Child refugees were ‘dumped’ in unsafe hotel, claims Brighton council

Law firm says attempts to evaluate a 15-year-old Afghan held in a hotel had been prevented, breaching the child’s rights

Fresh concern over the plight of thousands of refugees living in UK hotels has emerged after a council requested that the Home Office shut down temporary accommodation housing child refugees over “safeguarding concerns” and a lawyer revealed how he had been blocked from assessing unaccompanied minors.

Brighton and Hove city council has asked the Home Office to stop using a hotel holding scores of child refugees, claiming that no initial Covid-19 risk or safeguarding assessment had been carried out. Meanwhile, a law firm said that attempts to evaluate a 15-year-old Afghan held in a hotel had been prevented, breaching the child’s rights, with other unaccompanied minors subject to “unlawful forced imprisonment”.

The developments raise further questions over the 15,000 refugees – including 7,000 Afghans – currently housed in hotels following the hurried evacuation of families from Kabul last month.

Around 70 unaccompanied asylum-seeking children are in hotels, 16 of whom are aged under 16. MPs on the home affairs select committee last week expressed scepticism over whether such accommodation was adequate for children who have travelled to the UK alone.

Councillor Hannah Clare, chair of Brighton’s children, young people and skills committee, said the council had requested the Home Office to stop using a hotel near Hove following concerns for the wellbeing of children and anger that the local authority received less than 24 hours’ notice of the government’s intention.

“It is our position that the Home Office use of the site for this purpose needs to cease. They dumped a load of kids in there with no Covid risk assessment and no safeguarding,” said Clare. She added that dealing with the Home Office had been unpleasant, although they had eventually managed to get council officials into the hotels. “The Home Office have been very difficult the whole way through. It has taken a significant amount of pushing from our officers to get them to do things [to support the children].”

She believed the government’s approach compounded the trauma of child refugees arriving in the UK, many of whom have crossed the Channel by small boat.

So far during September, more migrants have crossed the Channel in small boats – almost 4,000 – than in any other previous month since the crossings became popular. Last Wednesday alone, 459 migrants were intercepted on 14 boats.

Stuart Luke, senior solicitor at InstaLaw, said unaccompanied minors in hotels were effectively imprisoned because they had been advised not to leave the premises. “They are de facto detained. We have so many young people who have been detained who now have legitimate claims for unlawful forced imprisonment,” he said.

Last week, a report into hotels used by the Home Office to accommodate asylum seekers said they were akin to detention centres with often sub-standard accommodation.

Luke added that his firm had received a referral for a 15-year-old unaccompanied minor who was held at a Kent hotel but officials had prevented him from assessing the child. “We went there and they refused us entry. They were detained and clearly weren’t being held in Children Act accommodation, they were in a hotel,” said Luke, also a trustee at charity Kurdish Umbrella.

When he asked for the teenager to be brought outside, the officials refused. “They effectively denied them access to a lawyer, which clearly breaches their human rights.” Ultimately, the solicitor did not meet the child and has no idea what happened to them.

Elsewhere, questions have emerged over an organisation apparently appointed by the Home Office in July – but without a competitive tendering process – to help provide support for child refugees in the hotels.

The firm, Greater Good Global, has raised eyebrows among many longstanding refugee groups, with some questioning its previous experience for assisting unaccompanied minors.

When asked about the appointment process and relevant experience, Krish Kandiah, chief executive of Greater Good Global, said: “I was asked in a personal capacity as a foster carer and the former director of a fostering and adoption charity to see what emergency voluntary support could be offered to the teenaged unaccompanied asylum-seeking children housed in hotel accommodation.

He added: “I was keen to muster any help I could for young people who are in need.”

However, some refugee groups have written to the home affairs select committee asking it to investigate the hiring of the firm.

A Home Office spokesperson said: In a critical and urgent situation, the Home Office may contact a number of organisations to ascertain whether they are able to provide support at short notice. Due diligence is undertaken on any potential providers before they are contracted to the Home Office to provide services.”

They added they were aware of one incident where an individual claiming to represent a child staying in a hotel was denied access. “The individual had been unable to provide any documentation showing that their services had been retained,” said a statement.

It added: We take the safeguarding of unaccompanied asylum-seeking children extremely seriously and have measures in place to ensure their welfare needs are met.”


Mark Townsend Home affairs editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Thousands of victims of child trafficking denied right to stay in the UK
New data reveals significant number of young vulnerable people put at risk of deportation by the Home Office

Mark Townsend Home Affairs Editor

17, Oct, 2020 @11:44 AM

Article image
UK ‘reneges on vow to reunite child refugees with families’
Home Office accused of making ‘no arrangements’ for transfers of unaccompanied minors after EU rules expire at end of year

Mark Townsend Home affairs editor

13, Dec, 2020 @8:00 AM

Article image
The car drew up. The children got in: UK child asylum-seekers’ narrow escape from kidnap
Alleged traffickers abducted three children from outside a Home Office-run hotel in Brighton last May. They were lucky to evade capture – many don’t

Mark Townsend

29, Jan, 2023 @6:30 AM

Article image
Fears grow over police collecting data from lone child refugees in UK
Welfare groups claim information could be used by Home Office to deport asylum seekers

Mirren Gidda

16, Apr, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
‘They just vanish’: whistleblowers met by wall of complacency over missing migrant children
As scores of youngsters are disappearing from hotels run by the Home Office and being trafficked across the country, sources claims warnings over their safety were ignored

Mark Townsend Home affairs editor

21, Jan, 2023 @6:14 PM

Article image
Child asylum seekers detained as adults after UK Home Office ‘alters birth dates’
Unaccompanied child refugees describe attacks in notorious Manston camp after officials ‘ignore or discount’ ID documents

Mark Townsend Home Affairs Editor

27, Nov, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
UK asylum seekers told claims at risk if they ‘misbehave’
Call for Home Office to act after private contractors tell people their applications will be jeopardised for speaking out, going on hunger strikes or complaining about food

Mark Townsend Home affairs editor

23, Jan, 2021 @9:26 PM

Article image
Home Office ‘ignoring offers to give homes to child refugees’
Lord Dubs calls response ‘miserable’ amid claims 1,400 offers from councils spurned

Mark Townsend

21, Dec, 2019 @9:00 PM

Article image
‘I don’t think lessons have been learned’: asylum policies fall short after more Channel deaths
Following another tragedy at sea and a ruling due on the Rwanda deal, is Britain complacent at home and complicit in refugee abuse abroad?

Mark Townsend

17, Dec, 2022 @1:00 PM

Article image
Migrants housed in Essex hotel find themselves at mercy of local hostility
Far-right For Britain party leading the charge against asylum-seekers with false claims of ‘crime surge’ in Epping

Mark Townsend in Epping

23, Aug, 2020 @5:20 AM