New Zealand Covid: Māori party likens new ‘traffic light’ system to ‘Squid Game’

Comments come after PM Jacinda Ardern said most restrictions will only be lifted when country reaches 90% vaccination

New Zealand’s new pandemic approach is “a real-life Squid Game for Māori”, the Māori party has said – likening plans unveiled on Friday to the viral Netflix show where contestants compete in children’s games and the losers are executed.

Their comments came as the prime minister, Jacinda Ardern, laid out plans to lift most restrictions when the country reached 90% vaccination – and amid concerns that the new roadmap would result in disproportionate illness and death for Indigenous people.

“On every single Covid indicator, Māori are significantly behind every other ethnicity,” the Māori party co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer said in a statement. “On every single indicator, Māori are likely to take the biggest hits from a Delta outbreak, vaccinated or not.

“The PM says no one will be left behind,” co-leader Rawiri Waititi said. “What she means is no one will be left behind except for Māori. Let the Squid Games begin.”

Ardern on Friday announced that 90% of eligible New Zealanders needed to be fully vaccinated across each District Health Board (DHB) region before the whole country moves to a new “traffic light” system of much looser public health restrictions. The new plans do not include specific vaccination targets for Māori and Pacific New Zealanders – something a number of experts have called for, as those populations lag behind national vaccination rates. The country has a growing outbreak of the Delta variant, and on Friday announced 129 new cases – a record high since the pandemic began.

“We cannot ask vaccinated people to stay home for ever. So now we need a new playbook to reflect a population protected from Covid,” Ardern said. She said the new system would provide “a future where we want to continue to protect people’s lives, but also to live our lives”.

When the 90% targets are reached, the country will switch to a traffic light system. Even at a “red” setting – the highest levels of restriction, designed to protect the health system from high transmission – businesses will be able to remain open and vaccinated people will be able to use services relatively freely. Those without vaccination certificates, however, will face serious limitations: they will be limited to takeaway food, smaller gatherings of up to 10 people, distance learning at universities, and not able to use “close contact” businesses like gyms, hairdressers or bars.

“Fully vaccinated people will be able to reconnect with family and friends, go to bars and restaurants and do the things they love with greater certainty and confidence. The framework also provides businesses greater certainty to plan and grow,” Ardern said.

“If you are still unvaccinated, not only will you be more at risk of catching Covid-19, but many of the freedoms others enjoy will be out of reach. No one wants that to happen but we need to minimise the threat of the virus, which is now mainly spreading amongst unvaccinated people.”

Jacinda Ardern visits a vaccination centre in Hastings
Jacinda Ardern visits a vaccination centre in Hastings. The ‘traffic light’ system will kick in when 90% of the population has been vaccinated. Photograph: Kerry Marshall/Getty Images

New Zealand is still some way away from hitting 90% double-dosed. As of Thursday, 66% of the eligible population (those aged 12 and over) were fully vaccinated with both doses; 83% of the eligible population have had at least one dose. Even with high vaccination rates, the country could experience significant levels of mortality and illness from Covid-19 – realities that New Zealand has not had to reckon with so far.

Modelling released by the government and research centre Te Pūnaha Matatini last month projected that with 80% of those aged 5 and over double-jabbed, it could cause just under 60,000 hospitalisations and just under 7,000 deaths over the course of a year. Even with 90% of the population aged 5 and over fully vaccinated, deaths could sit at about 600 a year without other health measures. Neither model is precisely analogous to the new plan – the government’s targets are for those aged 12 and over, not 5 and over, and under the traffic light system they could be combined with other public health measures.

A number of experts have raised concerns that those mortality rates would be disproportionately borne by Māori.

“At the very least, vaccination target details for Aotearoa New Zealand needed to include at least 90–95% full vaccinations for Māori and Pacific peoples, to help keep all of our most vulnerable communities safe from Covid-19,” Dr Dianne Sika-Paotonu, an immunologist and associate dean (Pacific) at the University of Otago said via the Science Media Centre.

“Leaving any of our most vulnerable behind and unprotected, given the adverse health impact already seen for vulnerable groups in Aotearoa New Zealand, will have consequences that will be far reaching and will speak to generations to come.”

Dr Rhys Jones, a senior lecturer in Māori health at the University of Auckland, said it was “extremely disappointing that the threshold … doesn’t include a requirement for a certain level of coverage among Māori and Pacific communities”.

“It is unethical to significantly ease restrictions any further while vaccine coverage for Māori and Pacific remains dangerously low,” he said.

Earlier drafts of the framework had been strongly opposed by a number of Māori groups, with Ngarewa-Packer earlier this month saying the government was “holding Māori up to be the sacrificial lambs” and calling it a “modern form [of] genocide”.

Māori and Pacific communities are lagging behind in vaccination rates, partly because their populations skew younger than the wider population. Modelling by Te Pūnaha Matatini found Māori were 2.5 times more likely to be hospitalised with Covid-19 than non-Māori, after controlling for age and pre-existing conditions. Pacific people were three times more likely to end up in hospital with Covid. On top of that, Māori are more likely to have pre-existing conditions, like diabetes and asthma, that put them at greater risk if they contract Covid-19.

The National Iwi Chairs Forum condemned the strategy last week, saying it was “absolutely clear that we reject the Traffic Light Framework”.

Families reunite with a picnic at Western Springs in Auckland
Level-3 restrictions were recently loosened in Auckland to allow vaccinated people to have picnics. Photograph: Phil Walter/Getty Images

“Māori and Pacific vaccination rates have to increase to the same level as other New Zealanders otherwise the infection and mortality rate will disproportionally affect our vulnerable communities,” said Lisa Tumahai, chair of the Pandemic Response Group.

Ardern said that the government believed major cities like Auckland would be able to hit those rates before Christmas. “Even at the current [vaccination] rates, Auckland would move before, absolutely before, Christmas. What we want is for them to move as soon as possible,” she said. Auckland, which has been in lockdown for several months, will be able to shift to the traffic light system as soon as its District Health Boards hit 90%, Ardern said. The city is 16,000 doses away from hitting 90% first doses.

The plan was met with criticism from all other parliamentary political parties across the political spectrum.

National leader Judith Collins, in an emotional press conference, said the plan was “dismaying, confusing and complicated” and that Aucklanders would end up “being held to ransom by some people who don’t want to get vaccinated.”

The Green party called the plan “rushed and risky”, with Green MP Julie Anne Genter saying the vaccine targets “are insufficient to protect the most vulnerable”. The Act party has called it “very complicated”.

Ardern’s announcement also marked a final, formal goodbye to the country’s long-held Covid-elimination strategy. While the country has been shifting away from this for weeks, some government officials have continued to say New Zealand was attempting to eliminate the virus.

“Delta has made it very hard to maintain our elimination strategy,” Ardern said. “Its tentacles have reached into our communities and made it hard to shake even using the best public health measures in the toughest restrictions we had available to us. But right as our longstanding strategy was challenged, we also had a new tool, one that means as Covid has changed, we could change too – and rather than being locked down, we could move forward safely and with confidence. That tool is the vaccine.”

Contributor

Tess McClure in Christchurch

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Māori party warns reopening New Zealand amid Covid outbreak would be ‘modern genocide’
Party say Maori would be ‘sacrificial lambs’ if Covid restrictions are lifted before vaccination rates rise

Tess McClure in Christchurch

11, Oct, 2021 @5:58 AM

Article image
New Zealand mental health crisis as Covid stretches a struggling system
Health workers and older people among those bearing brunt of added pressure brought by coronavirus

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Queenstown

09, Sep, 2020 @8:00 PM

Article image
New Zealand reports record Covid cases as experts sound warning over health system
Health officials have been unable to link more than half of the cases, possibly indicating further undetected spread in the community

Tess McClure in Christchurch

19, Oct, 2021 @4:11 AM

Article image
New Zealand National party promises 'significant' tax cuts to aid Covid recovery
Opposition party unveils billions in tax cuts and focus on disciplined spending in its pre-election economic proposals

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Queenstown

18, Sep, 2020 @1:25 AM

Article image
The pandemic has illustrated New Zealand's hypocritical attitude to Māori health | Emma Espiner
Prioritising Māori for the vaccine would be a concrete sign the government is committed to improving our health

Emma Espiner

01, Feb, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Māori tribe tells anti-Covid vaccine protesters to stop using its haka
Tribal leaders say they have lost many ancestors to previous pandemics and see vaccine as best protection against virus

Tess McClure in Christchurch

15, Nov, 2021 @3:57 AM

Article image
Waitangi Day: New Zealand Labour's Māori members arrive amid Covid measures
Coronavirus risk at events being managed amid trickle of cases in quarantine

Eleanor de Jong in Queenstown

02, Feb, 2021 @1:47 AM

Article image
New Zealand Māori party launches petition to change country’s name to Aotearoa
Party wants all original te reo Māori place names to be officially restored across the country in the next five years

Tess McClure in Christchurch

14, Sep, 2021 @1:46 AM

Article image
Covid-19: New Zealand government accused of 'flat-footed' response
Opposition claims not enough is being done to stimulate economy, despite Jacinda Ardern saying nation is in robust position to fight coronavirus

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Dunedin

10, Mar, 2020 @2:13 AM

Article image
'Deliberate, malicious': stop spreading Covid misinformation, says New Zealand minister
Health authorities struggle to lock down cluster at Auckland evangelical church after some people refused to co-operate

Eleanor Ainge Roy in Queenstown

10, Sep, 2020 @4:36 AM