Covid: Liverpool mass testing trial 'could do more harm than good'

Health experts raise concerns as large queues form on first day of pilot scheme

The UK’s first mass Covid testing trial in Liverpool risks being “an expensive mess that does more harm than good”, health experts said as it got under way on Friday.

Six new testing centres opened their doors to Liverpudlians at midday on Friday as part of the government’s Operation Moonshot drive to eventually test up to 10 million people a day.

Huge queues had formed before some of the centres had opened, indicating significant early demand. The Liverpool football club manager, Jurgen Klopp, joined council bosses in urging the city’s 500,000-strong population to volunteer for a test, but it remains to be seen how many will come forward.

Joe Anderson, the Liverpool mayor, said: “This is an incredible opportunity to turbo-charge our efforts to reduce coronavirus in the city.”

However, five public health experts, including Allyson Pollock, a professor of public health at Newcastle University, raised significant doubts about the trial in a letter to Liverpool MPs.

They said the plans to test asymptomatic people in Liverpool went against advice from the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (Sage) to prioritise the testing of people displaying symptoms, and “searching for symptomless yet infectious people is like searching for needles that appear transiently in haystacks”.

“The potential for harmful diversion of resources and public money is vast. Also of concern are the potential vested interests of commercial companies supplying new and as yet inadequately evaluated tests.”

Angela Raffle, a public health consultant in Bristol, said she had looked carefully at the Liverpool proposals and concluded they were not fit for purpose.

“Experience with screening tells us that if you embark on a screening programme without having carefully evaluated it first, without a proper quality-assured pathway, without certainty of test performance in field settings, without full information for participants, and without the means to ensure that the intervention needed for those with positive results does indeed take place, the result is an expensive mess that does more harm than good,” she said.

The pilot began amid confusion about whether NHS staff with no symptoms would be offered a saliva test, as originally intended as part of the trial.

The OptiGene Lamp tests, for which the government has paid £323m, are separate to the nasal swab tests used by the public, and there are questions about their accuracy. A trial in Greater Manchester found they missed half of infections, but the government said they had performed better in other pilots, without releasing the data.

Matt Ashton, Liverpool’s director of public health, said on Friday: “There are lots of different testing technologies coming onboard. The saliva one is the one that’s commonly referred to as Lamp testing, but Lamp testing is not part of the Liverpool pilot.”

Similarly, a spokesman for Liverpool university hospitals NHS foundation trust said it was not using the OptiGene Lamp tests on NHS staff or patients. This appeared to contradict the Department of Health and Social Care, which had said the OptiGene Lamp test would be used as part of the trial by NHS staff.

Significantly, people who do not have coronavirus symptoms are being urged to get tested. It is estimated that about one in four people who get the disease will never show symptoms, according to Bertie Squire, a professor of clinical tropical medicine at Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine.


Josh Halliday and Sarah Boseley

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Scientists in Liverpool mass Covid testing trial defend rapid tests
Professor says programme was very helpful, despite criticism about accuracy of lateral flow tests

Alexandra Topping

23, Dec, 2020 @6:48 PM

Article image
London council sets up own same-day Covid testing service
Exclusive: Barking and Dagenham says it acted because of delays at official test centres

Diane Taylor

22, Oct, 2020 @11:25 AM

Article image
Liverpool Covid admissions will 'devastate' other hospital care
Non-urgent operations at risk unless infection and admission rates fall, top doctor says

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

15, Oct, 2020 @11:25 AM

Article image
People urged to report Covid home test results after PCR follow-ups halted in England
The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) said the shift reflected the high accuracy of the tests

Hannah Devlin and Rachel Hall

05, Jan, 2022 @1:30 PM

Article image
Nightingale to reopen as Liverpool sets new Covid patient record
Hospital in Manchester will help ease pressure on existing facilities in north-west England

Josh Halliday North of England correspondent

22, Oct, 2020 @1:37 PM

Article image
Rapid Covid tests used in mass UK programme get scathing US report
Innova tests’ performance not proven and they should be returned to manufacturer or thrown in bin, says FDA

Natalie Grover and Aubrey Allegretti

11, Jun, 2021 @12:24 PM

Article image
Scientists raise concerns about quality of UK Covid-19 tests
Warning that infections could be missed amid questions about credibility of testing operation

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

19, Apr, 2020 @4:17 PM

Article image
Rapid Covid testing in England may be scaled back over false positives
Exclusive: In leaked emails, Matt Hancock’s adviser says there is ‘urgent need for decisions’ on asymptomatic testing

Josh Halliday

15, Apr, 2021 @4:48 PM

Article image
The remote Cumbrian town with the UK's highest Covid-19 infection rate
Barrow-in-Furness has fewer visitors than the nearby Lake District, yet has one of the worst death rates outside London

Helen Pidd

12, May, 2020 @3:39 PM

Article image
Matt Hancock launches contact-tracing app with Isle of Wight trial
Concerns raised over privacy, but health secretary claims there is ‘huge enthusiasm’

Heather Stewart, Alex Hern and Denis Campbell

04, May, 2020 @6:38 PM