'Clearly failed': Pauline Hanson blasts citizenship survey she lost 90% to 10%

Senator says foreign interference ruined results of SurveyMonkey poll

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

Pauline Hanson has complained that foreign interference ruined the results of an online survey on One Nation’s proposed changes to the citizenship test, in which 89.8% of respondents were against and 10.2% were in favour.

In February Hanson introduced a private member’s bill largely mirroring the Coalition’s failed attempt to increase the waiting time for permanent residents to become Australian citizens and increasing the English language requirements.

To help assess the bill the Senate legal and constitutional affairs legislation committee set up a SurveyMonkey online poll, giving people who provided a name and email address a yes-no vote on whether they supported it.

There was no requirement for the name or address to be genuine. It was also possible to fill out the survey multiple times.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

On Thursday the committee published the results, revealing that of the 140,646 responses received, 126,322 (89.8%) indicated the respondent did not support the bill and just 14,324 (10.2%) expressed support.

Before the poll closed on 27 April, Hanson wrote to the committee warning that some organisations – including international groups – had “campaigned heavily to promote the no vote” on social media and news websites.

Hanson highlighted the possibility of people voting multiple times and asked the committee to publish her letter “so that the people of Australia know of the efforts of certain sections of the community to interfere with the legitimate outcome of the poll and the decision of the committee”.

“I also strongly urge the committee to disregard this poll, whatever the outcome, because clearly it cannot be considered a reflection of the opinion of Australian citizens alone,” she said. “If the intention of this poll was to gauge the sentiment of the Australian public towards my citizenship reforms, it has clearly failed.”

On Thursday the committee’s chairman, the Liberal National party senator Ian MacDonald, responded to Hanson, noting that the committee had set up the poll because its inquiry into the Coalition’s original bill had been inundated with 14,000 submissions. Many of those were “form letters”, doing little more than expressing a position on the bill.

MacDonald noted that when the committee had decided to set up the poll “your office indicated its support but subsequently indicated to me that you had changed your mind”.

He defended the survey, noting that the Senate public information office had advised that “a respondent was able to complete the survey only once using a given internet browser and email address”.

The committee was “not able” to determine what proportion of respondents were foreign nationals, he said, but he accepted Hanson’s evidence that it had been posted on foreign social media. In future the committee might also ask respondents for their address, he said.

MacDonald noted Hanson’s request for the committee to “disregard the survey results and that they not be published” but said it had decided to publish them along with Hanson’s letter, for the public and committee to draw “their own conclusions about the survey”.

The committee is not due to report until 4 December.

The government proposed toughening the requirements for Australian citizenship last year. The bill attracted fierce political and public opposition, particularly over its requirement that migrants pass high-level English tests and its retrospective application of a four-year permanent residence period – up from the current one year – as a prerequisite.

It also proposed the signing of an Australian values statement by new citizens, and changing the pledge of commitment to a “pledge of allegiance”.

Hanson’s renewed amendment bill proposes raising the permanent residence requirement to eight years.


Paul Karp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pauline Hanson refers Malcolm Roberts to high court over citizenship
One Nation senator says he’ll continue voting in Senate while court considers his eligibility as Greens leader accuses him of changing his story ‘more times than I’ve changed underpants’

Gareth Hutchens

09, Aug, 2017 @8:15 AM

Article image
Looking back, and angry: what drives Pauline Hanson's voters | David Marr
In an extract from his new Quarterly Essay, David Marr finds that One Nation voters are richer, more urban and more liberal than you might expect. But they are profoundly nostalgic, display an unusual gloom and share a vehemently anti-government streak

David Marr

26, Mar, 2017 @5:00 PM

Article image
Scott Morrison won't say if Pauline Hanson is racist
Prime minister instead says Coalition has worked with One Nation leader on ‘a lot of important issues’

Amy Remeikis

22, Mar, 2019 @12:41 AM

Article image
Di Natale: Roberts's story has changed more times than I've changed underpants – as it happened
Pauline Hanson moves to refer Malcolm Roberts case to high court

Gabrielle Chan

09, Aug, 2017 @7:49 AM

Article image
Pauline Hanson damages Australia's standing in Asia, Penny Wong to warn
Shadow foreign minister warns One Nation’s ‘monocultural myth’ must be rejected, as Liberal backbencher accuses colleagues of ‘cuddling up to Hansonite rhetoric’

Katharine Murphy Political editor

07, Nov, 2016 @7:15 PM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull backs Brandis in berating Hanson for burqa stunt
Prime minister stresses that cooperation with Muslim Australians is critical to combating threat of terrorism

Katharine Murphy Political editor

18, Aug, 2017 @12:53 AM

Article image
Bill Shorten rebukes Pauline Hanson over threat to deny Labor preferences
One Nation and Labor leaders in spat over byelection in Longman, which ALP holds by 1,390 votes

Katharine Murphy Political editor

13, May, 2018 @9:05 AM

Article image
Pauline Hanson moves against Fraser Anning in bid to regain One Nation seat
Hanson will reportedly try to have the Queensland senator, who has separated from One Nation, referred to the high court over a dropped bankruptcy case

Paul Karp

21, Jan, 2018 @9:43 PM

Article image
Barnaby Joyce blasts Coalition for 'deal' with Pauline Hanson to announce $23m stadium grant
The Nationals MP has accused the government of using the Rockhampton funding to buy One Nation support on an unrelated matter

Paul Karp

11, Oct, 2020 @4:30 PM

Article image
Cory Bernardi warns One Nation will rise if migration not halved
Liberal senator, who has reiterated his support for Trump while on taxpayer-funded secondment to the UN, calls on government to ‘reconsider’ refugee intake

Paul Karp

02, Nov, 2016 @11:14 PM