Gladys Berejiklian gives NSW Nationals deadline to reverse threat to sit on crossbench

NSW premier tells deputy he cannot sit on crossbench and remain in cabinet after dispute sparked by koala protection

The New South Wales premier, Gladys Berejiklian, has given her deputy, John Barilaro, until Friday morning to reverse his threat to have the Nationals sit on the crossbenches or he and his fellow Nationals ministers will be stripped of their portfolios.

The crisis in the Coalition has been prompted by National party demands over koala policy which passed through cabinet and became law earlier this year but which the Nationals now want to be changed.

“It is my strong preference that existing Coalition arrangements stay in place,” Berejiklian said on Thursday afternoon.

“However, I have just made it clear to the deputy premier that he and his Nationals colleagues who are members of the NSW cabinet have until 9am Friday 11 September to indicate to me whether they wish to remain in my cabinet or else sit on the crossbench. They cannot do both.

“If required, I will attend Government House tomorrow and swear in a new ministry.”

National party members have until Friday morning to either support her government and its policies or resign from her ministry.

But Barilaro on Thursday night said the Nationals were sticking to their position on demanding changes to the koala policy and would not willingly vacate their ministries.

“This is about property rights,” he told Sky News. The deputy premier said the policy would prevent farmers from building a fence, driveway, shed or extra house without getting council approval.

“I am trying to find a way forward. I am not going to blow up the government. [But] if we have to walk away from our ministries that would be bad for regional Australia.”

But the NSW planning minister, Rob Stokes, said most of what Barilaro claimed was untrue.

“My colleague in the NSW government said farmers can’t build a feed shed or a driveway on their property without a koala study. This is not the case,” he wrote in the Sydney Morning Herald. “You can erect farm sheds, pour driveways, clear fence lines and engage in any routine agricultural practice that has occurred for generations without the need for development consent or a koala study.”

Stokes said koala protection “should not be about dividing our community between the city and the bush, between urban dwellers and country folk”. “Protecting the koala is protecting our shared identity as Australians,” he wrote.

Barilaro had earlier announced his 13 MPs would move to the crossbenches but would continue to serve as ministers and attend cabinet. He said the Nationals would abstain from voting but would not vote against supply.

The senior Coalition partner would need “to earn their votes” on legislation, rather than having guaranteed support, he said.

Barilaro said his party would be abstaining from voting on government legislation except when it was legislation that affected the regions or which the Nationals deemed important.

“We will not green-light just anything the government puts up,” Barilaro said on Thursday. But he ruled out voting with Labor to bring down the government or block supply.

In the most serious crisis of her political career, the premier is now facing the prospect of minority government and an end to the Coalition.

The Liberals have 35 MPs in the lower house, the Nationals 13, and Labor 36. There are also three Greens, three Shooters Fishers and Farmers and three independents.

“I am and always have been a strong Coalitionist and deeply respect the National party and all it stands for,” Berejiklian said. “It is my strong preference that existing Coalition arrangements stay in place.”

On the issue of the koala protections, which became law in March after a lengthy process and passage through cabinet, the premier said: “I have already made clear to the deputy premier that his policy concerns are listed for discussion at an upcoming cabinet meeting and will be considered by the joint party room.”

Barilaro had earlier said his ministers would continue to attend cabinet and expenditure review committee but would no longer automatically support the Liberals.

“We are equal partners, we are not a junior partner, and we will fight for the regions,” Barilaro said. The Nationals had said they were going to introduce legislation to repeal the koala protections.

Barilaro has accused the Liberals of foisting their guilt about koalas, whose habitats had already been destroyed by cities, onto the shoulders of farmers, whose property rights were now being attacked.

The new koala environmental planning policy expanded the number of tree species that trigger the scheme and included maps of land considered koala habitat.

If a person’s land is affected they must either seek an exemption by hiring experts to show it is not koala habitat, or they must show the development will not adversely affect koala habitat, before it will be approved.

The new planning policy, which has been championed by Stokes, has outraged Nationals.

While the new policy is unlikely to affect daily farming activities, it will particularly hit developers who want to develop rural land around regional towns and farmers in the north-west who want to clear land.

The new policy was introduced after scientists and environmental groups warned the koala could become extinct in NSW by 2050. Many groups say the new laws do not go far enough in protecting koalas.

The Liberal upper house member, Catherine Cusack, who is based in northern NSW, said Barilaro’s position was “just bewildering”. “There’s no exit strategy for either of us,” she said.

Cusack said that communities on the north coast were highly supportive of the new koala protections, as were a number of the local councils, because it gave more certainty. “This is the moment. Do we want koalas to go extinct?”

The chief executive of the Nature Conservation Council, Chris Gambian, said the departure of Barilaro from the government benches could only be good news for nature.

“Wanting to retain the right to kill koalas is an extraordinary hill for the Nationals to want to die on, but here we are,” Gambian said.

Gambian said the Nationals had dictated environmental policy to the Liberal party for the past decade.

“The koala policy is one small measure to ensure koalas don’t become extinct in NSW by 2050,” he said.

“People who have lived on the land for generations love the bush and share our goal of ensuring koalas survive and thrive into the future.”

The NSW Labor leader, Jodi McKay, called on Berejiklian to front the media to explain whether she still had a functioning government.

“We have 300,000 people in NSW without a job, and we are in the middle of a pandemic,” she said on Thursday.

“We have seen the deputy premier blow up the government. We want to know from the premier what is the status of her government. I don’t understand how you can walk into cabinet and be bound by cabinet solidarity and then walk into parliament and vote against government legislation.”


Anne Davies

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Berejiklian warns Nationals against further public posturing over koala protection policy
NSW premier implores John Barilaro to stick to agreement after he refused to rule out further threats to dismantle the Coalition

Anne Davies

17, Sep, 2020 @8:38 AM

Article image
NSW Nationals ditch threat to quit Coalition as John Barilaro's leadership condemned as 'untenable'
NSW premier Gladys Berejiklian offers to hold further talks over state’s koala protections policy at cabinet on 6 October

Anne Davies

11, Sep, 2020 @2:23 AM

Article image
NSW election: Gladys Berejiklian confident Coalition will win a majority
Government clings to power despite big gains from minor parties and independents

Josephine Tovey

24, Mar, 2019 @7:59 AM

Article image
Factional flareup: can Gladys Berejiklian keep her unruly ministers focused on the main game?
The NSW premier is trying to project a sense of order during Covid-19 but the men in her team are indulging in a kind of sabotage

Anne Davies

10, May, 2020 @1:58 AM

Article image
NSW Nationals meet as senior Liberal says Gladys Berejiklian 'is not bluffing' over threats
Planning minister Rob Stokes says Nationals’ actions over koala policy are not providing the ‘clarity’ Berejiklian needs during coronavirus pandemic

Anne Davies

10, Sep, 2020 @11:08 PM

Article image
Koalas still under threat in NSW despite Berejiklian's ultimatum to Nationals
The NSW Liberals now look like koala saviours – but green groups say much more is needed to save the animal from extinction in the state by 2050

Anne Davies and Lisa Cox

15, Sep, 2020 @2:52 AM

Article image
Gladys Berejiklian says she can't recall if she was at dinner where Labor claims illegal donations were made
Labor claims dinner at Club Taree raised $18,000 from four donors and gave them access to premier

Anne Davies

11, Nov, 2020 @9:04 AM

Article image
NSW election: Nationals' hold on environment policy drags down Coalition
Labor is promising to reverse the Berejiklian government’s record on renewables, land clearing and Murray-Darling management

Anne Davies

06, Mar, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Gladys Berejiklian: six pressing matters facing the new NSW premier
As the New South Wales Liberal leader takes over from Mike Baird, these are her most immediate political problems

Christopher Knaus

23, Jan, 2017 @3:21 AM

Article image
The Nationals’ victory in Upper Hunter byelection may owe more to Berejiklian and Hanson than John Barilaro | Anne Davies
More Labor voters prefer the premier than Jodi McKay, while One Nation’s spirited campaign in the NSW seat doomed Shooters, Fishers and Farmers to electoral failure

Anne Davies

23, May, 2021 @4:40 AM