Love Island South Africa accused of selecting too few black contestants

Viewers criticise reality TV show spin-off for failing to represent diversity of ‘rainbow nation’

A South African version of the reality show Love Island has been accused of failing to represent the diversity of the “rainbow nation” by selecting too few black contestants.

The programme was launched on Sunday night, and was immediately widely criticised by local viewers on social media.

Many pointed to publicity photographs released by the producers of Love Island South Africa, a spin-off of the successful if controversial UK show, which they said appeared to show only white contestants. Others complained that only one of the 10 contestants was a black woman. The presenter was also white, some pointed out.

Some viewers called for formal objections to be made to the broadcasting complaints commission.

Of South Africa’s 58 million inhabitants, 80% are described as black African in census statistics, and only 7.9% as white.

A major lottery that had sponsored Love Island SA said on Tuesday it was cancelling its support.

“LottoStar has taken the decision to respectfully withdraw its sponsorship of Love Island SA. We wish the show and its contestants every success,” the company said.

Contestants in the show, who are all single, live in a luxury villa for six weeks where they perform a series of tasks as couples, competing for the chance to win the equivalent of £50,000. New contestants are introduced as the series continues.

The row has exposed continuing tensions in South Africa over representation of different communities within the media, business and sport.

Last month, a TV journalist who asked a black interviewee to put on a mask after allowing a white interviewee to talk unmasked moments later prompted outrage and protests. The broadcaster ENC said the journalist had not been “racially motivated or with malicious intent”.

South Africa was ruled for decades by the white-supremacist apartheid regime, and has made significant progress towards greater tolerance between communities since the coming of democracy in 1994.

“Sex sells and whatnot … [but] what isn’t understandable is why the cast does not include more races in a country that is still grappling with the effects of apartheid,” wrote Helen Herimbi, a columnist in the City Press newspaper.

Thinus Ferreira, a TV critic, described the show as “shockingly embarrassing”.

“Yes the show is aimed at the … channel’s audience … that does skew white and female but that isn’t an excuse,” Ferreira wrote on his blog. “A reality show like Love Island SA is still anchored and done in South Africa and must reflect at least a modicum of ‘reality’ and ‘South Africa’.”

M-Net, which made the programme, did not respond to a request for comment.

In a statement given to local media, the company said it prided itself on reflecting diversity and inclusion in all its shows. “Viewers can be assured this will become more apparent in future episodes of Love Island SA. We hope viewers will keep watching to enjoy the new starts of the show who will be arriving over the next few days.”

Contributor

Jason Burke in Johannesburg

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Love Island makers say LGBT contestants bring ‘logistical difficulties’
ITV producers say greater inclusivity is a goal for the reality TV hit, but that sexual diversity challenges the show’s format

Hannah J Davies

03, Jun, 2021 @12:46 PM

Article image
Idols South Africa crowns first black winner
Khaya Mthethwa's success in TV talent show's eighth series seen as a cultural landmark 18 years after end of apartheid

David Smith, Africa correspondent

02, Oct, 2012 @11:53 PM

Article image
Oscar Pistorius's family to sue makers of 'grossly misrepresentative' film
Relatives of Paralympian threaten to take legal action over US drama Blade Runner Killer, scheduled for release next month

Jason Burke in Johannesburg

03, Oct, 2017 @1:20 PM

Article image
Widow of man killed in Libya accuses South Africa of ‘silence’ in hunt for his body
The South African government sent Anton Hammerl’s passport to his widow in 2016 but has refused to say how it came to have it

Peter Beaumont

19, May, 2022 @12:11 PM

Article image
South Africa may crown first black Idols winner

Lloyd Cele seen to have strong chance of winning Pop Idol-based show with disproportionately white audience

David Smith in Johannesburg

01, Nov, 2010 @5:23 PM

Article image
Love Island goes stateside as ITV sells rights to US network
With foreign versions of the dating show proving a huge global hit, CBS joins the party

Jim Waterson

08, Aug, 2018 @7:05 PM

Article image
South Africa considering granting immunity to Grace Mugabe
There is ‘no way’ Zimbabwean first lady will be arrested over model’s allegation of assault in hotel, says source in Pretoria

Jamie Grierson and agencies

18, Aug, 2017 @11:08 AM

Article image
Fourteen lions escape from Kruger park in South Africa
Police warn local residents after pride escapes from world-famous reserve

Jason Burke

07, Jun, 2019 @1:25 PM

Article image
South Africa issues arrest warrant for ANC's Ace Magashule
Party general secretary wanted over corruption allegations in Free State province

Jason Burke

10, Nov, 2020 @5:47 PM

Article image
‘Farmgate’ threatens Cyril Ramaphosa’s South Africa re-election bid
President is accused of trying to cover up theft of millions of US dollars hidden at his game farm

Jason Burke in Johannesburg

17, Jun, 2022 @4:31 PM