Blair government despaired at ‘juvenile’ media in efforts to keep ministers on-message

Aide’s suggestion of ‘accuracy’ regulations for press was dismissed as ‘probably suicidal to try’

Tony Blair’s government struggled to control a “juvenile” media as cabinet ministers failed to “do message”, often “kiboshing” each other’s announcements, previously secret documents reveal.

A despairing Alastair Campbell, Blair’s press secretary, told him the basic lack of professionalism of ministers in dealing with media interviews was “beyond a joke”.

At one point, senior aides asked if newspapers could be controlled by some form of “accuracy” regulations but the idea was dismissed as “probably suicidal to try”.

Notes for Blair’s presentation in September 1998 to a cabinet away day at Chequers, the prime minister’s country house, stated: “We have a serious problem with juvenile media. The smallest decision can become big headlines. They refuse to report the substance of what you do.”

Campbell advised Blair privately that he must tackle the problem of senior ministers not informing No 10 of their media interviews and briefings. Blair should tell the cabinet that “in relation to all major media bids, we want them cleared and coordinated,” he wrote.

Of ministers, he wrote: “Above all, they do not do message.” He added: “There is a basic lack of professionalism problem re message discipline which is beyond a joke.”

Conservative messages against Labour “are beginning to take hold”, Campbell wrote to Blair in October 2000. Referring to the Tory leader William Hague’s shadow cabinet, which at the time included Michael Portillo, Francis Maude and Ann Widdecombe, Campbell said: “And if the Conservative leading personalities were not so unattractive, we would not have recovered from the fuel crisis in the way we have.”

He added: “Too many ministers are almost completely depoliticised in their language and activities.”

In a suggested cabinet speaking note for Blair on lack of coordination, Campbell wrote: “There is nothing worse than one minister thinking that his/her event has been planned as the major event of the day, and another minister kyboshes [sic] it.”

On the question of media ownership, No 10 aides discussed how to prevent TV stations from becoming “political” in the same way as newspaper were. Jeremy Heywood, Blair’s principal private secretary, emailed the media policy adviser Ed Richards: “I assume it’s unthinkable to impose accuracy regulations on newspapers? No other industry would get away with the practice of making up stories that even our most serious newspapers indulge in. Is there no country in the world that has a successful model of newspaper reg?”

Richards replied: “Personally I think it is nigh on impossible to introduce controls on the newspapers of the kind you propose (and probably suicidal to try).”

Ever mindful of media coverage, one memo before a cabinet away day at Chequers in 1998 stipulated: “Alastair needs a story for the day. TV will film people arriving and going so there can be no woolly jumpers.”


Caroline Davies and Ben Quinn

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Blair aide feared 1997 cabinet portrait would look ‘triumphalist’
National Archives documents show concerns raised over Scottish National Portrait Gallery’s proposal

Caroline Davies and Ben Quinn

30, Dec, 2022 @6:01 AM

Article image
Blair gave Putin silver cufflinks for his birthday, archives reveal
Files show PM favoured allowing Putin ‘a position on the top table’ and encouraging him to integrate with west

Ben Quinn and Caroline Davies

30, Dec, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
Blair asked Bush during first phone call if he could call him by first name
Archives reveal PM’s early attempts to establish personal relationship with president after 2000 US election

Ben Quinn and Caroline Davies

30, Dec, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
New Labour infighting and sleaze concerns laid bare in archive papers
No 10 aides warned Tony Blair that Gordon Brown may have breached ministerial code, files show

Kevin Rawlinson and Caroline Davies

30, Dec, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Tony Blair was warned repeal of anti-gay section 28 might harm election chances
Archives reveal David Blunkett voiced concerns about overturning ban on ‘promotion’ of homosexuality

Jamie Grierson

18, Jul, 2022 @11:01 PM

Article image
Blair government had misgivings about Mandela mediation role over Lockerbie
Files show Downing Street felt former South African leader’s attempt to mediate was ‘unlikely to be helpful’

Caroline Davies and Ben Quinn

30, Dec, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
Corbyn spy claims: Labour steps up war of words with media
Jeremy Corbyn’s office blames rightwing press ‘owned by tax exiles’ for ‘absurd stories’

Heather Stewart and Matthew Weaver

21, Feb, 2018 @5:32 PM

Article image
Jeremy Corbyn versus the media – will he take on Murdoch?
Labour’s new leader has been marginalised and demonised by the rightwing press, but has he also fallen out with the BBC?

Roy Greenslade

13, Sep, 2015 @8:21 AM

Article image
Downing Street initially opposed Stephen Lawrence inquiry
Tony Blair’s policy chief thought inquiry into police racism would raise unrealistic hopes for change

Kevin Rawlinson and Caroline Davies

30, Dec, 2021 @12:01 AM

Article image
Spying row: how Corbyn seized chance to take on the Sun
Labour used to woo the rightwing press; the age of social media has changed all that

Dan Sabbagh

21, Feb, 2018 @7:26 PM