Scrapping PHE is not the answer to Covid failures | Letters

Philip Barber says the government is making the same mistakes by creating another overcentralised body, while Dr Anthony Isaacs believes Public Health England is just a convenient scapegoat. Plus Neil Wyatt highlights a more serious issue behind the restructuring

It is true that Public Health England has largely failed as the engine of test and trace, but the reasons are complex and systemic (Ministers criticised over plan to scrap Public Health England, 16 August).

PHE was set up in 2013 with statutory responsibility to meet government targets on public health, but its relationship with local public health departments was only advisory, a curious and dysfunctional paradox. It has always been isolated from core healthcare and thus built to fail, unable in practice to pull the necessary levers.

But now is not the time for yet another major restructuring, and the chosen model risks making exactly the same mistakes by creating another overcentralised body, remote from the clinical coalface. We badly need to reintegrate our response to Covid-19 into local public health and general practice, which have been delivering the goods since 1947, but are starved of information and funding. We are instead throwing good money after bad into the private sector. The most beneficial step in the short term would be to mandate the full collaboration of a reinvigorated PHE with local public health departments and the NHS, and the preparation of a joint action plan. It is still not too late to flatten a secondary wave.
Philip Barber
Consultant respiratory physician, Manchester

• In the manner of the revolution devouring its own children, the government has found a convenient scapegoat in PHE, spawn of the misguided Lansley reforms, to carry the can for its mismanagement of the Covid-19 crisis. Warnings were given from the start that the fragmentation of the public health function between central government and local authorities would lead to the loss of clear lines of control, with severe weakening of the ability to respond to a pandemic.

Tory peer Dido Harding, the head of England’s discredited test-and-trace programme, is now to be given the job of sorting out the mess (Dido Harding to run agency replacing Public Health England, 17 August). Given her role as a steward of the Jockey Club, which approved the Cheltenham festival, described by former chief scientific adviser David King as “the best possible way to accelerate the spread of the virus”, her new appointment sounds much like outsourcing responsibility for rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic to the iceberg. A new comprehensive public health system must be based on the achievement of public good rather than corporate interests and private profit.
Dr Anthony Isaacs

• The government’s competence and arrogance is spotlighted by the decision to axe PHE. On the face of it, this is a bewildering rearrangement of the deckchairs at a time of national crisis. But it’s almost certain that beyond governance and senior management, the National Institute for Health Protection will just be PHE with a reworded mission statement.

Beyond this is a deeper issue: we are assured that now is not the time for an enquiry into the handling of the Covid-19 crisis . Yet somehow the government has been able to find the time to reflect deeply on what has happened and conclude that the fundamental problem happens to be with a public body, rather than its own incompetence.

I’m only surprised they had the wits to select a body sufficiently detached from the NHS to avoid even further disquiet. All I can ask is – who feels that they, their families and loved ones are safer as a result of this masterclass in misdirection?
Neil Wyatt
Branston, Staffordshire


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Counting the cost of the UK’s Covid failures | Letters
Letters: Jeremy Cushing on the tragic consequences of the pandemic response, Prof W Richard Bowen on the need for more scientifically educated politicians, Joseph Palley on England’s excess deaths, and Betty Cairns on how the dead are being remembered in Italy


04, Aug, 2020 @4:45 PM

Article image
Government failures still hamper our Covid-19 response | Letters
Letters: Prof Sarah Gilbert on the lack of pandemic preparedness, Sarah Woolnough on the dearth of support for those struggling with long Covid, and Catherine Tann and Brian Clarke on the missing lateral flow tests


27, Jun, 2021 @3:02 PM

Article image
The shameful failures that threw care home residents to Covid | Letters
Letters: Readers on the government’s mistakes and neglect that meant elderly patients were discharged to care homes, without a Covid test, at the height of the pandemic


30, May, 2021 @3:51 PM

Article image
NHS workers don’t want applause, they want PPE | Letters
Letters: Readers on the shocking lack of personal protective equipment and government ineptitude that is leading to the deaths of frontline staff


19, Apr, 2020 @4:57 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson is trying to mug us off | Letters
Letters: Readers are unimpressed by the prime minister’s comeback speech in which he likened Covid-19 to a mugger


28, Apr, 2020 @5:34 PM

Article image
The UK's catastrophic failure to heed the coronavirus warnings | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by Nesrine Malik that said many coronavirus deaths could have been prevented had the government acted faster


14, Apr, 2020 @5:16 PM

Article image
‘Pingdemic’ is the result of a criminal Covid policy | Letters
Letters: One emergency worker says the NHS is already at breaking point. Plus letters by Joan Twelves, Prof Claire Anderson and Linda Wright


25, Jul, 2021 @3:55 PM

Article image
PPE debacle should be sewn up on the home front | Letters
Letters: John O’Driscoll says the UK has a dynamic garment industry and worldwide shortages cannot be blamed, while Fred Brook recalls a time when hospitals got what they needed and weavers got work and wages. Plus letters from John Paterson and Sarah James


24, Apr, 2020 @4:55 PM

Article image
Construction sites are aiding spread of Covid | Letters
Letters: A construction worker says they are being forced to work under unsafe conditions, Shirley Osborn highlights the gaps in financial support for low-paid workers and John Lynham laments the absence of effective government communication

11, Jan, 2021 @4:35 PM

Article image
Who should be first in line for the Covid vaccine? | Letters
Letters: An NHS doctor writes of their concerns about the decision to vaccinate health workers at a later time, while Martin Lippitt and Tony Green wonder why Rupert Murdoch has been among the first to receive the jab


21, Dec, 2020 @5:30 PM