A powerful moment for the Archibald prize: could a portrait of a black woman win? | Shantel Wetherall

Only 15 paintings of women and three of non-white Australians have been Archibald winners in 97 years

The sensation of being alien has been with me as long as I can remember. I think it’s common to many descendants of displaced people. After 10 years in Australia, I’m a citizen but I’m still a settler on someone else’s country. But this was the work of an altogether different power, as subtle as it is violent, and a feeling that is distinctly Australian, integral to a culture built on “not noticing”.

One afternoon while enjoying an exhibition at the Art Gallery of New South Wales, I simply ceased to exist. The Archibald prize claims to feature “a who’s who of Australian culture”. But the finalists for the Archibald portrait prize are a window into how the cultural establishment imagines Australian aspiration and identity. It’s one of Australia’s most prestigious art awards, with $100,000 at stake and the power to transform “outsiders into insiders”. Curious, then, that no representation of a black woman – in many ways, the ultimate outsider – has ever won the prize.

In 97 years, only 15 paintings of women and three of non-white Australians have been winners. Last year, the only trace of us among the finalists was Angela Tiatia’s ethereal self-portrait, itself a powerful exploration of the way more than 60 millennia of women have been rendered as “passive objects” or “exotic others” by the eye of European art. So where are the black women we know in the imagination of Australian culture? I hope this year’s Archibald might conjure up a more satisfying answer.

The global history of art and conventions of portraiture have been dominated by the white male gaze. Black women have been limited to a handful of roles or erased altogether. If our cultural institutions want to forget about black women, perhaps it’s because, as Nora Chipaumire argues, the black female body is “always potentially disruptive”. We are erased to hide the memory of colonialism, its history and its economics. Or shown in ways that demonstrate our inferiority, as servants, as specimens, as sex objects. At the same time “exploitation and abuse have become part of black women’s shared memory and history”.

The way art has been an instrument of colonialism is well documented. However, the global conversation about the connection between culture and violence is changing.

Eighteen months of the #MeToo movement has clearly demonstrated the link between a lack of inclusion and abuse. We’re now undeniably aware of what can happen in boys’ clubs and that we’re complicit if we allow them to persist. #MeToo popularised a discussion about the metrics of structural change – who could have explained an “equity rider” before 2018? None of it is new information but now it’s circulating on an unprecedented scale. The straight white man as de facto representative is just not a good look anymore. The question isn’t “can you be more inclusive?” but “why aren’t you?” Can any publicly funded institution still expect the status quo to continue unchecked?

We didn’t see an equal number of works by women among the Archibald finalists until 2016, and their sitters were still overwhelmingly male. But we’ve got even further to go on race. The recent exhibitions haven’t represented an Australia of the past so much as one that’s never existed.

Thankfully, there are signs that things are beginning to change globally. I can see it in Tiatia’s work, in the disruptive work of Australian artist Boneta-Marie Mabo and her portraits that examine who represents Indigenous women and how. I can see it in American artist Kara Walker’s challenges to the abuse and injustice she sees in the world, rather than replicating it in her art. This feels like progress. As does Amy Sherald’s 2018 portrait of Michelle Obama. Obama wears a brightly patterned dress, reminiscent of quilts sewn by generations of African American mothers during and after slavery. Introducing the idea of “black women’s self-making” and referencing folk art, in stark contrast to the “elitist tradition of portraiture”. Sherald was the first African American woman to receive such a commission – an intentional choice by Obama. “I know the impact that will have on their lives because I was one of those girls,” she said.

It’s time that the many awe-inspiring black women in Australia were included in this reckoning of who’s who. The announcement that Brook Andrew will curate the 2020 Biennale of Sydney was exciting, as was seeing that the Art Gallery of New South Wales introduce an Indigenous advisory board in 2017. Speaking to past finalist and current sitter Tony Albert was equally encouraging. While there’s still room for improvement, he was happy to confirm that there is a noticeable drive for inclusion.

Change can only happen if artists can feel hopeful enough to take part, and it’s been wonderful to see some of the diverse artists and the portraits they’ve entered: Blak Douglas’s vivid painting of Aunty Esme Timbery. Laura Jones’s portrait of her friend Nakkiah Lui. Kim Leutwyler’s bold yet vulnerable image of Faustina Agolley, and 1996 winner Wendy Sharpe’s portrait of Megan Wilding as Blackie Blackie Brown. It feels like a positive trend.

Perhaps this can be the beginning of a snowball, like Gloria Petyarre’s 1999 victory in the Wynne prize that arguably led to record numbers of Indigenous participants. The artists are showing up, I hope the trustees will too. This could be a powerful moment for Australian art. An opportunity for culture to lead an act of shared remembering, waking up to see how white Australia’s past, present and future includes black women.

Contributor

Shantel Wetherall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
'Unblushing give-it-a-go-to-get-a-go bravura': who will win the Archibald? | Andrew Frost
The selection of some finalists seems so obvious as to be verging on parody but there are a few genuinely good portraits

Andrew Frost

03, May, 2019 @3:19 AM

Article image
Archibald prize 2020: Angus McDonald's portrait of Behrouz Boochani wins people's choice award
Portrait depicting ‘strong, confident and peaceful’ Kurdish-Iranian writer and refugee, who spent six years in detention, wins public vote

Guardian staff

16, Dec, 2020 @12:17 AM

Article image
Archibald prize 2023: Noni Hazlehurst portrait wins people’s choice award
Jaq Grantford’s portrait of the beloved actor and former Play School presenter wins $5,000 prize decided by the public

Kelly Burke

09, Aug, 2023 @1:23 AM

Article image
Doug Moran prize 2019: mysterious artist 'What' wins $150,000 for Robert Forster portrait
The artist’s portrait of the Go-Betweens frontman embodies ‘the endless possibilities of portraiture and painting’, say judges

Stephanie Convery

29, Oct, 2019 @11:56 PM

Article image
Archibald prize 2016 review – a typically debatable portrait beats some very worthy work
Louise Hearman’s looming half-figure of Barry Humphries may have scooped the prize, but in a just alternate universe, Nick Stathopoulos’s portrait of Deng Thiak Adut or Marc Etherington’s painting of Ken Done would have been rewarded

Andrew Frost

15, Jul, 2016 @8:07 AM

Article image
Former armed robber Nigel Milsom wins Archibald prize with portrait of his lawyer
The Newcastle-based artist wins $100,000 art prize for his painting of Charles Waterstreet, the inspiration behind hit ABC legal series, Rake

Nancy Groves

17, Jul, 2015 @9:15 AM

Article image
Archibald prize 2022: the small Sydney studio breaking big ground
Studio A has become a leading centre for artists with intellectual disability – and with four works up for the portrait prize, they’re getting the recognition they deserve

Kelly Burke

12, May, 2022 @12:30 AM

Article image
Painted with coffee and toothbrushes: Kurdish refugees enter the Archibald prize
Mostafa Azimitabar and Farhad Bandesh spent eight years in detention after fleeing war-torn homelands. Now they are vying for a $100,000 prize

Kelly Burke

31, Mar, 2022 @4:20 AM

Article image
Archibald prize 2015 review – three worthy winners from an eclectic mix
Nigel Milsom’s portrait of Charles Waterstreet is easily the most commanding picture in the Archibald, while Natasha Bieniek’s Biophilia is a Wynne gem and Jason Phu’s Sulman-winning ink and paper work both gentle and funny

Andrew Frost

17, Jul, 2015 @9:16 AM

Article image
Craig Ruddy, Archibald prize-winning painter, dies at 53 from Covid complications
Ruddy was best known for his paintings of leading Indigenous Australian figures including David Gulpilil, Bruce Pascoe and Cathy Freeman

Guardian staff

05, Jan, 2022 @10:20 AM