Turner prize 2010 – which artist should win? | Andrew Dickson

Sound artist Susan Philipsz may be the bookies' favourite, but Angela de la Cruz, Dexter Dalwood and the Otolith Group are also strong contenders. Ahead of tonight's announcement, who gets your vote?

When it comes to predicting the winner of the Turner prize, I have appalling form. One year I was convinced that Phil Collins's brilliantly sardonic TV project about Turkish reality shows was going to win (it didn't). In 2008, I quite fancied Cathy Wilkes's chances (Mark Leckey went on to win). So when I tell you that my favourite for this year's award is Angela de la Cruz, who makes awkward, funny sculptures that don't quite do what they're meant to, my advice is: don't listen to anything I say.

The betting is, of course, hardly the point. And some would argue that, when the shortlist includes work as different as painting, film, sculpture and sound, choosing a winner at all doesn't make much sense. But that's prizes for you, and – like it or not – a winner will be chosen later this evening, in the full glare of the world's press, at Tate Britain.

A reminder about who's in the running. There's Dexter Dalwood, who paints scenes that many of us have imagined (the death of Dr David Kelly, Jimi Hendrix's basement, wartime Iraq) but never seen. Dalwood has his fans – you lot said he should win – but Britain's newspaper critics aren't among them: Richard Dorment of the Telegraph called his work "cack-handed paintings of imaginary landscapes and interiors", while our own Jonathan Jones said back in 2000 that "if this is what they mean by painting, I hope it goes away soon". Then there's The Otolith Group, Anjalika Sagar and Kodwo Eshun, who make erudite, multi-strand work drawing on the history of cinema and social movements. Their room in the Turner prize exhibition contains a 45-minute film made of fragments of other films, a row of TV sets playing an obscure documentary about Ancient Greece, and a densely packed book. Easy to digest it certainly isn't; maybe that's the point.

The next room in the show is de la Cruz's, and contains a number of new paintings that have been torn apart or otherwise subjected to violence. They're called things like Deflated and Clutter, and squat anxiously in the gallery as if they're embarrassed to be there. I love her work – the wit as well as the sadness of it – but there's a feeling that perhaps this isn't her year. I guess we'll find out. The fourth artist to be shortlisted this year is Glaswegian Susan Philipsz, whose contribution to the show you hear long before you see it. Actually there isn't anything to see, just three loudspeakers and a bench; it is a piece of sound art, recordings of the artist singing slightly different versions of a Scottish medieval ballad. Mysterious and enticing, sorrowful and enigmatic, these songs overlap and intermingle, echoing around the room and out into the gallery beyond. The bookies tell us that Philipsz is the favourite to win – a good result, if only because it will be the first time that sound art has received this kind of recognition (and if you want to find out more about what she does, we ran a video interview with her last Friday).

The judges are meeting this afternoon to decide, and the waiting will be over for the rest of us at about 7.50pm when the ceremony is broadcast on Channel 4 News. Both Charlotte Higgins and I will be tweeting snippets live (follow us at twitter.com/andydickson and twitter.com/chiggi; we'll use the #TP2010 hashtag). We'll have news and reaction as soon as we can, pictures as soon as we get them, and tomorrow morning we'll have a video digest of the night's events. In the meantime, you could watch Adrian Searle's video tour around the exhibition, read Laura Cumming's astute review, or test your wits with our Turner prize quiz. And of course we want to know what you think. Have you seen the show? Did it pass muster? Who do you reckon should win?

Oh, one final thing: you haven't seen any of the artwork and still feel like posting that it's a load of old nonsense, I'm afraid Twitter's IanVisits has already got there: he suggests using #YouCallThatArt, #MyKidCouldDoBetter, #ItsRubbish or #WhatAWasteOfTime as tags. Enough said.

Contributor

Andrew Dickson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Turner Prize winner Susan Philipsz: an expert view | Adrian Searle
Susan Philipsz' work makes you think about place, space, memory and presence: it opens up your feelings, says <b>Adrian Searle</b>

Adrian Searle

06, Dec, 2010 @7:45 PM

Article image
Turner prize shortlist includes painter who imagines death of Dr David Kelly

Dexter Dalwood, Angela de la Cruz, Susan Philipsz and the Otolith Group nominated – but no Banksy

Charlotte Higgins, chief arts writer

04, May, 2010 @9:12 PM

Article image
The Turner prize shortlist 2010: their pictures, our words

Banksy may not have made it onto this year's Turner prize shortlist, but Susan Philipsz, Angela de la Cruz, Dexter Dalwood and the Otolith Group did. Click through to investigate their work and see the verdict from Guardian critics

04, May, 2010 @11:45 AM

Article image
Turner prize 2010 quiz: Call that art?

Are you an artworld insider, or a prize chump? Take our Turner prize test and find out

Jessica Lack

06, Dec, 2010 @1:23 PM

Article image
Turner prize 2010: Dark nights of the soul

From mangled canvasses to disembodied voices singing Scottish laments, the entries for this year's Turner prize are mournful, tough and beautiful, says Adrian Searle. So which of the four contenders should win?

Adrian Searle

04, Oct, 2010 @5:53 PM

Article image
Turner prize nominee Dexter Dalwood tipped by William Hill

Bookies William Hill are leaning towards Dalwood to win the 2010 Turner prize because his work is 'easy on the eye', writes Charlotte Higgins

Charlotte Higgins

04, May, 2010 @9:30 PM

Article image
Turner prize 2010: a shortlist that is half-baked | Jonathan Jones

Jonathan Jones: Only two of the four artists shortlisted for this year's Turner prize – Susan Philipsz and Angela de la Cruz – are worthy contenders. Not good enough

Jonathan Jones

04, May, 2010 @11:05 AM

Article image
Turner prize 2010 – review
The 2010 Turner prize show is concise, beautifully displayed and just a little bit dull, writes Laura Cumming

Laura Cumming

09, Oct, 2010 @11:05 PM

Article image
Turner prize: Susan Philipsz may be a worthy winner, but don't call her a sound artist | Jonathan Jones
Jonathan Jones: 'Sound art' doesn't really exist. One of the great things about the Turner prize is that it rewards work in many different forms

Jonathan Jones

07, Dec, 2010 @11:47 AM

Article image
The real Turner prize winner: this one's for you, Glasgow
Sarah Lowndes: Turner prize star Susan Philipsz comes from a long line of innovative artists and musicians with Glaswegian roots

Sarah Lowndes

08, Dec, 2010 @3:00 PM