France and Israel hold ‘secret’ talks to defuse phone spyware row

Senior advisers discuss alleged targeting of French cabinet ministers’ phones with NSO Group spyware

A top adviser to the French president, Emmanuel Macron, has met with his Israeli counterpart to discuss the alleged targeting of French ministers by a client of NSO Group, the Israeli spyware maker.

A row over the alleged surveillance has been described as a major diplomatic headache for the government of Naftali Bennett, the Israeli prime minister.

The “secret” meetings at the Élysée Palace were first reported by the news website Axios and then confirmed by the Guardian’s partners in the Pegasus Project, a consortium of media outlets that have investigated NSO.

The meeting between Emmanuel Bonne, a senior diplomatic adviser to Macron, and Eyal Hulata, Israel’s national security adviser, was reportedly aimed at ending the “crisis” that has engulfed the two countries’ relationship since the summer.

In July, it was reported that the phone numbers of some French cabinet members, as well as Macron himself, appeared on a leaked database of mobile phone numbers which included some selected as possible targets for surveillance by government clients of NSO.

The Israeli company is closely regulated by Israel’s ministry of defence, which vets the export of licences to NSO’s government clients.

Traces of NSO’s spyware, called Pegasus, were found on the mobile phones of at least five serving French cabinet ministers, the investigative website Mediapart recently reported, citing multiple anonymous sources and a confidential intelligence dossier. The discovery was made weeks after the Guardian and other outlets published details of the leaked list.

There is no firm evidence that the phones of the five cabinet members were successfully hacked, but the Mediapart allegations indicate the devices were targeted with the powerful spyware, which can intercept phone conversations, text messages, emails and photographs. It can also turn a mobile phone into a listening device by remotely controlling a phone’s recorder.

NSO has said its spyware is meant to be used to investigate serious crime, and not to target members of civil society. It has said it has no connection to the leaked database that was investigated by the Pegasus Project and that the tens of thousands of numbers contained in the list are not the targets of NSO’s government clients. It has also staunchly denied that Macron was ever targeted by Pegasus spyware.

Commenting on the Israeli-French talks, a spokesperson for NSO said: “It is not for NSO to comment on the existence or content of diplomatic meetings. However, regarding the allegations of the Pegasus Project, we stand by our previous statements: the so-called list is not a list of Pegasus targets, hence the French government officials mentioned are not and never have been Pegasus targets.”

Axios reported that the “crisis” between the two countries led to a “partial freeze” on diplomatic, security, and intelligence cooperation between Israel and France and the suspension of high-level bilateral visits. Hulata reportedly briefed Bonne on the status of an Israeli investigation into Pegasus and proposed a commitment to ban its clients from being able to penetrate French mobile numbers. US, UK, Canadian, Australian, and New Zealand-based numbers are also reportedly off limits to NSO clients.

The diplomatic tensions underscore the serious nature of the allegations exposed in the Pegasus Project. Forbidden Stories, a Paris-based journalism nonprofit, and Amnesty International led the journalistic collaboration.


Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Spyware ‘found on phones of five French cabinet members’
Mediapart claims indicate that devices were targeted by NSO’s Pegasus spyware

Jon Henley and Stephanie Kirchgaessner

23, Sep, 2021 @9:47 PM

Article image
Israel to examine whether spyware export rules should be tightened
Commission to review claims NSO’s Pegasus was misused by customers to target journalists and activists

Peter Beaumont and Philip Oltermann

22, Jul, 2021 @3:45 PM

Article image
Pegasus spyware found on journalists’ phones, French intelligence confirms
Announcement is first time an independent and official authority has corroborated Pegasus project findings

Kim Willsher in Paris

02, Aug, 2021 @2:16 PM

Article image
How does Apple technology hold up against NSO spyware?
The iPhone maker says it is keeping pace with malware, but the Pegasus project paints a worrying picture

Stephanie Kirchgaessner and Alex Hern

19, Jul, 2021 @11:00 AM

Article image
What is Pegasus spyware and how does it hack phones?
NSO Group software can record your calls, copy your messages and secretly film you

David Pegg and Sam Cutler

18, Jul, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
Demonstrations and inquiries: the global impact of the Pegasus project
Worldwide concern over the use of invasive spyware sold to autocratic regimes

Reporting team

23, Jul, 2021 @1:09 PM

Article image
Edward Snowden calls for spyware trade ban amid Pegasus revelations
NSA whistleblower warns of world in which no phone is safe from state-sponsored hackers if no action taken

David Pegg and Paul Lewis

19, Jul, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Viktor Orbán accused of using Pegasus to spy on journalists and critics
Hungary’s far-right government suspected of hacking phones of investigative journalists and targeting owners

Shaun Walker in Budapest

18, Jul, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on spyware sales: the proliferation risks are real | Editorial
Editorial: This week’s revelations around NSO’s Pegasus snooping software is an argument for an immediate moratorium on trade in the technology


19, Jul, 2021 @5:33 PM

Article image
Fifty people linked to Mexico’s president among potential targets of NSO clients
Numbers of 15,000 Mexicans including politicians, journalists, judges, activists and teachers appear in leak

Nina Lakhani in Mexico City

19, Jul, 2021 @4:00 PM