Former PMs apologise to Pacific leaders for Australia’s apathy on climate crisis

Kevin Rudd and Malcolm Turnbull lash out at Morrison government’s ‘cynical indifference’ and assure Pacific leaders ‘a majority’ of Australians ‘are in your corner’

Former Australian prime ministers Kevin Rudd and Malcolm Turnbull, and former foreign affairs minister Bob Carr, have accused the Morrison government of “cynical indifference” and “empty rhetoric” when it comes to climate action, saying the commitment to achieve net zero emissions by 2050 was the “bare minimum” that needed to be done.

The broadside came in a letter to Pacific leaders, in which the Australian politicians said they shared the “alarm and disappointment” of Pacific heads of government at the suggestion Australia will not table a new and increased target for the reduction of emissions ahead of the Cop26 summit in Glasgow next month.

“As you know, the Paris agreement requires nations to step up their short-term national ambition every five years. Glasgow is all about what countries plan to do by 2030 to reduce emissions … Australia can and should do much more,” they wrote.

“Promising net zero by 2050 is the bare minimum and a promise Prime Minister Morrison first made at the Pacific Islands Forum in August 2019. But without accelerated cuts in emissions in the near and medium term, a net zero by 2050 promise has no credibility.”

The former leaders said they had taken the “somewhat unusual step” of writing to Pacific leaders as a sign of their respect for the region and in recognition of its importance to Australia.

The Pacific region is one of the areas considered most vulnerable to the impacts of the climate crisis, and its leaders have had an outsized impact on the global fight.

“With Glasgow less than two weeks away, we want you to know that millions of Australians are just as disappointed with our government’s lack of action as you are,” the letter reads.

“At Cop26 we know you will press for high ambition action that will limit warming to 1.5 degrees and continue to lead by example. Be assured of one thing: a majority of the Australian people, and all our state and territory governments, are in your corner … Do not be disheartened by the cynical indifference or the empty rhetoric from Canberra.”

A girl walks past a cemetery in the Marshall Islands that was inundated by the seawater during storm surges.
A girl walks past a cemetery in the Marshall Islands that was inundated by seawater during storm surges. Photograph: Vlad Sokhin/World Bank

Rudd, Turnbull and Carr said that the obstacles to climate action in Australia were “not economic” but rather were the result of “the vested interests of the coal and gas industry coupled with rightwing populist media and politics”, which they accused of being “the most intractable opponents to cutting emissions faster and sooner”.

The former leaders sought to distance themselves from the stance of the Morrison government, criticising particular policies of the current government.

They singled out the decision to reorient the emissions reduction fund “in the pursuit of so-called ‘clean coal’ or carbon capture and storage – a technology which is a thoroughly proven failure now used by the fossil fuel lobby to delay the transition to renewables.”

The emissions reduction fund is a scheme established under Tony Abbott that pays farmers and businesses to cut carbon dioxide emissions below what they would have otherwise been.

The letter was also critical of a controversial proposal to create a $250bn loan facility for the resources sector in return for National party backing for a net zero emissions target, put forward by Nationals MP Keith Pitt and endorsed by the current and former leaders of the National party Barnaby Joyce and Michael McCormack.

“Of course, the beneficiaries of these subsidies would be overwhelmingly foreign-owned miners,” wrote Rudd, Turnbull and Carr.

The former leaders claimed to speak for “millions of Australians [who] expect their government to raise our ambition and move faster to cut emissions”, saying these Australians also wanted Australia to rethink the way climate finance was delivered – calling for Australia to participate in the Green Climate Fund, the primary multilateral vehicle that delivers climate finance.

Australia stepped back from the Green Climate Fund in 2018 and has opted to provide climate aid largely through bilateral partnerships, including committing to provide hundreds of millions in funding to help Pacific nations invest in renewable energy and climate and disaster resilience.

This money has come from the existing aid budget, something Rudd, Turnbull and Carr are critical of, saying they wanted to see “real increases in aid for climate adaptation, not shuffling money from one side of the aid budget to the other”.

The Prime Minister’s Office has been contacted for comment.


Kate Lyons

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pacific leaders condemn Australia's 'weak' climate target in open letter to Scott Morrison
Fourteen eminent signatories urge Canberra to commit to net-zero emissions by 2050

Ben Doherty Pacific Editor

01, Dec, 2020 @4:12 AM

Article image
Eight years, 20 policies: how Australia’s leaders have fumbled and dithered on climate
How did we get here? And how much has actually changed? Before we look forward to 2050, let’s take a look back …

Amy Remeikis

16, Oct, 2021 @7:00 PM

Article image
Three-quarters of Australia’s ‘significant’ climate aid projects in Pacific don’t mention climate change, Greenpeace says
A governance facility in Papua New Guinea is among projects Australia claims as ‘significantly focused’ on climate adaptation

Kate Lyons

03, Nov, 2021 @9:18 AM

Article image
Marise Payne says net zero is government’s ‘broad position’ as she plays down Nationals’ climate revolt
Foreign affairs minister says net zero emissions target preferable by 2050 even as Liberals’ coalition partner shoots down idea

Paul Karp

20, Jun, 2021 @2:37 AM

Article image
Q&A: former Tuvalu PM says Scott Morrison denies climate change is happening in Pacific
Special episode of the ABC show featuring Pacific leaders was dominated by climate crisis and Australia’s response

Kate Lyons

02, Dec, 2019 @8:36 PM

Article image
UK will be ‘very disappointed’ if Scott Morrison not at Cop26 climate talks
High commissioner to Australia calls on PM to give ‘firm commitment’ to net zero emissions by 2050, saying ‘the time is now’ to raise targets

Paul Karp

29, Sep, 2021 @1:31 AM

Article image
Scott Morrison could restore Australia’s climate reputation as a lifter rather than a leaner with five steps | Tristan Edis
There is a way the Coalition can claim its climate policy is all about technology not taxes and still show it is serious about net zero

Tristan Edis

09, Nov, 2021 @11:39 PM

Article image
Kevin Rudd lashes Coalition over increasingly strained relationship with China
Former PM says Australia ‘opened the door’ to Chinese influence in the Pacific by slashing aid and retreating on climate

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

26, Nov, 2019 @6:20 AM

Article image
Climate pressure on Scott Morrison grows as NSW promises to cut emissions in half by 2030
The Berejiklian government commitment is backed by Liberals and Nationals in state cabinet while their federal counterparts remain split

Adam Morton and Katharine Murphy

28, Sep, 2021 @2:01 PM

Article image
UN climate summit president thanks Australian states – but not Morrison government – for backing net zero
UK energy minister Alok Sharma urges ‘all of you who have not already done so to join the race’ to net zero emissions by 2050

Adam Morton and Graham Readfearn

02, Dec, 2020 @2:03 AM