Sticken submarine crew 'killed in sub blast'

Video shows massive damage to stricken vessel
Special report: Russia's stricken submarine

The Russian authorities yesterday disclosed that the stricken Kursk submarine lying at the bottom of the Barents sea had suffered much greater damage than initially believed, making it highly likely that many of the crew, the vessel's commanding officers and other more senior navy officers died instantly last Saturday.

As hopes faded of bringing out any of the 118 crewmen alive, the defence minister, Igor Sergeyev, revived the first theory advanced for the cause of the disaster - a collision with another vessel.

"The scenario in which the Kursk submarine suffered a collision with another object is now the main one," the defence minister said. "Irrefutable data is already available."

At the northern fleet's main base of Severomorsk outside Murmansk last night, senior navy and government officials were examining five hours of video of the sunken submarine taken earlier in the week by an unmanned observation craft before deciding on their next course of action.

The video shows massive and severe damage to the submarine extending from the nose to the conning tower. "The accident happened so quickly we can say it was like a flash," said Captain Igor Dygalo, the navy spokesman.

A reporter from Russia's state RTR television said the film showed that the Kursk suffered severe damage. "Water flooded the front in a flash and the command centre, I mean the hull, was destroyed in a moment," the correspondent said from a ship on the Barents Sea.

"This is tragic news, when so much water gets into the sub, it is impossible to avoid casualties."

Russian sources said the crash theory focused on the notion that the submarine collided with a surface vessel while trying to come up from the depths. Norwegian experts speculated that the disaster was caused by crew error which sent the submarine careering quickly to the sea bed.

American and Norwegian observation ships detected two blasts at the time of the accident last Saturday, the second much more powerful than the first. Some attributed the explosions to a torpedo blowing up inside the submarine and triggering another explosion.

The Norwegian analysts, Bellona, said the first explosion could have been the thud of the submarine hitting the sea bed which then triggered the more powerful explosion of a pressurised storage tank.

"Nobody knows what caused the accident", a British naval source said, but since the Kursk was very strong, it must have been a "high energy accident".

As a British rescue crew with the LR5 mini sub headed towards the Kursk, the Ministry of Defence said the submarine was so badly damaged that one of its escape hatches was unusable. The LR5 rescue sub would aim for the apparently undamaged hatch at the stern of the vessel.

The craft was lying at an angle of 20 degress, less than earlier suggested. "It could have shifted during the week. It seems to be far more upright, that is good news", the sources said. But underwater currents were extremely strong - and have already severely hampered Russian rescue efforts.

Commander Alan Hoskins of the British rescue team told the BBC his team was trying to remain optimistic. "We hope that we will get there and still find that people have survived," he said.

Tony Blair telephoned the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, from Tuscany to express his concern and to stress that Britain was doing everything possible to assist the operation.

Although the Russian public and media are rapidly losing faith in pronouncements from the top brass,with a wave of resentment and disgust sweeping across Russia at the way the authorities have handled the crisis, the theory that there had been a collision was supported by the fact that the submarine's periscopes were raised.

The retired admiral Eduard Baltin, the former commander of the Black sea fleet, blamed the disaster on bad planning, lack of training and incompetence. "The Kursk is designed for the ocean, not for shallow waters," he said. "Where it was manoeuvring and where it perished is completely wild - strong currents and strong winds. You can't carry out torpedo firing there."

He said the submarine would have been forced to surface to try to identify its torpedo targets, but the 108-metre depth of the sea at that point meant its commanders would not have heard another vessel above.

The vessel's commanding officers would normally be in a section just below the conning tower and experts said their chances of survival were minimal. Other senior navy personnel were on board to observe the war games.

Three days of attempts by Russian rescue capsules to dock with the crippled submarine's escape hatches have yielded no results and the British and Norwegian rescue mission is not expected to reach the site until lunchtime tomorrow, almost exactly a week to the hour since the accident occurred.

"The situation is almost catastrophic," said the prime minister, Mikhail Kasyanov.

The revelations of the massive damage raised fears of radioactive contamination from the two 190-megawatt nuclear reactors which powered the submarine. But Norwegian and Russian authorities said no increase had been detected in radiation levels and that contamination was a long-term problem rather than an immediate one.

The Barents sea, Bellona said, was one of the cleanest in the world and the low levels of radiation detected flowed in on the Gulf stream from Britain's and France's nuclear reprocessing plants at Sellafield and Le Hague.


Ian Traynor in Moscow

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Russian submarine crew faces dreadful fate
Russia's refusal of help to rescue a sunken nuclear submarine shows it cares more about its wounded pride than the 116 crew members on board, thinks Derek Brown.
Submarine rescue bid 'under way'

Derek Brown

15, Aug, 2000 @2:27 PM

Russian sub: all crew confirmed dead
The chief of staff of Russia's Northern Fleet, Mikhail Motsak, has confirmed that all 118 submariners stranded on the sunken Kursk submarine have died.

Staff and agencies

21, Aug, 2000 @1:03 PM

Kursk crew died 'within minutes'
All the 118 seamen in the Russian nuclear submarine Kursk died almost instantly when it sank in the Arctic on August 12, the Russian authorities said yesterday.

Ian Traynor in Moscow

07, Sep, 2000 @12:40 AM

Russian sub sinks with crew aboard
Two dead and seven missing in icy waters as ghosts of Kursk tragedy return to haunt Putin.

Kevin O'Flynn in Moscow

31, Aug, 2003 @11:00 AM

Crew found dead in stricken sub
Ten days of drama in the Arctic reached a grim climax last night when all 118 Russian crew who went down with the Kursk nuclear submarine in the Barents Sea on August 12 were declared dead in the country's worst naval disaster.

Ian Traynor in Murmansk

22, Aug, 2000 @12:46 AM

Fury as Russians admit crew dead
The race to save the crew of the stricken Russian submarine Kursk reached a chilling climax last night when military leaders admitted there was no longer any realistic hope of finding the men alive. The grim statement came as a British rescue mission arrived above where the nuclear-powered submarine sank eight days ago.

by Jason Burke and Amelia Gentleman Murmansk

19, Aug, 2000 @11:04 PM

Note reveals 23 survived initial Kursk blast
A note that was found on one of four bodies raised from the sunken Russian nuclear submarine Kursk, revealed today that at least 23 people remained alive after powerful explosions killed most of the crew.

Staff and agencies

26, Oct, 2000 @10:49 AM

Fresh rescue bid fails to reach submarine crew
Underwater rescue capsules again failed to reach the 118 seamen trapped on a Russian nuclear submarine today.

17, Aug, 2000 @4:52 PM

Focus: Russia's submarine catastrophe
Yesterday they all but gave up hope for survivors of the doomed Kursk. Jason Burke, Ian Traynor and Amelia Gentleman report on the devastating events that destroyed the submarine and humiliated Russia's military might: Putin thought putting himself at the head of a lost cause would hurt his image. His inaction was politically costly. For the first time, he was seen to falter

19, Aug, 2000 @11:04 PM

Voices from beyond
The words themselves were matter-of-fact but the short message desperately scrawled on one side of a sodden piece of paper sent a chill through us all. Like Scott's heroic contemplation of his end, Lieutenant-Captain Dmitri Kolesnikov's missive from the wreck of the Kursk offers us a taste of the terrifying moments before a certain death. Stephen Moss on how dying became a public affair

Stephen Moss

27, Oct, 2000 @4:16 PM