Cold war echoes as Aukus alliance focuses on China deterrence

Analysis: security partnership is wide-ranging and may come to define future approach to Indo-Pacific security

For those who study the history of the cold war, Washington’s new initiative with London and Canberra – known by its acronym “Aukus” – has overtones of the name UKUSA, an intelligence-sharing agreement signed 75 years ago now more commonly known as the Five Eyes partnership.

When the seven-page full text of UKUSA agreement was finally released in June 2010, Time magazine called it one of the cold war’s most important documents that “reveals one of the foundations of the special relationship the UK and the US still hold dear”.

But unlike the cold war-era UKUSA agreement, the Aukus alliance has a strong security and technology dimension. It comes at a time when many western capitals are recalibrating their relations with China. Until recent years, Australia, for example, had insisted on a “hedging” strategy in navigating changing regional dynamics. At one point, Canberra withdrew itself from the Quad, a strategic alliance with Japan, the US and India.

“This is about investing in our greatest source of strength, our alliances, and updating them to better meet the threats of today and tomorrow,” Joe Biden said late on Wednesday. “It’s about connecting America’s existing allies and partners in new ways.”

Yet, he left little doubt which power Aukus was supposed to aim at. After his nine-minute joint announcement with Scott Morrison and Boris Johnson, reporters asked: “Did you tell President Xi [Xinping] when you spoke to him last week?” and: “Is this all about China?”

Joe Biden is joined by Boris Johnson for Wednesday’s announcement.
Joe Biden is joined by Boris Johnson for Wednesday’s announcement. Photograph: REX/Shutterstock

“From Beijing’s perspective, this trilateral initiative is yet another US-led coalition emerging,” said Dali Yang, a Chinese foreign policy expert at the University of Chicago.

“In the last couple of years, a lot of efforts by the Chinese diplomatic community have been to trying to prevent something like this from happening,” Yang said. “Although in the meantime, Beijing has also been trying to solidify its ties with other countries, in a hope that they could remain as neutral as possible when it comes to agreements as such.”

Whether the Aukus initiative will succeed in the end still remains a question. After all, the four-year Trump presidency has shown America’s partners how multilateral initiatives can unravel overnight with a changing of the guard in Washington.

But if this initiative survives, it may show the shape of a possible future Indo-Pacific security strategy as Biden unites allies and partners to tackle “threats of the 21st century”, said Yuka Kobayashi of the School of Oriental and African Studies in London.

“At a first glance it looks like a traditional security partnership, however if you look at other areas mentioned – cyber and AI [artificial intelligence], for example, they mirror China’s Belt and Road Initiative. It covers more than security and it is about deterrence,” Kobayashi said.

Dual-track China strategy?

“With the US’s withdrawal from Afghanistan, we are seeing Washington revamping their ‘Pivot to Asia’. Similarly, the UK has pushed its identity as ‘Global Britain’, with more ambitious goals with the Indo-Pacific tilt unveiled in this year’s Integrated Review.”

Ahead of Wednesday’s announcement, senior US officials told reporters the initiative was about “sustaining and improving deterrence”. It is a narrative on China that is taking shape these days: it’s not all about confrontation, but more about deterrence as well as cooperation.

Some say that with the COP26 climate change conference just around the corner, the US and the UK in particular, would like to bring China on their side to show that a relationship that is both competitive and cooperative is viable in practice.

“But the key question is how far Biden can go with this dual-track strategy, acting more competitively in many respects, while at the same time signalling to Beijing that it still wishes to talk and collaborate on other issues,” said Neysun Mahboubi, a China expert at the University of Pennsylvania. “Will China be interested in the collaborative dimensions of this dual-track strategy at all?”

A few days before Wednesday’s announcement, Biden and Xi held their first telephone call for seven months. According to the Financial Times, the US president proposed a face-to-face meeting, but the Chinese leader did not respond.

Kobayashi thinks the muted response from Xi shows the limits of a dual-track strategy when approaching China. “Washington and its allies need to make sure they have a coherent strategy. They need to distinguish global issues such as climate change, which require global cooperation including China, and security and defence issues as covered in the Aukus alliance but also make sure they have a consistent message.”

She added: “China is the number one emitter of greenhouse gas emissions, so any meaningful response to the climate crisis requires China.”

Contributor

Vincent Ni China affairs correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
China vows to resist ‘interference’ as Taiwan welcomes support from Aukus allies
Australia and US pledge stronger ties, EU calls for trade deal and Johnson refuses to rule out getting involved in a conflict involving the island

Helen Davidson in Taipei and Vincent Ni

17, Sep, 2021 @11:08 AM

Article image
US, UK and Australia forge military alliance to counter China
Aukus partnership will enable Australia to have nuclear-powered submarines for the first time

Julian Borger in Washington and Dan Sabbagh

16, Sep, 2021 @12:17 AM

Article image
What is the Aukus alliance and what are its implications?
The US, UK and Australia’s new strategic partnership has upset both China and France

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

16, Sep, 2021 @4:40 PM

Article image
Aukus deal showing France and EU that Biden not all he seems
Analysis: the western alliance is the main victim – and China will win out unless US can soothe Paris’s anger

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

16, Sep, 2021 @4:09 PM

Article image
Aukus submarines banned from New Zealand as pact exposes divide with western allies
Experts say Aukus military deal underlines Australia’s increasingly close alignment with the US on China – and New Zealand’s relative distance

Tess McClure in Christchurch

16, Sep, 2021 @2:56 AM

Article image
Aukus pact: UK and US battle to contain international backlash
Nuclear submarine deal with Australia draws criticism from allies and China amid fears of conflict

Dan Sabbagh, Julian Borger, Helen Davidson and Angelique Chrisafis

16, Sep, 2021 @7:48 PM

Article image
Climate experts fear Aukus will dash hopes of China emissions deal
Timing of defence deal, ahead of Cop26 summit where China will be key player, dismays campaigners

Fiona Harvey Environment correspondent

16, Sep, 2021 @5:26 PM

Article image
Alliance with Australia and US a ‘downpayment on global Britain’
Comment from White House shows there is a price to be paid: support for US-led stronger posture against Beijing

Dan Sabbagh

15, Sep, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
China warns US-UK-Australia pact could ‘hurt their own interests’
Aukus described as ‘exclusionary’ amid French anger at scrapping of $90bn submarine deal with Australia

Helen Davidson in Taipei and Gavin Blair in Tokyo

16, Sep, 2021 @9:25 AM

Article image
Biden to rally regional support for China containment strategy at Quad summit
Biden will meet leaders of Australia, India and Japan as he builds a web of alliances to support democracy and deter authoritarianism

Julian Borger in Washington

24, Sep, 2021 @10:00 AM