Australia’s foreign minister to meet French ambassador in bid to heal submarine rift

Marise Payne says she regrets France’s ‘deep disappointment’, as tension with Indonesia over Aukus deal revealed

Australia’s foreign minister will meet with the French ambassador next week in an attempt to patch up the damaging diplomatic rift over submarines, while declaring she regrets “the deep disappointment that France feels”.

While the government hopes to begin to repair the relationship with France, Australian officials have also shared details of friction with Indonesia over the new plan to acquire at least eight nuclear-powered submarines.

Australia’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade revealed it had not been aware an Indonesian official was going to publicly flag an intention to close a “loophole” in the nuclear non-proliferation treaty, before a newspaper interview last week.

Australian officials told a committee hearing on Thursday they had responded by “clarifying” in “great detail” Australia’s position and “underlined firmly” that the Aukus proposal would be consistent with the treaty.

The prime minister, Scott Morrison, is expected to address the concerns during a planned meeting with the Indonesian president, Joko Widodo, on the sidelines of the G20 summit in Rome this weekend, before he travels to Glasgow for the climate conference.

The French president, Emmanuel Macron, will be at the G20 – the first time Morrison has seen the French leader since diplomatic outrage erupted when Australia abruptly cancelled the $90bn plan for French-designed submarines. No bilateral meeting with the French president is currently scheduled.

The French government has said it was “betrayed”, “stabbed in the back” and “deceived” over Australia’s negotiation of the new submarine plans with the US and the UK, and temporarily recalled two ambassadors.

Australia’s foreign minister, Marise Payne, was asked on Thursday whether she regretted any aspect of her handling of the matter. “I certainly regret the deep disappointment that France feels,” Payne told a Senate estimates hearing.

Payne said the French ambassador, Jean-Pierre Thébault, had since returned to Canberra and would be out of quarantine this weekend.

“I’m meeting him myself on Monday – that is part of the process of addressing these concerns,” she said.

Payne said she had also submitted a request for a phone call with the French foreign minister about two weeks ago but “we’re awaiting a response”.

Payne said she had “heard very acutely what the French government is saying in two languages” but dismissed the idea France could have been given a heads-up earlier than 15 September – hours before the formal announcement of Aukus.

Payne said the decisions were “about the most sensitive issues at the heart of our sovereign defence strategy”.

“It was the judgment of the government that that sensitivity precluded broader information sharing substantially in advance of the announcement,” she said.

The minister declined to comment directly on a media report that Biden administration aides had acknowledged “they were mistaken to leave it to the Australians to tell the French they were killing their submarine deal”.

Axios reported on 6 October: “The Australians told the Americans in June that they had all but told France that they were pulling the plug, both in writing and in direct conversations between Macron and Australian prime minister Scott Morrison, according to two sources familiar with the assurances.”

Payne said: “That piece of reporting is just another piece of reporting, senator … I don’t comment on multiple random media articles.”

Labor’s Senate leader, Penny Wong, told the minister: “I think that the thing that potentially is risky for the relationship [with France] is not just that we’ve done this, it’s how they feel we’ve done it. They feel deceived, it’s quite clear from public statements.”

Payne replied: “And as I said, we will work through all of these issues and all of these steps.”

Within south-east Asia, Indonesia and Malaysia have been the most vocal in expressing their concerns about Australia’s nuclear-powered submarine plans, including the potential to contribute to a regional arms race.

Payne also said it was “regrettable” and “not helpful” that elements of the Aukus plans were leaked and reported prior to the public announcement of the deal with the UK and the US on the morning of 16 September.

Wong pressed Payne to confirm that she first spoke to the Indonesian foreign minister, Retno Marsudi, by phone about 11pm AEST on 15 September – after the initial reports had begun to be published.

Payne said her office would check the Australian times, but both she and her Indonesian counterpart had been travelling in the US and it was the earliest opportunity.

Dfat officials said the communication plans they had prepared for the government were based on the timing of the official announcement.

Australia planned to contact Indonesia, New Zealand, South Korea, India, France, Canada and Japan prior to the public announcement. The head of the International Atomic Energy Agency was also on this list.

Morrison spoke to leaders from the Association of South East Asian Nations (Asean) on Wednesday in a virtual summit, and assured them that the Aukus plan “does not change Australia’s deep, long-standing commitment to nuclear non-proliferation”.

Leaders expressed “views” on the “implications for the region”, according to an official statement issued by Asean.

Despite the concerns some countries hold about the submarine plan, Asean leaders agreed on Wednesday to elevate the regional grouping’s relationship with Australia to the status of “comprehensive strategic partnership”.

Justin Hayhurst, a Dfat deputy secretary, raised concerns on Thursday about growing tensions across the Taiwan Strait, including China’s incursions into Taiwan’s air defence identification zone.

“We consider that the risk of some sort of miscalculation is higher than it was before,” Hayhurst said.

He said Australia had directly communicated those concerns to Chinese government representatives in Canberra and Beijing, including the view “that a conflict of any sort across the strait would be a catastrophe for regional security”.


Daniel Hurst

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘We didn’t deface the Eiffel Tower’: Barnaby Joyce dismisses French anger at axed submarine deal
Diplomatic fallout continues as French president quips ‘good luck’ with Aukus delivering vessels on time

Daniel Hurst in Canberra and Katharine Murphy in Rome

01, Nov, 2021 @7:24 AM

Article image
Morrison accused of worsening rift with French government after leak of Macron text
Release of message from French president described as ‘highly unconventional behaviour between state leaders’

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

02, Nov, 2021 @7:37 AM

Article image
‘We thought we were mates’: French ambassador laments subterfuge en route to Sydney airport
Jean-Pierre Thebault was angry about Aukus as he left Australia on Saturday night, saying: ‘It’s like in a couple, you know, when you commit … you don’t run away’

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

19, Sep, 2021 @12:28 AM

Article image
‘Someone lied’: French foreign minister accuses Australia of submarine betrayal in latest broadside
Jean-Yves Le Drian says Australia reassured France everything was fine right up to the day the Aukus pact was announced

Kim Willsher in Paris and Daniel Hurst in Canberra

30, Sep, 2021 @6:56 AM

Article image
Macron took aim at Scott Morrison over the submarine fracas – and he did not miss | Katharine Murphy
The accusation Australia’s PM lied could play into voter unease that he doesn’t always play it straight, and rarely cops it sweet

Katharine Murphy

01, Nov, 2021 @1:16 AM

Article image
Macron accuses Australian PM of lying over submarine deal
French president criticises Scott Morrison and expresses scepticism that Aukus pact will deliver on schedule

Katharine Murphy in Rome

31, Oct, 2021 @7:27 PM

Article image
Australian defence minister Peter Dutton urges French to focus on China instead of ‘hurt feelings’ over submarine contract
Labor’s Penny Wong attacked government over saga, likening it to Donald Trump’s treatment of allies

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

04, Nov, 2021 @5:27 AM

Article image
Game-changer or irresponsible? The known unknowns on Australia’s nuclear submarine deal
Analysis: Stay tuned as we battle the notoriously secret defence establishment to work out what we are getting and when, and maybe why and whether it’s worth it

Tory Shepherd

17, Sep, 2021 @8:35 AM

Article image
Essential poll: majority of Australians back Aukus submarine pact, but fear it will inflame tensions with China
Coalition has 13-point lead over Labor on voter trust to handle national security, while ALP has 13-point lead on managing climate crisis

Katharine Murphy Political editor

27, Sep, 2021 @9:26 PM

Article image
Why is Emmanuel Macron so upset with Scott Morrison?
A fiery war of words has erupted between the French president and Australian prime minister over submarines. So how did it come to this?

Daniel Hurst

01, Nov, 2021 @10:43 PM