'We are all Edward Hopper paintings now': is he the artist of the coronavirus age?

With his deserted cityscapes and isolated figures, the US painter captured the loneliness and alienation of modern life. But the pandemic has given his work a terrifying new significance

Who can fail to have been moved by all the images of people on their doorsteps clapping for the NHS last night? They filled TV screens and news websites, presenting a warming picture of solidarity in enforced solitude – all alone yet all together. But there are some far less reassuring images circulating on social media. Some people are saying we now all exist inside an Edward Hopper painting. It doesn’t seem to matter which one.

I assume this is because we are coldly distanced from each other, sitting at our lonely windows overlooking an eerily empty city, like the woman perched on her bed in Morning Sun, or the other looking out of a bay window in Cape Cod Morning.

“We are all Edward Hopper paintings now,” according to a WhatsApp compilation of Hopper scenes: a woman alone in a deserted cinema, a man bereft in his modern apartment, a lonely shop worker and people sitting far apart at tables for one in a diner. As is the way with memes, it’s hard to tell if this is a serious comment or a glib joke with a side order of self-pity.

Edward Hopper, Nighthawks, painting, 1942
Coldly distanced … Edward Hopper’s Nighthawks, 1942. Photograph: Alamy

But let’s take it seriously. If we really are all Edward Hopper paintings now, a crisis of loneliness is impending that may be one of the most fraught social consequences of Covid-19. The loss of direct human contact we’re agreeing to may be catastrophic. This, at least, is what Hopper shows us. This painter born in New York state in 1882 made solitude his life’s work. In the 1920s, while F Scott Fitzgerald was chronicling the party animals of the jazz age, he painted people who looked as if they had never been invited to a party in their lives.

Modern life is unfriendly in the extreme for Hopper. It doesn’t take a pandemic to isolate his poor souls. Cold plate-glass windows, towering urban buildings where everyone lives in self-contained apartments, gas stations in the middle of nowhere – the fabric of modern cities and landscapes is for him a machine that churns out solitude. Nor do his people find much to do with themselves.

In older art, being alone has its benefits. In paintings titled Saint Jerome in His Study, a scholarly hermit looks perfectly at ease in his well-designed home office with his books, his cool desk – and his pet lion. In another way, the Romantic out for a walk in Caspar David Friedrich’s painting The Wanderer Above the Sea of Fog actively seeks splendid isolation so he can absorb sublime nature without human disturbance. He’s happy by himself – terrifyingly so.

Edward Hopper - Morning Sun, painting, 1952
Atomised individuals … Edward Hopper’s Morning Sun, 1952. Photograph: Alamy

But it’s not such images of contented or chosen solitude that are being shared today. It’s Hopper’s horrors – and that isn’t too strong a word. One of the painter’s biggest fans was Alfred Hitchcock, who famously based the Bates mansion in Psycho on a Hopper painting of a strange old house isolated by a railroad.

We all hope to defy Hopper’s terrifying vision of alienated, atomised individuals and instead survive as a community. But, ironically, we have to do that by staying apart and it may be cruelly dishonest – the empty propaganda of the virus war – to pretend everyone is perfectly OK at home.

For the message of Hopper is that modern life can be very lonely. His people are as isolated among others in a diner or restaurant as they are at their apartment windows. In this he is typical of modernist art. Edvard Munch had already shown in his nightmarish Evening on Karl Johan Street that a crowd can be a very isolating place to be.

Today, we’re simply better at hiding the isolation that these artists thought defined the modern condition. In normal times, we sit alone in cafes, too, except we’ve now got mobile phones to make us feel social. The fact is that modernity throws masses of people into urban lifestyles that are totally cut off from the gregariousness that was once the norm.

Edvard Munch, Evening on Karl Johan Street, painting, 1892
Lonely in a crowd … Edvard Munch’s Evening on Karl Johan Street, 1892.
Photograph: Alamy

In pre-industrial times, Bruegel’s scenes of peasant life show a world in which it was practically impossible to be alone. Kitchens are crammed and carnivals a nightmare for anyone practising physical distancing. Looking at Bruegel, you can see why many people in Britain were so reluctant to give up pubs – those last refuges of the Bruegelian past.

We choose modern loneliness because we want to be free. But now the art of Hopper poses a tough question: when the freedoms of modern life are removed, what’s left but loneliness?


Jonathan Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
From the archive: a major Edward Hopper retrospective in London, 1981
Fourteen years after the painter passed away, William Feaver assessed his lonely legacy. By Chris Hall

Chris Hall

12, Sep, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Lydia Towsey: how I discovered the Venus in me
From Botticelli to glossy magazines, women have been idealised and misrepresented for centuries. Performance poet Lydia Towsey reveals how her own near-fatal eating disorder set her on a path to explore new ways of looking at female bodies

Lydia Towsey

30, Aug, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
How art helped me see the beauty in loneliness
Olivia Laing’s The Lonely City explores the connection between isolation and creativity. Here she examines its role in the work of Edward Hopper and others

Olivia Laing

28, Feb, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Artist of ‘loneliness’ Edward Hopper depended on his wife, says film-maker
Role of Josephine Nivison Hopper in US realist’s work has been overlooked, says director of forthcoming documentary about them

Harriet Sherwood Arts and culture correspondent

07, Oct, 2022 @11:29 AM

Article image
The 10 best holiday paintings
The Observer's art critic, Laura Cumming, chooses her 10 favourites, from Matisse to Hopper

Laura Cumming

11, Jul, 2014 @11:00 AM

Article image
Peter Duggan's Artoon – Edward Hopper and Mark Rothko

In Peter Duggan's redrawing of art history, an art class one Early Sunday Morning sees a young Edward Hopper inspired by shadows, but could a young Mark Rothko's vision be slightly blurred?

01, Feb, 2012 @1:57 PM

Article image
America’s Cool Modernism: O’Keeffe to Hopper review – a whole new story
From monumental skyscrapers to lonely grain silos, the jazz age to the Depression, these brooding American masterpieces are a revelation

Laura Cumming

01, Apr, 2018 @7:00 AM

Article image
Dark arts: how night inspires great painters
Whether it’s the night terrors of Edvard Munch or the shadowy holy light of Dutch nativity scenes, northern European artists have long found their voice in the dark

Jonathan Jones

27, Sep, 2016 @12:17 PM

Article image
Fictional portrait of Jo and Edward Hopper wins Walter Scott prize
£25,000 award for the year’s best historical novel goes to Christine Dwyer Hickey’s The Narrow Land, which depicts the artists’ marriage

Alison Flood

12, Jun, 2020 @6:45 PM

Article image
'I love staring at one spot for six hours!' Life models on the secrets of disrobing
What sort of person would stand naked and still for hours, often in agony? Nude models talk about how tough yet life-changing the work can be, even when posing for hen parties

Tim Jonze

14, Aug, 2019 @5:00 AM