Theresa May accuses fire and rescue services of significant failings

Home secretary says lack of diversity and accountability as well as ‘bullying culture’ in parts of country make reform necessary

The home secretary, Theresa May, has criticised fire and rescue services for being 96% white, 95% male and allowing a “culture of bullying and harassment” in some parts of England and Wales.

May said this lack of diversity, the existence of what she described as a toxic and corrosive culture in some parts of the fire and rescue services and a lack of accountability made necessary a programme of reform that was as “radical and ambitious as I have delivered in policing since 2010”.

In a speech to the Reform thinktank in London, she confirmed her intention to allow elected police and crime commissioners (PCCs) to take over fire and rescue services, where a local case to do so is made, and to introduce an independent inspection regime, which she said was currently impossible.

The speech was May’s first major statement of direction since the Home Office took over responsibility for fire and rescue services this year.

The home secretary, Theresa May.
The home secretary, Theresa May. Photograph: Will Oliver/EPA

She acknowledged the “fine tradition and proud record” of firefighters who were held in “profound affection” by their local communities. But she argued that their achievements were in spite of the framework they operated within and not because of it.

“A fire and rescue landscape still beset by poor governance and structures. A workforce lacking diversity and still bound by many of the old ways of working. A service that requires further reform to improve accountability, bring independent scrutiny and drive transparency,” she said.

The home secretary said the overall size of the workforce had not changed in the last 10 years despite a 42% decrease in the number of incidents attended. She said greater use of flexible shift patterns and relying on on-call firefighters even in major towns and cities could secure significant savings without reducing the availability of frontline firefighters.

May said the fire and rescue workforce had to modernise and she hoped she could work with the Fire Brigades Union to tackle the lack of diversity and end the culture of “bullying and harassment” in some parts of the country.

But modernisation had to also extend to chief fire officers who, she said, could no longer be allowed to retire one day only to be rehired in the same job just a few days later with financial benefits that the rank and file could never expect. “It looks wrong; it erodes public confidence; it undermines the respect of firefighters and staff in their leadership. It must stop,” she said.

The existing fire authorities, which are made up of appointed councillors, bore “all the hallmarks of the flawed police authorities that I abolished in 2012”, she added.

May said making the fire and rescue services accountable to PCCs would not amount to a police takeover or a top-down merger of the roles of police officers and firefighters.

“The important distinction between operational policing and firefighting will be maintained; fire officers will not be given the power of arrest and the law will continue to prevent full-time police officers from training as firefighters. Funding streams for police and fire will not be merged and PCCs will raise a separate fire precept, so local people can hold them to account for how their money is spent,” she said.

Matt Wrack, FBU general secretary, said: “The home secretary may be surprised that we agree with her on some of the issues she raised. We have been calling for an independent inspectorate for some time, as the current system had led to huge imbalances on the standards imposed on services across the county. We support any move that will mean all fire and rescue services are inspected, validated and held accountable in a standardised fashion.

“We are all, however, surprised about the claims that the home secretary has made about the size of the fire and rescue workforce not having changed in the past decade. The record cuts that this government have imposed on the fire and rescue services have resulted in far fewer frontline firefighters and is contributing to a poorer and less reliable public service.

“Whilst we want to work with the home secretary for a greater diversity in our fire and rescue service, it needs to be pointed out that it was her government who in 2010 chose to remove the diversity targets that were in place, sending a clear signal to employers that diversity was of being downgraded,” Wrack added.


Alan Travis Home afairs editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Home Office blamed as emergency services network costs rise
Overspend of £3.1bn and delay down to department’s failings, says National Audit Office

Rajeev Syal

09, May, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Emergency services face 'potentially catastrophic' communication gap
MPs warn that six-month delay of cheaper ESN system approved by Theresa May could be ‘tragedy in waiting’

Rajeev Syal

20, Apr, 2017 @11:01 PM

Article image
Ministers complacent over high-rise fire risk, say firefighters
Fire Brigades Union questions government’s claims that resources are sufficient

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

20, May, 2019 @11:01 PM

Article image
Fears grow over safety of timber-framed blocks of flats after Grenfell fire
Fire safety experts and opposition parties call for update of regulations as they raise concerns about popular building method

Peter Walker Political correspondent

17, Jul, 2017 @5:00 PM

Article image
Fire services: 999 callers waiting longer than five years ago
Average response for serious fires in England more than half a minute slower than in 2013-14

Polly Bindman

16, Jan, 2020 @7:06 PM

Article image
London fire brigade one of the worst in UK, inspectors say
Country’s biggest brigade ‘inadequate at getting the right people with the right skills’

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

17, Dec, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Every fire brigade in England plagued by bullying and harassment claims, report finds
Inspectors say ‘deeply troubling’ behaviour found at fire and rescue services across England may be ‘tip of the iceberg’

Kevin Rawlinson

30, Mar, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
New network planned for emergency services 'inherently high risk'
Spending watchdog criticises Home Office plans to replace Airwave system with untested emergency services network

Rajeev Syal

14, Sep, 2016 @11:01 PM

Article image
Review casts doubt on London fire brigade's high-rise capabilities
Inspectors find LFB cannot assure itself that response to a Grenfell-like fire would be vastly improved

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

11, Feb, 2021 @6:42 PM

Article image
MPs call for inquiry into claims of bullying in UK fire services
New details emerge from report on London’s brigades as opposition parties demand national review

Rajeev Syal

28, Nov, 2022 @6:51 PM