The Queen's found a Caravaggio in her loft! Masterpieces from Buckingham Palace – review

Queen’s Gallery, London
There’s an entire wall of Rembrandts, as well as magnificent works by Vermeer and Rubens. But these treasures should be on show to everyone all the time – not shut off in the palace

Some of the greatest paintings in Britain – and I mean works by the likes of Rembrandt, Vermeer and Rubens – all hang in a single room, namely the Picture Gallery of Buckingham Palace. It must be quite something to visit, the kind of royal sanctum many of us only see via The Crown on Netflix. Except we don’t – because, obviously, they weren’t allowed to film there. (Everyone notices their own clangers on the show: I stopped watching when Anthony Blunt, surveyor of the Queen’s pictures and a Soviet spy, explained art – and this collection – to HM using the term “early modern”. This old school art snob would no more have said “early modern” than he’d have said “taken to Twitter”. He’d have said “renaissance” or “baroque”.)

The Picture Gallery is having works done so its paintings are being shown at the Queen’s Gallery next door. So here they are, those early modern masterpieces, in a stunning revelation of the Royal Collection’s finest canvases. There is an entire wall of Rembrandts, each astonishing, some rarely seen out and about. I’ve never before looked into the eyes of Rembrandt’s rabbi. Always curious about his Jewish neighbours when he lived on Amsterdam’s Breestraat, the artist homes in on an old scholar’s anxious expression.

In another painting, overflowing with life, he depicts Jan Rijcksen, a shipbuilder, and his wife, Griet Jans. He is turning from his desk, where he’s studying ship designs, as she lunges in with a message. They’re consciously posing, playing themselves in a little drama of their lives together. Griet seems about to burst out laughing. But far from undermining the seriousness of the painting, this overt self-consciousness adds to its reality and depth by making us part of the game, and therefore part of a conversation with these people.

Consciously posing … Rembrandt’s Portrait of Jan Rijcksen and his Wife, Griet Jans, 1633.
Consciously posing … Rembrandt’s Portrait of Jan Rijcksen and his Wife, Griet Jans, 1633. Photograph: Royal Collection Trust / © Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II 2020

The most imposing of all is his portrait of Agatha Bas. This long-dead woman moves towards you, her gilded fan seeming to escape the canvas over a painted frame, her pale gaze formidable. If the Queen is ever in her Picture Gallery alone at night, I’ll bet this revenant spooks her. It spooked me.

The Rembrandts alone would make this an unmissable event. But he has rivals. It’s hard to be sure about Anthony van Dyck. Was he a great artist or just a very talented one? Here’s the answer. Right by the Rembrandts hangs his portrait of Thomas Killigrew, flaccidly resting his head on his hand beside a broken column as he slumps in grief. He’d recently lost his wife. A friend – thought to be William, Lord Crofts – is gently trying to distract him with work. The emotional punch and plain truth of this painting proves Van Dyck’s mettle. Then again, it is his very greatest work.

If portraits are not your thing, try Vermeer’s surreal frozen cinema. Light and shadow form an immense wall in the left part of A Lady at the Virginals with a Gentleman, which was formerly called The Music Lesson. She stands at her baroque keyboard, with her back to us, face caught in a high mirror along with other objects in the room. A man gazes intently at her but probably not to supervise her playing. Colour seems to immerse and embrace them, as if the big room they’re in were a bath of luminescent fluid.

Embraced by colour … Johannes Vermeer’s A Lady at the Virginals with a Gentleman, early 1660s.
Embraced by colour … Johannes Vermeer’s A Lady at the Virginals with a Gentleman, early 1660s. Photograph: Royal Collection Trust / © Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II 2020

It goes on. Rubens, like Van Dyck, knew and worked for the greatest British royal art collector, Charles I. His Milkmaids with Cattle in a Landscape glistens as if painted yesterday, bulges with roly-poly life as Rubens tries to distil all the forces and freedom of nature into a carnival of breezy colour. The same appetite for life spills out of his Portrait of a Woman, whose bulging bosom is swathed in translucent lace that rises up to form her ruff collar. It’s either an insight into baroque fashion or Rubens’s personal fetish. What stops you, though, is the creamy iridescent colour.

One of the strengths of rambling old art collections is that they can hold onto forgotten works that later get recognised as masterpieces. There’s a terrific painting here by Paulus Potter of cows: their knobbly bodies, in a Dutch meadow, are like tree roots or turds. The Royal Collection has lent Artemisia Gentileschi’s Self-Portrait as the Allegory of Painting to her sensational National Gallery show – she painted it for Charles I – and the Queen even found a Caravaggio up in the loft a while ago.

So I say this with respect for the Royal Collection’s virtues: this exhibition is disastrously brilliant. While I’m grateful that some of the royal family’s treasures are being revealed for a limited time, I object to them then going back to being decorations for state visits, royal audiences and part of the tourist spectacle of the annual summer opening. The universality of this magnificent art should not serve as a prop in the royal pageant. It’s hard to believe the 21st-century monarchy really depends on owning all these Rembrandts.

• At Queen’s Gallery, London, from 4 December to 31 January 2022.

• This article was amended on 3 December 2020 to make it clear that these paintings can be seen in the annual summer opening of Buckingham Palace.


Jonathan Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Buckingham Palace art collection to go on gallery display for the first time
Masterpieces by Rembrandt, Van Dyck and Canaletto to be shown at Queen’s Gallery while palace is renovated

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

16, Aug, 2020 @1:43 PM

Article image
Revealed: the unseen flip-sides of the world's most famous paintings
From the Mona Lisa to Van Gogh’s Starry Night, Brazilian artist Vik Muniz has exposed – literally – the nuts and bolts of centuries-old masterpieces

Senay Boztas

16, Jun, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Highlights from the Victoria & Albert: Art & Love exhibition at Buckingham Palace

A new exhibition at the Queen's Gallery, Buckingham Palace, explores the unique partnership of Queen Victoria and Prince Albert through their passion for arts

17, Mar, 2010 @12:15 PM

Article image
Pearl of a museum: Vermeer shines among Dutch icons in new Mauritshuis

A dramatic yet tasteful refurbishment allows The Hague's fine collection of golden age Dutch art to seduce and intrigue, writes Jonathan Jones

Jonathan Jones in The Hague

20, Jun, 2014 @3:23 PM

Article image
Charles I: King and Collector review – majestic collection fit for an unfit king
This blockbuster show is chock-full of masterpieces. So why is our critic calling for revolution?

Jonathan Jones

22, Jan, 2018 @6:01 PM

Article image
Playful portraits and the Queen's Rembrandts on show – the week in art
Lynette Yiadom-Boakye’s fictitious portraiture is at Tate Britain, Buckingham Palace offers up a post-lockdown assortment of royal art and Jennifer Packer explores race in the US

Jonathan Jones

27, Nov, 2020 @2:00 PM

Article image
Queen's coronation takes centre stage in Buckingham Palace's summer show
Monarch's coronation robe will be laid out for first time since June 1953, along with personal objects including her coronation service

Maev Kennedy

25, Jul, 2013 @11:01 PM

Article image
Buckingham Palace to move 10,000 artworks during refurbishment
Aides seeking storage for items to be removed from east wing as part of 10-year project

Caroline Davies

27, Jun, 2018 @11:01 PM

Article image
Art of diplomacy: 300 years of Japanese art in Britain’s royal collection
A Queen’s Gallery exhibition tells the story of centuries of artistic and cultural exchange between east and west

Nicholas Wroe

07, Apr, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Mauritshuis review – 'the ideal museum, a home from home for art'

The Hague gallery's refurbishment sheds a perfectly balanced new light on its rich collection of Dutch masters, writes Laura Cumming

Laura Cumming

28, Jun, 2014 @11:01 PM