Unfinished ... Works from the Courtauld Gallery review

Bourgeois taste celebrates ‘finished’ art but as this exhibition shows, real poetry lies in a hesitant line, roughly splashed colour and patches of bare canvas

The greatest works of art in the world are unfinished. This is not a provocation. Leonardo da Vinci’s dreamlike, infinitely suggestive sketch of a painting The Adoration of the Magi, Michelangelo’s tortured Prisoners struggling to attain human form from blocks of rough-hewn marble, Cézanne’s fragmentary, unending studies of Mount Sainte-Victoire – for me these unfinished masterpieces literally are the definition of artistic greatness.

Bourgeois taste, in the 19th century and even today, means by contrast a dull admiration for the finished. Glossy paint and spanking enamel. The neatly finished paintings of the Pre-Raphaelites gleam boringly in their frames. Damien Hirst’s dots are drearily perfect. Often, real poetry in art belongs to the hesitant line, to roughly splashed colours and patches of bare canvas.

Au Bal - Marguerite de Conflans en Toilette de Bal, 1870-80, by Edouard Manet
The unfinished as erotic daydream ... Au Bal - Marguerite de Conflans en Toilette de Bal, 1870-80, by Edouard Manet. Photograph: The Courtauld Gallery

When artists like Cézanne, Monet and Degas started leaving their paintings in an ambiguous and aleatory state in the late 19th century the bourgeoisie were shocked. Where were the immaculately detailed meadows full of identifiable flowers, the clinically exact nudes and historically accurate costumes they had come to expect?

The Courtauld Gallery’s summer exhibition, Unfinished ..., takes us back to that moment – and then back a lot further. The Courtauld has one of the world’s great collections of French modern art and here it shows off its raw, tentative refusal of what 19th-century critics actually praised as “finish”. Manet delivers a loose, louche daub of a woman seen at a ball – the unfinished as erotic daydream. Degas too glimpses a woman briefly, sketching her, then breaking off. Cézanne meanwhile is in the country, in about 1905, touching his canvas with blues and browns, the shimmer of the day, then leaving much of it bare.

Revolutionary stuff. But this disorder was not as new as it seemed. In the Renaissance, too, the unfinished was recognised as poetic, soulful, and perhaps the badge of true artistic genius. Leonardo da Vinci was legendary in his own lifetime for never finishing paintings – it won him respect, for it showed he was making art for himself instead of to please the church. In 1502 people queued up in the streets of Florence to see an unfinished picture by him.

The Courtauld’s exhibition has fascinating examples of unfinished Renaissance works that were carefully preserved and treasured as pieces of fugitive genius. Piero del Vaga’s Holy Family with Saint John the Baptist (1528-37) only has two “finished” figures, Jesus and John. Mary and Joseph are drawings suspended in varnish, delicate spectres of Leonardesque mystery. Palma Vecchio’s Venus in a Landscape (about 1520) sets a finished image of a nude woman against a grandly unfinished landscape that is all blocks of impressionistic colour.

Why is the unfinished such a powerful thing in art? The answer is in our minds. A brightly complete work of art leaves nothing for our brains to do. Unfinished art on the other hand provokes the imagination. It invites the onlooker to collaborate with it. Our relationship with the artist is suddenly much more intimate – Michelangelo’s chisel marks left on his incomplete statues are breathtakingly personal.

Lady with a Parasol, 1870-72, by Edgar Degas
Just a glimpse... Lady with a Parasol, 1870-72, by Edgar Degas. Photograph: The Courtauld Gallery

That mysterious connection between incompleteness and greatness in art is mesmerisingly revealed here in Rembrandt’s little print study of himself at work, drawing a nude model. He and the model are sketched in the slightest of lines against a background of firm yet shadowy detail. The extremes of light and darkness, precision and unfinished openness are confounding. Less is more, and it is genius.

Unfinished ... Works from the Courtauld Gallery, 18 June–20 September 2015

Contributor

Jonathan Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Encounter: Drawings from Leonardo to Rembrandt review – so where are they all then?
While Holbein’s portraits are electrifying, this show’s title is something of an overstatement. Couldn’t they have managed more than one apiece?

Jonathan Jones

12, Jul, 2017 @5:10 PM

Article image
Top 20 art exhibitions of 2019
Egypt’s golden boy and Bridget Riley’s dazzling arcs of colour join a towering indictment of empire – this year’s stunning art shows hit like a bomb

Adrian Searle and Jonathan Jones

15, Dec, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Eye-boggling Bridget Riley and black British pioneers – the week in art
Keith Haring’s first major UK exhibition opens in Liverpool, Leonardo da Vinci visits the British Library and op-art invades Edinburgh – all in your weekly dispatch

Jonathan Jones

14, Jun, 2019 @2:23 PM

Article image
More than Mona Lisa: Louvre's Leonardo da Vinci is a blockbuster with brains
From a windmill-punk helicopter to a VR Mona Lisa that the artist himself would have loved, this show blows away his old-master reputation to present a relentlessly modern mind

Jonathan Jones

21, Oct, 2019 @2:23 PM

Article image
Kathy Acker's astonishing vision and Bacon bares all – the week in art
The ICA illuminates Acker’s words with some terrific art and Modern One in Edinburgh celebrates Francis Bacon’s images of blood and guts in 1950s Soho

Jonathan Jones

03, May, 2019 @1:00 PM

Article image
Leonardo da Vinci: A Life in Drawing review – lines of beauty
This superb show of Leonardo’s drawings reveals the craftsman alongside the visionary – and the sheer range of his curiosity

Laura Cumming

26, May, 2019 @6:59 AM

Article image
Revealed: the scientific principles behind Dalí’s surrealist eccentricity
Unpublished drawings show a scrupulous painter inspired by the precise mathematical ratios of the Renaissance masters

Dalya Alberge

21, Feb, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Biggest ever Leonardo da Vinci exhibition to open in Paris
Louvre will host works of Italian artist after long-running political spats and legal battles

Angelique Chrisafis in Paris

19, Oct, 2019 @4:00 AM

Article image
Leonardo's thumbprint stars in anniversary display of drawings
Drawing from royal collection to go on show in Cardiff to mark 500 years since his death

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

28, Jan, 2019 @6:29 PM

Article image
Drawing in Silver and Gold review – a stupendously rich gathering of great art
Some of the finest drawings in history were done using silverpoint. A new exhibition is proof that this artform is ingenious, magical – and will stop you in your tracks

Jonathan Jones

08, Sep, 2015 @7:00 AM