Cheng Lei: detained Australian at risk of torture in China, observers say

CGTN presenter is being held in ‘residential surveillance at a designated location’, classified by the UN as a type of enforced disappearance

Australian journalist Cheng Lei is at risk of torture by Chinese authorities, human rights observers have said.

On Monday the Australian government revealed Chinese authorities had detained Cheng, a Chinese-born Australian citizen and business news anchor for CGTN, China’s English-language state media channel. The government has not been told why she has been detained, and amid deteriorating relations China’s foreign minister has not returned calls from Australian representatives for months.

Cheng was taken into “residential surveillance at a designated location” (RSDL), a form of detention that has been classified by United Nations human rights experts as a type of enforced disappearance.

The coercive custody allows the ministry of public security and the ministry of state security to circumvent ordinary criminal law processes and hold subjects in undisclosed locations without formal arrest, charge, trial, or access to a lawyer, for up to six months.

RSDLs can not use existing places of detention, so instead special purpose facilities have been constructed, sometimes repurposed guesthouses and motels are used. Inside, detainees are held in suicide-proofed rooms in effective solitary confinement.

Elaine Pearson, head of Human Rights Watch Australia, said on Tuesday RSDL was “not house arrest”, and detainees were “at risk of ill-treatment and even torture”.

Peter Dahlin, director of human rights NGO Safeguard Defenders, told the Guardian the average length of detention in RSDL was about 30 days but for high profile targets – like Cheng – it rose to about 120 days.

“The UN has classified solitary confinement – if it is during investigation stage and lasting more than two weeks – to be torture,” Dahlin said.

“Once [Cheng] breaks the 15 day [mark] she’ll technically be a torture victim. She’s not at risk of being tortured, she is technically being tortured.”

This called into question China’s obligations as a signatory to the international convention against torture, he said.

Dahlin, who was held for 23 days in 2016 and subjected to sleep deprivation, said RSDL was introduced to China’s criminal justice system in 2013, purportedly to provide for detainees with special needs or for authorities who needed special powers, but it has been almost entirely for authorities’ gain.

“When I was switched into RSDL after 24 hours in detention, I was told I have the right to ask for a lawyer but not the right to actually have one, and that I have the right to ask to speak to my family, but not the right to actually speak to them,” Dahlin said. “This is the norm not the exception.”

According to a landmark study released this week by Safeguard Defenders, which analysed Supreme Court data, about 30,000 people have been taken into RSDL between 2013 and 2019, and its use is increasing.

It remains unknown why Cheng has been targeted by authorities. All references to her have been scrubbed from CGTN’s online presence, and on Tuesday the Chinese foreign ministry declined to provide details on the case. Her Facebook posts, some which are critical of the Chinese government, remain online.

The International Federation of Journalist said Cheng’s detention was “without cause or reason [and] is deeply concerning, particularly if it means she has no access to legal support or communication with her family in Australia”.

“We urge for immediate clarification on the circumstances surrounding her detention and call for every effort to resolve the matter promptly to secure her release.”

Pete Humphrey, a China academic and former foreign correspondent who was arbitrarily detained in China in 2013-2014, said there was no precedent for Cheng’s case.

“She is a Chinese journalist with Australian citizenship. This is going to make things very complicated. Beijing will handle her roughly, as though she is one of their own, they will therefore treat her harshly. But it will also play up the Australian connection at a time when diplomatic relations are tense and it wants to bully Australia.”

The Australian government was able to see Cheng via videolink last week, foreign minister Marise Payne said on Tuesday. Payne – whose department historically favours private diplomatic entreaties in such cases - provided few details or criticisms, saying only the Cheng was “as well as can be expected”.


Helen Davidson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cheng Lei: China says Australian news anchor was arrested on national security grounds
Foreign ministry spokesman defends questioning of Australian journalists Bill Birtles and Mike Smith

Helen Davidson

08, Sep, 2020 @10:57 AM

Article image
Yang Hengjun: I am innocent and will fight to the end, Australian detained in China tells family
The writer and democracy activist has denied Chinese reports he confessed to espionage

Ben Doherty

03, Sep, 2020 @5:30 PM

Article image
‘I pray for her’: Australian broadcaster Cheng Lei no closer to release a year after being detained in China
Friends rally support from Canberra to Washington to ask Chinese government to show compassion to Lei who is separated from her children

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

12, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Revealed: 17 Australian residents believed detained in China's Uighur crackdown
Exclusive: Activists urge embassy to ‘tell us if they’re alive or dead’ amid claims of inaction by Canberra

Kate Lyons

10, Feb, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Ambassador barred from Beijing spy trial of Australian journalist Cheng Lei
Canberra protests as court verdict deferred after closed-door, one-day trial

Helen Davidson in Taipei and agencies

31, Mar, 2022 @11:55 AM

Article image
Revealed: five Australian children trapped in China amid Uighur crackdown
Children, aged between one and six, are all Australian citizens and are separated from at least one of their parents

Kate Lyons

05, Apr, 2019 @10:48 PM

Article image
Australian writer Yang Hengjun detained in China, authorities confirm
The novelist, blogger and former Chinese diplomat did not complete the second leg of his travel plans from Guangzhou to Shanghai

Lisa Martin

23, Jan, 2019 @9:09 PM

Article image
Detained, missing, close to death: the toll of reporting on Covid in China
Activists say crackdown is driven by Xi Jinping, who has ‘declared a war on independent journalism’

Helen Davidson

04, Jan, 2022 @5:30 AM

Article image
Partner of detained Australian journalist Cheng Lei hopeful of ‘compassionate and speedy resolution’
Nick Coyle said it was positive that prime minister Anthony Albanese and foreign minister Penny Wong had raised her case with their Chinese counterparts

Daniel Hurst and Katharine Murphy

28, Nov, 2022 @1:32 AM

Article image
Australian journalist Cheng Lei formally arrested in China after six months' detention
Calls renewed for humane treatment of news anchor after arrest ‘on suspicion of illegally supplying state secrets overseas’

Daniel Hurst

08, Feb, 2021 @5:36 AM