Jonathan Jones: Is the Sagrada Familia being banalised in the name of tourism?

Jonathan Jones: With the continuing work to complete Gaudí's religious masterpiece, has the Catalan's genius been betrayed?

Antoni Gaudí was the most modern and the most medieval of souls. The great Catalan architect, whose ecstatic, organic vision has made his buildings among the world's best-loved, saw himself as recreating a Christian society through art. What makes him so great is that his architecture expresses that longing with no regard for convention and no tyranny of tradition, and with such an enthusiasm for the techniques and fragments of modern life - the shards of mosaic on his facades, the dynamism of his interiors - that it becomes an art of energy and change even as it wishes for order. Gaudí's genius is inexhaustibly rich. But has it been betrayed?

A group of Spanish architects and art world types has savagely denounced the continuing work to complete Gaudí's religious masterpiece the Sagrada Familia. Should work on this vast church - often mistaken, with good reason, for Barcelona's cathedral – have been carried on, after his death in 1926 left it unfinished? The grumpy intellectuals say no. Gaudí, they complain, is being banalised in the name of tourism.

It's true that a lot of tourists go to the Sagrada Familia. Last time I was there, some English blokes on a stag weekend stood staring up bleary-eyed at the crazed plenitudes of the building's Victor Hugo fantasia of a facade - the section of the building that Gaudí himself brought closest to completion. It's probably not the best thing to look at with a hangover. But what is wrong with Gaudí's popularity? Nothing. He was an architect with a generous social vision and it is fitting that his works are visited. It is so rare for an architect to be truly loved that to carp at the masses who go to see Gaudí is a quite nasty form of snobbery.

But what about the specific question of the drive to finish the church? Work there has carried on, sporadically, since 1926. In other words the completion effort predates Gaudí's contemporary fame. I personally find it moving. Anyone can see that the interior is not by Gaudí and never will be: however closely based on his designs, it does not have his touch. Obviously. The collective work, however, has the poetry of an architectural spectacle more medieval than modern - the century-long effort to build a great cathedral. These critics need to read their Ruskin. Far from betraying Gaudí's spirit, the belief that the Sagrada Familia should be finished is in accord with a religious sensibility in which the architect is a worker, not a star.

Michelangelo, another great religious architect, designed the dome of St Peter's but died before he could erect it. His designs were adapted by later architects. Does this make St Peter's a botched job, a betrayal? No. We experience it for what it is - a great collective religious work in which the individual contributions of Michelangelo, Bramante, Raphael, Sangallo and Bernini are visible, yet at the same time subsumed in the common purpose.

Significantly, Michelangelo for once set aside his habitual rivalries at St Peter's and incorporated into his own contribution designs by his enemy Bramante. This was the place to work together, not against one another.

That ancient attitude to building churches - which can also be experienced at Salisbury Cathedral, or Notre Dame, or Cologne - is kept alive today by the pious effort to finish Gaudí's masterpiece. I love the emerging result, kitsch and all.


Jonathan Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Gaudí's Sagrada Familia basilica in Barcelona evacuated as arsonist strikes
Local man reportedly walked into the sacristy, sprayed it with flammable liquid and set fire to priest's robes stored there

Giles Tremlett in Madrid

19, Apr, 2011 @5:23 PM

Article image
Not so Familia: visit Antoni Gaudí’s first project – just outside Barcelona
The Nau Gaudí, 30km from Barcelona, was the first building designed by the great Catalan architect, when he was just 26. Today its elegant interior showcases contemporary art

Stephen Burgen in Barcelona

25, Nov, 2015 @11:49 AM

Article image
Barcelona's Sagrada Família: Gaudí's 'cathedral for the poor' – a history of cities in 50 buildings, day 49
Giles Fraser arrived in Barcelona not expecting to like Antoni Gaudí’s monumental creation – derided by George Orwell as ‘one of the most hideous buildings in the world’. But then he went inside ...

Giles Fraser in Barcelona

03, Jun, 2015 @6:30 AM

Article image
Gaudí’s partner in iconic Barcelona design finally gets the limelight
Josep Maria Jujol’s contribution to Gaudí’s Barcelona masterpieces, and those he created himself in Catalonia, have been overlooked. A new documentary seeks to give him the recognition he deserves

Stephen Burgen

09, Sep, 2016 @5:30 AM

Article image
Gaudí's Catalan shadow: the art of Josep Maria Jujol

Antoni Gaudí is Barcelona's most famous son but one of his collaborators, Jujol, created buildings with a lighter touch, and humour, in its surrounding villages. Richard Eilers takes a tour

Richard Eilers

03, Jun, 2013 @6:00 AM

Article image
Robert Hughes on Barcelona's uniquely Catalan architecture

Barcelona is celebrated as one of Europe's finest cultural treasures, but until recently we knew little about its heritage. Robert Hughes on how a group of architects - in particular Gaudí - created a uniquely Catalan city that combined the myths of a glorious past with progress and innovation.

Robert Hughes

10, Feb, 2007 @12:05 AM

Article image
Gaudí opening to lead Barcelona’s tourism comeback
The first house designed by the iconic architect – exuberant Casa Vicens in the beleaguered city’s Gràcia district – opens to the public later this month. ‘This could be a moment of peace,’ says its manager

Steve Tallantyre

03, Nov, 2017 @1:35 PM

Article image
Work in progress: Sagrada Familia
Take a tour of one of the world's most famous unfinished masterpieces: Antoni Gaudí's dazzling Sagrada Familia

14, Aug, 2008 @1:23 PM

Article image
Top 10 free things to do in Barcelona
From Gaudí and Picasso to street parties and outdoor movies, we pick the best attractions and local haunts to help you enjoy Barcelona for free

Marta Bausells

17, Jun, 2014 @5:00 AM

Smash hits

Gaudi's broken tiles stunned visitors to Barcelona at the turn of the last century, and still inspire 100 years on.

Tamsin Blanchard

05, Aug, 2001 @5:20 PM