The day began with the immigration minister, Peter Dutton, accusing refugees of being at once illiterate and “languishing in unemployment queues” and “taking Australian jobs” and, if you can believe it, went downhill from there.

.@PeterDutton_MP says more refugees will take Australian's jobs or languish in unemployment queues #ausvotes #pmlive

— Sky News Australia (@SkyNewsAust) May 17, 2016

His claims were made on Sky in response to the Greens’ plan to increase the humanitarian intake to 50,000 – higher than that proposed by both Labor and the Liberals. The foreign minister, Julie Bishop, was among the first of Dutton’s colleague to parse his statement for palatable pebbles, presenting a generous interpretation in the form of this “reality check”:

There’s an extraordinarily high cost in ensuring they can be a contributing member of society … What he’s pointing out is that we would want such people to have a job, we wouldn’t want them to be on welfare, we would want them in jobs.”

Julie Bishop Defends Peter Dutton's Claim That He Didn't Actually Piss Himself, No He Just Spilled A Coffee On His Pants, Really

— content enjoyer (@dannolan) May 17, 2016

Later, in far north Queensland, Malcolm Turnbull came to the defence of his “outstanding immigration minister”, repeating Dutton’s observation that “large percentages” of refugees are “illiterate in their own language” but adding that was “no fault of theirs”. On the “taking Australian jobs” point, he said, “We want them to become part of our workforce.”

And so, as in a particularly grim round of Chinese whispers, Dutton’s original statement was diluted with each repetition by his colleagues. (And to quote Louis CK: “Maybe, if someone without contacts, money, or speaking the language steals your job, you’re shit.”)

“But we all heard what Dutton said the first time,” said political editor Lenore Taylor, marking an escalation in the scare tactics at play in this campaign from “dog whistle” to “foghorn”. Here’s Guardian Australia’s fact check of Dutton’s statement.

Here’s government whip Ewen Jones demolishing Dutton’s lazy, job-stealing refugee remarks

— Mark Di Stefano (@MarkDiStef) May 18, 2016

In reality, Dutton’s own department takes an overwhelmingly positive view of refugees’ contribution to Australia, with a report it commissioned in 2011 finding plenty of reasons to do so. And new findings into the impact incomers have on host communities in Europe state similar.

Back in Sydney, Bill Shorten said Dutton’s remarks were “deeply divisive and offensive” and “comments that Pauline Hanson would have been proud to make”. And on Twitter, users were sharing their own experiences with the hashtag – at Mariam Veiszadeh’s suggestion – #soilliterate.

I'm #Soilliterate that I could take #PeterDutton 's job. #Auspol

— Mariam Veiszadeh (@MariamVeiszadeh) May 18, 2016

My grandparents were so #soilliterate they came here with nothing, worked hard, learnt the language and made their new lives in a decade

— Jacqueline Maree (@PSDontTellMum) May 18, 2016

Mirabella cut loose

The Liberal party’s Indi candidate, Sophie Mirabella, has been cut loose by the Coalition, writes Guardian Australia’s Gabrielle Chan. Senior government sources claim she has been starved of Liberal party funding, leaving her to foot the bill for her campaign with only what she can raise locally.

Adding insult to financial injury, Barnaby Joyce – deputy prime minister, Nationals leader, and “sweaty, big-gutted man from Australia” (Johnny Depp, 2015) – openly mocked Mirabella at a party event for the Nationals candidate Marty Corboy in Indi last night.

“I don’t want to talk too much about the other candidates, they can talk for themselves … What I can say is the more they talk, the better you look, Marty.”

This was a day after Mirabella accused some in the Liberal party of destabilising her campaign in an intriguing appearance on the ABC’s 7.30, in which she said, “If you want a friend in politics, get a dog.”

But don’t tell Johnny Depp that.

Greg Mirabella removes his cat from shot without breaking eye contact with the 7.30 reporter

— Freya Newman (@freyanewmn) May 17, 2016

The reporter reads Mirabella some of her bad press

— Freya Newman (@freyanewmn) May 17, 2016

'Not a happy day at camp Mirabella'

— Freya Newman (@freyanewmn) May 17, 2016

It suggests that the Coalition doesn’t fancy Mirabella’s chances against the current MP, independent MP Cathy McGowan. Corboy – who has a stock feed supply business – is also an outsider, though he’s not without optimism about his chances: “Without sounding sexist, some people are rapt to have a man to vote for.”

Perhaps conscious of this competitive advantage, Joyce suggested Corboy was a future leader within the National party. “If we start now in Indi, we know we can bed him down and the return will be great to this seat.”

Feeney not so positive on negative gearing

Negative gearing, the policy that sounds boring but is in fact of apparently endless interest to everyone, is still trucking along in the headlines.

Hey @TurnbullMalcolm should we be allowing the one year olds of illiterate job-taking refugees to access negative gearing?

— Bernard Keane (@BernardKeane) May 17, 2016

Labor frontbencher David Feeney is facing questions over his $2.3m property, which he failed to declare in his parliamentary interests register. He says the purchase of the negatively geared house in Northcote is on the public record but he neglected to register it.

“I’ve racked my mind how this omission came to be.”

Feeney – who is in a tight battle with a Greens candidate over his inner Melbourne seat of Batman – has today written to the register of members interests seeking to rectify his mistake. When first questioned on Tuesday, he didn’t know if the house was negatively geared or not.

.@Feeney4Batman has tweeted about negative gearing being a lurk for millionaires #ausvotes #Afronthetrail

— Joanna Mather (@JoannaMather) May 18, 2016

Cormann popped up again to say Feeney was hypocritical to be negative gearing a property when Labor planned to introduce a policy reining-in the practice.

“Under Labor’s policy on negative gearing, all of those Labor members of parliament that are negatively gearing existing investment properties will be able to continue to do so while they’re taking that opportunity from everybody else,” he told the ABC.

This comes after Aussie Home Loans founder, John Symond, warned that Labor’s policy could cause a recession and (it was strongly inferred) dark clouds to black out the sun and frogs to fall from the sky en masse. “All of a sudden it could be armageddon with the housing industry that’s propped up the Australian economy the last four years”. Here’s Guardian Australia’s fact check of his statement. We’re big into fact checks here, we are.

Best of Bowers

Mike Bowers joins Bill Shorten, Anthony Albanese and the member for Kingsford Smith, Matt Thistlethwaite, who toured a container freight facility in Port Botany in Sydney on Tuesday morning.
Mike Bowers joined Bill Shorten, Anthony Albanese and the member for Kingsford Smith, Matt Thistlethwaite, in a rare moment out of their high-vis gear after touring a container freight facility in Port Botany on Tuesday morning. Photograph: Mike Bowers/The Guardian

Further reading

The truth about Malcolm Turnbull’s Google tax (Sydney Morning Herald) You could be forgiven for being sceptical about Turnbull and Scott Morrison’s bid to ensure multinational companies “pay their fair share of tax in Australia”.

Could Bill Shorten win? And why is everyone so scared of the Greens? In the latest episode of Guardian Australia’s Behind the Lines podcast, David Marr discusses the Labor leader’s chances – and how this election is shaping up as a repeat of 2013. See also the extract from Marr’s revelatory new book on Shorten.

Seizing the memes of production (Overland) “The most leverage a campaign can extract from a potent or ‘dank’ meme is limited to young, internet-savvy audiences already steeped in online culture,” writes young, internet-savvy Osman Faruqi.

hey @PeterDutton_MP

— The AMWU (@theamwu) May 17, 2016

And also ...

The Sydney Morning Herald columnist Paul Sheehan has been given a redundancy package two months after he was suspended indefinitely over his false story of a woman, “Louise”, who claimed she had been raped and beaten by Arabic-speaking men.

Sheehan told Guardian Australia he was made redundant from the Fairfax newspaper he first worked for 30 years ago but he declined to clarify whether the arrangement was voluntary or forced.

Meanwhile, in the rest of the world ...

Speaking of drawn-out campaigns … Bernie Sanders’ supporters have handed him a win in the Oregon primary, adding to his run of late victories over the Democratic frontrunner, Hillary Clinton. In Kentucky, which also voted on Tuesday, the race was too close to call – though Clinton went right ahead and declared victory hours after polls closed. Here’s the Guardian US tracker.

Megyn Kelly questions Donald Trump for calling her a ‘bimbo’

In the Republican camp, Donald Trump was declared winner in Oregon over rivals Ted Cruz and John Kasich, still on the ballot after dropping out of the race earlier this month. Trump’s win was announced just after his interview with Megyn Kelly aired on Fox, ending a feud between the two that dated back to the first Republican presidential debate last August.

Trump said Kelly, one of the moderators of that debate, had treated him unfairly – perhaps, he infamously supposed, because she had “blood coming out of her wherever”. The public animosity between the two continued until their hourlong meeting at the Trump tower in April.

But Tuesday’s interview was not without confrontations as Trump pleaded ignorance over retweeting followers’ description of Kelly as a “bimbo” – and then a defence: “Over your life, Megyn, you’ve been called a lot worse.”

And if today was a pop song ...

“And though the news was rather sad, well I just had to laugh.”

There’s an ultrasonic dog whistle just audible in the last 30 seconds of A Day in the Life, inserted by John Lennon into the run-out groove at the end of Sgt Pepper. You may not be able to hear it in the YouTube clip, but “oh boy” is as good an assessment of the news today as any.

Never miss another catchup: If you’re reading this in the Guardian app, tap on “Australian election briefing” at the top or bottom of this page, then tap on ‘Follow series’ to get an app notification as soon as the Campaign catchup publishes every afternoon.


Elle Hunt

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Campaign catchup: big day for Barnaby
Election 2016: it’s never been a more exciting time to be Australia’s deputy PM/agriculture minister/biosecurity defender, writes Bridie Jabour

25, May, 2016 @6:38 AM

Article image
Guardian Australia's morning mail: refugees would 'take Australians jobs', says Peter Dutton
Today’s campaign: Coalition hits Labor hard over its asylum policy as Peta Credlin says Liberals ‘just as compassionate’ as left

Bridie Jabour

17, May, 2016 @9:50 PM

Article image
Campaign catchup: what if no one wins the election?
Election 2016: as polls remain close the question of a hung parliament comes up again – and earlier outright denials are softening

Elle Hunt

30, May, 2016 @7:33 AM

Article image
Campaign catchup: Trump effect reaches Australia
Election 2016: Donald Trump is clearly too big to be restricted to the US presidential campaign – but even he can’t outshine the ‘black hole’ debate

27, May, 2016 @7:05 AM

Article image
Today's campaign: Turnbull asked about Medicare and asylum seekers on Q&A
Election 2016: A very ill Malcolm Turnbull takes his turn the solo guest on Q&A before heading to the Northern Territory, while Bill Shorten returns to Melbourne

Helen Davidson

20, Jun, 2016 @9:28 PM

Article image
Campaign catchup: Coalition and Labor seize on shock UK vote
Election 2016: Brexit could be very scary for Australia – best vote Coalition. Or see it as sign of the importance of ‘inclusive growth’ – best vote Labor

Elle Hunt

24, Jun, 2016 @7:29 AM

Article image
Campaign catchup: Labor offers just what the doctors ordered
Election 2016: Bill Shorten vows an end to Medicare rebate freeze as Malcolm Turnbull warms up on border protection, writes Elle Hunt

19, May, 2016 @7:10 AM

Article image
Campaign day 10: Peter Dutton's comments on refugees dominate debate – as it happened
Malcolm Turnbull questioned over immigration minister’s claims ‘illiterate’ refugees are taking Australian jobs. Follow all the updates on day 10 of the campaign

Katharine Murphy and Bridie Jabour

18, May, 2016 @7:36 AM

Article image
How the slow-burn Australian election campaign felt the chill of global politics
It has seemingly been a marathon of beige – weeks of wrangling over ‘jobs and growth’ and company tax cuts v education spending. But the story of the 2016 election included echoes of bigger issues – themes tapped by Donald Trump and the pro-Brexit campaigners

Gabrielle Chan

30, Jun, 2016 @9:24 PM

Article image
Peter Dutton says detainees trying to force asylum policy change
Immigration minister accuses advocates and Greens of aiding 600 refugees and asylum seekers who refuse to leave Manus Island centre

Helen Davidson

31, Oct, 2017 @6:52 AM