Treatment of children at Don Dale prison could amount to torture, says UN

Special rapporteur Juan Mendez says public officials who covered up the acts at Darwin’s juvenile detention centre could also be guilty of torture

The treatment of Indigenous children in a Northern Territory youth prison could amount to torture under international criminal law, the United Nations special rapporteur on torture, Juan Mendez, has said.

Mendez said any public officials who covered up the treatment of children at Darwin’s Don Dale youth detention centre could also be guilty of torture as defined in the convention against torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment, which includes acts done “with the consent or acquiescence of a public official or other person acting in an official capacity”.

Speaking on the ABC’s Radio National on Thursday, Mendez said the acts shown in footage broadcast by Four Corners, which included children being thrown, stripped, assaulted, teargassed, held in solitary confinement, and hooded and tied to a “mechanical restraint” chair, “can amount to torture or to very cruel, inhumane or degrading treatment under any circumstance”.

Four Corners shows boy being stripped by Northern Territory detention staff. Source: ABC

Australia was accused of violating the international convention against torture last year for detaining children in immigration detention and holding asylum seekers in dangerous and violent conditions on Manus Island.

Mendez, who was responsible for that report, said at the time that Australia had fallen short “of its obligations under international law.”

He said the acts committed against the children at Don Dale could have made up the elements of the international crime of torture but it would be up to Australia to prosecute those involved.

Teenager hooded and restrained in Northern Territory detention. Source: ABC

“There’s no question that here there’s been an infliction of very severe pain and suffering, that the perpetrators are, or seem to be, state agents; but what we need to know is whether appropriate action was taken afterwards,” he said.

“If this information was in the possession of other state agents who didn’t do anything about it, then of course it would be an added, you know, reason to conduct a very serious inquiry and to let the chips fall where they may, and punish those who not only participated in the acts but acquiesced in them and tolerated them.”

Whether it puts Australia in violation of its international responsibilities, he said, depended on the government’s response.

Mendez said it was “encouraging” that the Australian government had moved swiftly to establish a royal commission into both the abuse and the alleged coverup of abuse.

He added, “but I also want to know what the scope of the inquiry is going to be, how far it is going to go … [what] we need to know is not only that this happened but that a proper response has happened.

“That is: has it been investigated; has everybody that participated in it, including those that may have covered it up, been appropriately punished; have reparations been offered and paid to the victims.

“All of those things that are part of Australia’s international obligations, we’re going to be looking at that.

The prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, was set to release the terms of reference for the commission after a cabinet meeting on Thursday.

He has already said the inquiry would be restricted to the Northern Territory, despite calls from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leaders, lawyers, and Gillian Triggs, president of the Australian Human Rights Commission, that the inquiry start with the events at Don Dale and be broadened to include juvenile justice centres in other states.

Labor senator for Western Australia Pat Dodson, who was one of the commissioners in the 1989-91 royal commission into Aboriginal deaths in custody, said the inquiry “should look at how systemic practices pertain across all jurisdictions”, and should also look at how children ended up in detention.

The human services minister, Alan Tudge, said it was up to other states to initiate their own inquiries if they believed they had similar issues.


Calla Wahlquist

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Activists gather at Don Dale detention centre to demand boys' release
Protesters call for release of boys featured in Four Corners report containing footage of alleged mistreatment of youths by corrections staff

Helen Davidson in Darwin

03, Aug, 2016 @2:13 PM

Article image
Northern Territory juvenile detention 'may amount to torture', says Unicef – as it happened
Chief minister takes over portfolio and PM announces royal commission after ABC airs footage of teenagers being teargassed, hooded and restrained for hours

Calla Wahlquist (earlier) and Elle Hunt (later)

26, Jul, 2016 @7:18 AM

Article image
Don Dale run like a 'human storage facility', NT royal commission told
Author of report into territory’s corrections system tells inquiry the Darwin youth detention centre is ‘basically a prison’ and not a ‘therapeutic environment’

Helen Davidson in Darwin

05, Dec, 2016 @4:01 AM

Article image
NT royal commission 'should also include children in immigration detention'
Human rights advocates say inquiry should be expanded to including ‘all children deprived of their liberty by the Australian government’

Calla Wahlquist, Katharine Murphy and Gabrielle Chan

26, Jul, 2016 @8:25 PM

Article image
After the horrific footage from Don Dale, we need to see what hasn't been shown
Police forces and prisons in Australia are imbued with structural racism and releasing video of atrocities committed against vulnerable people will help change that

Calla Wahlquist

27, Jul, 2016 @12:36 AM

Article image
'Abu Ghraib'-style images of children in detention in Australia trigger public inquiry
Australian prime minister says he is ‘deeply shocked and appalled’ by footage of teenager being hooded in a restraint chair and other apparent abuses

Helen Davidson in Darwin, Paul Karp in Canberra and Elle Hunt in Sydney

26, Jul, 2016 @8:31 AM

Article image
Nigel Scullion should be stripped of portfolio, says Bill Shorten
Opposition leader says Indigenous affairs minister’s response to Don Dale abuse shows he was ‘either asleep at the wheel or he just doesn’t get it’

Helen Davidson in Darwin

04, Aug, 2016 @9:07 AM

Article image
Appoint Indigenous commissioners to NT juvenile detention inquiry, says Shorten
Labor leader says: ‘This royal commission has to be done with Aboriginal people, not to Aboriginal people’

Paul Farrell

30, Jul, 2016 @3:12 AM

Article image
Dylan Voller could be restrained in chair again, says Northern Territory's chief minister
Exclusive: In an interview with Guardian Australia, Adam Giles says Voller is now 18 and in an adult prison, where the chair is still permitted

Helen Davidson

02, Aug, 2016 @10:22 PM

Article image
Abuse of teenage prisoners in NT detention: how Four Corners got the story
The ABC team obtained the shocking footage through ‘a combination of good fortune and relentless sleuth work’ – and the compelling TV pictures finally forced the Australian government to act

Amanda Meade

26, Jul, 2016 @9:00 AM