Beyoncé meets Botticelli: how tabloid photos throw new light on old masters

The Twitter account Tabloid Art History juxtaposes celebrity shots with artworks they resemble. It’s a game that works because great art is universal

Beyoncé poses with her twin babies. She is bedecked in flowers as she gazes emotionally into the heavenly distance. Do you spot the artistic echo? The creators of a Twitter account called TabloidArtHistory did. They juxtapose this photo with Botticelli’s Renaissance masterpiece Madonna of the Pomegranate. It is a beguiling match. Beyoncé’s maternal ecstasy mirrors Botticelli’s mystically beautiful Virgin Mary.

Melania Trump presenting Michelle Obama with a gift alongside the manuscript illumination of Christine de Pisan and Queen Isabeau.
Melania Trump presenting Michelle Obama with a gift alongside the manuscript illumination of Christine de Pizan and Queen Isabeau. Composite: ABC Screengrab/Alamy

Tabloid Art History delights in hilarious yet visually convincing collisions of high art and celebrity culture. Melania Trump giving Michelle Obama a gift is compared with a manuscript illumination of Christine de Pizan presenting her book The City of Women to Queen Isabeau and Géricault’s Romantic vision of despair, The Raft of the Medusa, is matched with a pic of The Real Housewives of New York slumped on the floor at an airport.

Harry Styles and Egon Schiele’s Self-Portrait with Physalis, 1912.
Harry Styles and Egon Schiele’s Self-Portrait with Physalis, 1912. Composite: Rex/Alamy

Is this a lazy reduction of great works of art to the status of memes to snigger at? No, it’s a fresh and insightful way to look at art – and at life. We’re surrounded by great art all the time, these iconographic couplings reveal. Everyone is a statue or a painting, just waiting to be recognised. Harry Styles looks like an Egon Schiele self-portrait in a certain light. When Tyra Banks cupped her breasts to give contestants on America’s Next Top Model some career advice, she suddenly resembled Mary Magdalene in an altarpiece by Jan Polack.

Zendaya and Albert Lynch’s Jeanne D’Arc engraving, 1903
Zendaya and Albert Lynch’s Jeanne D’Arc engraving, 1903 Composite: Getty

This game works because great art is universal. The gestures and expressions that artists such as Botticelli and Schiele saw in the world around them and distilled into sombre monumental images amount to a gallery of human possibility, a museum of moods, experiences and fates. All human life is in their masterpieces. So why is it surprising that Beyoncé looks for a moment like a Botticelli? He painted the way he did because he observed the street life around him with insight and truth. It’s no wonder today’s tabloid images and selfies occasionally throw up images of the same human truths.

Janelle Monáe and a detail from The Virgin of Deliverance, by Auguste-Antoine-Ernest Hébert.
Janelle Monáe and a detail from The Virgin of Deliverance, by Auguste-Antoine-Ernest Hébert. Composite: Getty

The creators of TabloidArtHistory – graduates Elise Bell, Chloe Esslemont and Mayanne Soret – have hit on the democratising magic that often eludes curators of old-master art collections. By presenting art with humour and humanity, they have unlocked the marble prison that can make it seem remote.

The sweet melancholy dreaminess of Botticelli’s Madonna of the Pomegranate is relevant to all people in all times. If we need to see it next to a photograph of Beyoncé to recognise that – all power to the memes.

Contributor

Jonathan Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Beyoncé and Jay Z – the Sybil and Basil Fawlty of pop
Music’s most powerful couple act more like the warring Torquay hoteliers with every passing year

Marina Hyde

05, May, 2016 @5:24 PM

Article image
Beyoncé has mastered this celebrity age as creator of worlds, sayer of nothing
In this era in which stars keep tight control of their publicity, Beyoncé’s offer to answer fans questions was refreshing – if the answers were ... not always clear-cut

Joel Golby

12, Dec, 2019 @4:38 PM

Article image
From Bowie to Beyoncé: what the stars can teach us about travelling in style
Mia Farrow opted for a kaftan while Marilyn Monroe went for high heels. What can vintage celebrity fashion tell us about cool, comfortable travel?

Leah Harper, Scarlett Conlon and Ellie Violet Bramley

14, Aug, 2019 @11:00 AM

Article image
Zip it, Kim Kardashian – Taylor Swift is the Marmite we're all coming to love
It’s true the singer isn’t everyone’s favourite, but the online pasting she’s been subjected to leaves a very nasty taste in the mouth

Joel Golby

26, Mar, 2020 @4:25 PM

Article image
Marina Hyde: Will the real Beyoncé please stand up

Marina Hyde: To south-eastern Germany, or 'Austria' as some would have it, and a fog of rumour concerning Ms Beyoncé Knowles

Marina Hyde

30, Apr, 2009 @11:01 PM

Article image
Rhik Samadder tries … mindful painting: ‘It dawns on me that I’m a very talented artist’
Keen to unlock your inner creativity? De-stress and unwind? Or merely improve the quality of the gifts you make for friends? Step right this way

Rhik Samadder

02, Aug, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
What’s it like to be called Beyoncé?
An interview with Beyoncé’s teenage namesake has gone viral as other celebrity name doubles like Kelly Rowland, Kaity Perry and Bridgett Jones sympathised with her on photography site Humans of New York

Laura Abernethy

06, Apr, 2015 @4:56 PM

Article image
Beyoncé and Lupe Fiasco: your inauguration-scandal roundup
The singer's alleged lip-synching has raised some eyebrows – but it's pretty small beer compared to the Fiasco, er, fiasco

Alexis Petridis

24, Jan, 2013 @5:07 PM

Beyoncé and Joe McElderry: that duet in full
Witness the moment the singer got together with X Factor's Joe McElderry – if only for a brief, but beautiful, moment

Peter Robinson

16, May, 2013 @5:01 PM

Article image
The Anti-Beyoncé Protest Rally – who's racist now?
The singer’s halftime Super Bowl performance in support of #BlackLivesMatter may cause angry activists to descend on the NFL’s HQ

Marina Hyde

12, Feb, 2016 @7:00 AM