Scott Morrison rejects criticism of climate policies as MPs call for more action

PM says he is disappointed that Australia’s bushfire crisis is being ‘conflated’ with emission reduction targets

Scott Morrison has rejected criticism of the Coalition’s climate change policies amid the ongoing bushfire crisis, as a growing number of MPs privately concede that the government needs to do more to match the rising tide of concern over the issue.

As firefighters continued to battle out-of-control bushfires across four states on Friday, the prime minister said it was “disappointing” that people were conflating the ongoing fire crisis with Australia’s emission reduction targets.

“We don’t want job-destroying, economy-destroying, economy-wrecking targets and goals, which won’t change the fact that there have been bushfires or anything like that in Australia,” Morrison told Sydney radio, 2GB.

“The suggestion that there’s any one emissions reduction policy or climate policy that has contributed directly to any of these fire events is just ridiculous and the conflation of those two things, I think, has been very disappointing.”

He said the government would “continue to consider our policies carefully here”, while conceding to the ABC that the bushfire crisis had elevated the debate over the government’s stance on climate change.

“I think the public opinion on this issue, has been heightened across a whole range of factors and climate is one,” Morrison said.

“But I mean, there are a range of other things … the drought, which is not unrelated to the issues we’re talking about, but the hazard reduction and how we manage that in the future, because hazard reduction has proved to be very difficult in recent times because of the drought.”

Experts have pointed to the link between climate change and an inability to undertake more hazard reduction burning, with hotter, drier conditions and a prolonged bushfire season narrowing the window of opportunity for the practice.

When asked if a national inquiry into the fires that canvassed all issues, including climate change, could prompt a “recalibration” of the government’s climate change policies, Morrison said the government would review any recommendations arising from an inquiry.

“I’m up to discuss all of those things and there’s no hesitancy or pushback from the government to address any of those things. And I think we have to address them calmly and rationally and in proper context and perspective.”

But when pressed on whether he would revisit the vexed issue of energy policy – including the national energy guarantee that Morrison previously supported – the prime minister said that he believed the community wanted him to be “100% focused” on the response effort, rather than drawn into a policy debate.

Coalition MPs have also been asked not to engage in public discussions about the government’s climate change policies until after the current bushfire threat has passed, urging a focus on the government’s emergency response.

In a phone hook-up with government MPs on Thursday, Morrison also banned backbench MPs from doing any international media interviews, after conservative MP Craig Kelly was lambasted on UK television for denying the role of climate change.

But as the prime minister fends off criticism for the government’s climate policies, a growing number of MPs are privately conceding that more needs to be done to match the growing level of public concern about the links between climate change and Australia’s drying climate.

An update from the Bureau of Meteorology released on Thursday showed Australia recorded its hottest and driest year on record in 2019, with temperatures 1.52C above the long-term average.

MPs say that the view being pushed by Labor and the Greens that the Coalition is not doing enough has penetrated, and will be politically damaging at the next election unless Morrison charts a more ambitious course.

This would particularly be the case in inner-city seats where the issue was recognised as a key factor that won Labor votes in certain seats at the last election.

A number of MPs have already joined a cross party pro-climate action group, the Parliamentary Friends of Climate Action group, including Liberals Tim Wilson, Dave Sharma, Jason Falinski, Katie Allen, Angie Bell and Trent Zimmerman.

MPs told Guardian Australia that they believed the government needed to reposition on climate change, but recognised Morrison could not be seen to be responding in a knee-jerk fashion.

The independent MP Zali Steggall, who defeated Tony Abbott on a platform of climate change action, is hoping that some Liberals wanting stronger action will cross the floor to support her bill to establish a climate change action framework.

She is planning a public awareness campaign aimed at putting pressure on the government to allow a conscience vote on the legislation.

Labor leader Anthony Albanese said the opposition wanted to see “strong action on climate change”, but the party was still considering its position following last year’s election loss.

“We will announce our proposals based upon where we’re at closer to the election. We won’t let the government off the hook,” Albanese said.

“[But] we want the government to act immediately. We will have strong policies, but they’ll be off the basis of what the starting point is. We don’t want the starting point to be the pathetic response with no climate change policy and no energy policy that we have from this government at the moment.”

The environment minister, Sussan Ley, said the “majority view” within the Coalition party room was that climate change was an underlying factor for the fires.

“I would say government policy reflects the majority view, and government policy is very clear about acknowledging that climate change and dry sequence years are increasing the frequency and the risk and the intensity [of fires],” Ley told ABC on Friday.

She said the view of Kelly and a “minority” within the Coalition were not dictating the government’s policy approach.


Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Public support for new coalmines falls even among Coalition voters, ANU poll finds
Survey shows ‘significant and substantial’ decline in the popularity of Scott Morrison and the Coalition

Paul Karp

17, Feb, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Labor attacks government's wages record – as it happened
Anthony Albanese grills PM on wages growth being lower than forecast. Plus John Hewson says Liberals have ‘lost their roots’ on climate

Amy Remeikis

11, Sep, 2019 @8:04 AM

Article image
Essential poll: more voters disapprove of Scott Morrison and see him as arrogant
The prime minister’s handling of the bushfire crisis has seen his disapproval rating rise 9 points from 43% in December to 52%

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

13, Jan, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Morrison admits there are climate costs, but won't say what 3C heating would do to economy
Ahead of the release of its technology roadmap, the Coalition tries to ramp up pressure on Labor over its net zero emissions target

Katharine Murphy Political editor

24, Feb, 2020 @7:44 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull criticises Scott Morrison for 'downplaying' bushfire crisis
Former Australian prime minister says the PM did not act in ‘the way a prime minister would and should’

Naaman Zhou

22, Jan, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
Anthony Albanese says public wants 'practical' action on climate change – as it happened
Michael McCormack sees off Nationals leadership challenge from Barnaby Joyce, while Adam Bandt is elected Greens leader. This blog is now closed

Amy Remeikis

04, Feb, 2020 @6:14 AM

Article image
Coalition grilled on regional jobs package – as it happened
The Senate-only sitting week has started in the midst of a debate on climate change as ‘catastrophic’ blazes threaten swathes of NSW and Queensland. All the day’s events, live

Amy Remeikis

11, Nov, 2019 @5:05 AM

Article image
Greens senator says major parties are 'no better than arsonists' – as it happened
Jordon Steele-John uses energy debate to attack Labor and Coalition support of coal industry

Amy Remeikis

12, Nov, 2019 @5:58 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison says Hawaii holiday was like taking 'that extra plumbing contract' on a Friday afternoon
PM says ‘we can all make better decisions on occasions’ as he again defends government position on climate change amid catastrophic bushfires

Paul Karp

22, Dec, 2019 @11:49 PM

Article image
More voters think Australia not doing enough on climate, Guardian Essential poll shows

Sixty per cent of respondents want to see more action – compared with 51% in March

Katharine Murphy Political editor

25, Nov, 2019 @11:33 PM