:00 PM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull backs moratorium on new coalmines in NSW
Former PM says Upper Hunter Valley mines are devastating the landscape and shortening life expectancy, and jobs focus should be on clean energy, tourism and wine

Adam Morton Environment editor

31, Mar, 2021 @1:25 AM

Article image
Court rules out Hunter Valley coalmine on climate change grounds
Judge rejects Rocky Hill mine near Gloucester, NSW, because of its impact on the town and ‘dire consequences’ of increasing emissions

Michael McGowan and Lisa Cox

07, Feb, 2019 @11:20 PM

Article image
Liberal Andrew Bragg urges Scott Morrison to commit to net zero
Barnaby Joyce declares test for Nationals to sign up will be impact on jobs ‘in Muswellbrook’

Katharine Murphy Political editor

13, Sep, 2021 @2:47 AM

Article image
Energy Australia confirms new gas plant in Illawarra after Morrison government threatened to intervene
Confirmation comes as questions raised over controversial Snowy Hydro project in Hunter Valley

Katharine Murphy Political editor

04, May, 2021 @3:30 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull accuses John Barilaro of ‘gaslighting’ with claim air quality data is manipulated
Former PM says NSW deputy premier and One Nation’s Mark Latham are treating the people of the Hunter Valley with ‘complete contempt’

Royce Kurmelovs and Adam Morton

08, Apr, 2021 @8:38 AM

Article image
NSW Independent Planning Commission accused of acting as 'rubber stamp' as coalmine approved
Maxwell mine in Hunter region is fourth fossil fuel project to get the green light in five months

Lisa Cox

23, Dec, 2020 @4:30 PM