Replacing old ITV Studios building ‘just greedy’, inquiry hears

Plans to redevelop 72 Upper Ground ignore material and climate impact, detractors say

Developers have been urged to “stop demolishing youthful concrete towers at whim” on the opening day of a planning inquiry which will examine plans to replace ITV’s former headquarters on London’s South Bank with a £400m office complex.

Objectors say the plans for 72 Upper Ground, nicknamed “the Slab”, will generate more carbon emissions in its construction than if the 4,000 officer workers it is designed to house were to drive in from Surrey for 30 years.

The inquiry, which comes hot on the heels of a probe into Marks & Spencer’s plans to raze and redevelop its Marble Arch store on London’s Oxford Street, will again highlight the carbon impact of redevelopment as well as the rapidly changing landscape of central London.

Michael Ball, speaking for the Save our Southbank campaign group, acknowledged the inquiry had mainly been prompted by concerns about the visual impact of a prominent site on a bend in the River Thames between St Paul’s and the Palace of Westminster.

But he argued that the climate impact should be taken into consideration as well. “Does it meet the rapidly overriding material consideration, the very real materiality of climate emergency, the existential threat to our way of life, our civilization, our planet?”

He said: “As events overtake a slow-moving planning process, we need urgent and significant changes to the way we do things … We must do better than generating 173,000 tonnes of carbon emissions just through construction.”

Attended by more than 50 local people on Monday as well as those speaking for developers Mitsubishi Estate and CO-RE and the local council, the inquiry – which will take until early January– will hear from local MP Florence Eshalomi, who has said the building will cause a “substantial degree of unnecessary harm”, and the area’s former MP Kate Hoey, now a baroness, who has said “it’s just greedy”.

The inquiry, called by the communities secretary, Greg Clark, in August, comes despite the planning committee of the London borough of Lambeth giving the development the go-ahead earlier this year with approval backed by London’s mayor, Sadiq Khan. Demolition of the current building was paused in April by Michael Gove while ministers considered whether to call in the application.

Rupert Warren KC, speaking for the developers, said the scheme, which includes a 26-storey tower linked to a 13-storey block, was designed to “the highest standards in terms of sustainability” and that it had been decided that it was difficult to reuse the existing building for office space.

He added that some design studios, which make up a small part of the planned building, would be a “marvellous new facility for creative people and groups in Lambeth.” which would “help the South Bank’s recovery from the pandemic.”

• The main image on this article was replaced on 7 December 2022, as the original image did not show the former ITV studios as the caption said.


Sarah Butler

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Not just any building: why plans for the M&S flagship store hit a raw nerve
Bid to raze and rebuild Oxford St store stirs debate over carbon footprints and future development of UK high streets

Sarah Butler

24, Jun, 2022 @1:45 PM

Article image
Selfridges backs M&S plan to raze and rebuild Oxford Street store
Public inquiry starts on Tuesday into proposals for 90-year-old shop, which campaigners oppose

Sarah Butler

25, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Barratt reports slump in new home orders as mortgage rates rise
Shares slide after developer warns of ‘less certain’ outlook as housing market hit by jump in borrowing costs

Joanna Partridge

12, Oct, 2022 @10:54 AM

Article image
Sadiq Khan warns 'greedy' developers as he outlines housing plan
London’s mayor criticises Boris Johnson and says he wants more than half of homes on some new developments to be affordable

Robert Booth

16, May, 2016 @2:26 PM

Article image
The £3bn rebirth of King's Cross: dictator chic and pie-in-the-sky penthouses
Google HQ, boutique shops in old coal sheds, gasholders offering wedge-shaped flats at sky-high prices … as the vast project comes together after 18 years, our critic gives his verdict

Oliver Wainwright

09, Feb, 2018 @3:30 PM

Article image
22 Bishopsgate: a perfumed 62-storey village for City workers
With climbing wall, 41st floor retreat and its own signature scent, London’s biggest ever office building opens just as home working looks set to stay

Rowan Moore

23, May, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
‘I have to move my bike to get to the fridge’ – the UK boom in microflats
From rentals the size of a tiny hotel room to Barratt’s pocket-sized new-builds, the market is expanding

Julia Kollewe

15, Nov, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
High times: 76 tall buildings to join London's skyline in 2019
Number of towers of 20 or more storeys that are planned or under construction hits new record of 541

Julia Kollewe

05, Mar, 2019 @3:54 PM

Article image
Complex chain of companies that worked on Grenfell Tower raises oversight concerns
Experts warn of impact of multiple contractors, reduced council oversight, disparate build teams and privatisation

Rob Davies

16, Jun, 2017 @7:54 AM

Article image
£1.5m Battersea power station apartments held back from market
Developers withhold from sale 150 flats designed by Frank Gehry and Norman Foster because of downturn at top end

Julia Kollewe

21, Apr, 2016 @3:44 PM