South Korean media call for country to build its own nuclear weapons

Experts and commentators say a deterrent independent of the US is needed in face of uncertain support from Donald Trump

South Korea should take a page out of the work of Shakespeare in dealing with North Korea and fight “fire with fire”, experts and media commentators have said in response to the North’s latest nuclear test.

Many in the South are calling for the country to develop its own nuclear weapons as a deterrent independent of the US given uncertain support from Donald Trump.

South Korea hosts about 30,000 US troops and falls under the US nuclear umbrella, but in return is banned from building its own nuclear weapons under a 1974 agreement with Washington.

“As nuclear weapons are being churned out above our heads, we can’t always rely on the US nuclear umbrella and extended deterrence,” the Dong-a Ilbo, South Korea’s second-largest newspaper, said in an editorial.

The US stationed atomic weapons in the South after the 1950-53 Korean war, but withdrew them in 1991 when North and South Korea jointly declared they would make the peninsula nuclear-free.

The editorial said that agreement no longer applied.

“There is no reason for us to cling on to the declaration when it has come to mean the denuclearisation of South Korea, not the denuclearisation of the Korean peninsula,” it said.

North Korea tested its most powerful nuclear bomb on Sunday, producing a 6.3-magnitude earthquake that was felt as far as north-east China.

Almost 60% of South Koreans support starting a nuclear weapons programme, according to a poll in September 2016. Respondents aged 60 and above overwhelmingly supported the idea.

Jeon Yun-gu is just a few years away from his compulsory military service, and despite the rising tensions, the 16-year-old is ready to fight to end the constant threat hanging over the country.

“We should quit just talking and meet North Korea with a firm stand. We should respond to them with the same, they have nuclear weapons, so we should develop our own,” the teenager said. “I think we should attack.”

But others said the first step should be returning US nuclear arms to South Korea, despite Trump accusing the South Korean president, Moon Jae-in, of “appeasement”.

“With the North Korean nuclear threat getting worse, we should bring US tactical nuclear weapons back into South Korea,” Park Byung-kwang, director of centre for north-east Asia at the Institute for National Security Strategy in Seoul, a thinktank affiliated with the country’s intelligence agency.

South Korea had no choice but to work with the US to resolve the deepening crisis, despite Trump’s “unique character”, Park said.

While some in South Korea called for a home-grown nuclear arsenal, Park said it would be impractical given the South has no desire to become a pariah state.

“It would be difficult for South Korea to develop its own nuclear weapons because of international treaties,” Park said. “While sanctions don’t always work on North Korea, the South Korean economy is completely integrated with the rest of the world, making it vulnerable.”

But in rural communities along the demilitarised zone that separates the North and the South, provocations only serve to harden their resolve for a tougher response.

“North Korea has nuclear weapons and are doing experiments despite the entire world’s opposition,” said Woo Jong-il, who lives near the border. “Russia, America, China, they all have it, and even North Korea, a small country in deep poverty has it, so why aren’t we allowed to have it?

“Either America gives us a nuclear bomb or allows us develop one.”

With additional reporting by Soeun Seo in Seoul.


Benjamin Haas in Hong Kong

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
North Korea open to relinquishing nuclear weapons, says Seoul
Donald Trump says ‘possible progress being made’ after North Korea offers to freeze programmes if US comes to table

Benjamin Haas in Seoul and David Smith in Washington

06, Mar, 2018 @10:29 PM

Article image
Railway diplomacy: South Korean trains venture north for first time in a decade
Engineers onboard will inspect 1,200km of North Korean tracks as part of future plan to modernise regime’s network

Benjamin Haas in Seoul

30, Nov, 2018 @3:16 AM

Article image
North Korea says missile tested over weekend can carry nuclear warhead
Kim Jong-un, who oversaw rocket launch on Sunday, warns Washington that US mainland is in ‘sighting range for strike’

Justin McCurry in Tokyo and agencies in Seoul

15, May, 2017 @7:37 AM

Article image
North Korea: can Trump succeed where so many others have failed?
South Korea is talking about a peace treaty with Kim Jong-un but US president’s participation is a huge wild card

Robert Kelly

18, Apr, 2018 @9:06 AM

Article image
New South Korea leader Moon Jae-in willing to meet Kim in North
Former human rights lawyer vows to move quickly to solve national security crisis and bring lasting peace to peninsula

Justin McCurry in Kyoto and agencies

10, May, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
Everything you need to know about the inter-Korean summit
Kim Jong-un will meet Moon Jae-in on 27 April, in a historic summit that could bring about a formal truce and lay the groundwork for a Trump/Kim meeting

Benjamin Haas in Seoul

27, Apr, 2018 @12:12 AM

Article image
North Korea apologises for 'unfortunate' killing of South Korean official
Kim Jong-un says death ‘should not have happened’ after man shot in North Korean waters

Justin McCurry and agencies in Seoul

25, Sep, 2020 @7:44 AM

Article image
Kim Jong-un greets Moon Jae-in as inter-Korean summit starts
Leaders take part in highly choreographed opening to three days of talks in Pyongyang, North Korea

Benjamin Haas in Seoul

18, Sep, 2018 @1:49 AM

Article image
North Korea reopens hotline with South hours after Trump button boast
Move raises hopes of diplomatic thaw after Kim Jong-un said he would consider sending athletes to Winter Olympics

Justin McCurry in Tokyo and agencies

03, Jan, 2018 @9:57 AM

Article image
South Korea offers to hold talks with North after Olympics olive branch
Offer comes as Kim Jong-un says he is prepared to send delegation of athletes to Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang

Justin McCurry in Osaka and agencies

02, Jan, 2018 @8:04 AM