Dear Edward review – the dire folk-pop soundtrack ruins every tender TV moment

There are plenty of authentic emotional moments in Jason Katims’s drama about a bereavement support group. Until the dreadful, mewling music starts up …

A plane goes down in a field killing everyone on board. Or everyone except one little boy – soon nicknamed “miracle boy” by the press – who, having lost his parents and brother in the crash, will now be raised by an aunt. In an instant, hundreds of lives are over and thousands more are changed forever. How can loss on that scale be fathomed?

In 2020, the writer Ann Napolitano made an attempt. She turned her grim fascination with the real-life 2010 tragedy of Flight 771 into a novel called Dear Edward. In her fictionalised version, the disaster takes place on a flight from New York to Los Angeles and the nine-year-old Dutch survivor becomes a 12-year-old American boy. The novel was well received, praised for its sensitive study of sorrow and healing, and has now been adapted into a 10-episode ensemble drama by Jason Katims, best known as the Emmy-winning showrunner of high-school football series Friday Night Lights.

At the centre of the ensemble is Edward, a curly-haired, sickly-looking piano prodigy (Colin O’Brien) who is traumatised first by the crash (unsparingly played out in the first episode) and then by a deluge of attention from strangers who unburden themselves both in writing – the “Dear Edward” letters of the title – and in person. They tell him he’s lucky to be alive. He feels anything but.

That’s far too much to put on any one person, least of all a child. Fortunately, the drama is evenly shared between the eight core members of a bereavement support group. Some of them you can’t help but care for, including two played by already established, always engaging TV stars, Connie Britton (Nashville, American Horror Story, Friday Night Lights) and Taylor Schilling (Orange Is the New Black). Britton is Dee Dee, an upfront, often tipsy, emotionally raw housewife, while Schilling is Edward’s aunt turned adoptive mum Lacey, a woman whose marriage and mental health were already on the brink before this huge new responsibility landed in her lap. Crucially, both actors invest their characters with some much-needed animation and individuality, modulating the programme’s otherwise monotonous tone of grief, grief and yet more unimaginable grief.

There are other winning performances. British actor Idris DeBrand charms as Uncle Kojo, the self-described “Portaloo prince of Ghana”. But there are many underwritten and uninvolving other characters whose scenes will have you counting the minutes till you can be back in Dee Dee’s New Jersey mansion, drinking wine and talking trash about her dead husband.

Perhaps these generic grievers would be more memorable if they looked more distinctive? Dear Edward is dutifully diverse in racial terms but has been cast from the same pool of uniformly slim, symmetrical people as most US network television, with the effect of undermining its otherwise sincere efforts to depict the reality of life’s struggles. Any of these dreamboats could walk into a modelling contract at a moment’s notice.

It’s also a shame that some tantalising loose story threads are left hanging. Like what’s the deal with pregnant Linda’s (Amy Forsyth) interfering LA in-laws who receive the astounding news about their dead son, then are never heard from again? Or what about that oxy-addicted paramedic (played by Mare of Easttown’s Joe Tippett) who responds to the crash site while still high? How did his story pan out? Maybe it’s the nature of an ensemble drama to flit from person to person with nary a backward glance, but in the case of Dear Edward’s already broken-hearted characters, it feels like a particularly callous series of abandonments.

Connie Britton and Audrey Corsa.
Dreamboats … Connie Britton and Audrey Corsa. Photograph: Apple TV+

It’s not that TV drama must always uplift, or find triumph in tragedy. Some of the best is determinedly dour, with only the blackest humour for relief (see Sally Wainwright’s not-so-Happy Valley). But in contrast to the easy catharsis of a 90-minute movie tearjerker, downer television does need to earn our tears. Dear Edward achieves the necessary moments of authentic emotion with some regularity (usually courtesy of Connie Britton), but each and every one is ruined when a folk-pop needle-drop comes mewling in like the uninvited guest at a funeral.

We have plenty of examples of how well-chosen music can further elevate quality television (I’m still humming the White Lotus theme), and now here’s a reminder that the opposite is also true. If it lost the genuinely obnoxious soundtrack, Dear Edward would be at least 25% improved.

• Dear Edward is on Apple TV+


Ellen E Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Confession review – you’ll study every gesture in this true-crime documentary
Keith Hall confessed his wife’s murder to an officer wearing a wire – and was found innocent. This programme will leave you scrutinising his every second on screen to make your mind up about him

Jack Seale

25, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
The White Lotus review – a magnificently monstrous look at how the other half live
Rich guests – including a spaced-out Jennifer Coolidge – rub shoulders with downtrodden workers on a holiday from hell, in Mike White’s superb satire about inequality

Lucy Mangan

16, Aug, 2021 @9:05 PM

Article image
Granite Harbour review – the best dressed cop double-act in TV history
One corpse, multiple suspects and countless chic accessories: this gloriously gloomy whodunnit tries one last – surely the last? – variation on odd-couple detectives

Stuart Jeffries

02, Dec, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Beyond Paradise review – Kris Marshall’s detective spinoff swaps sunshine for awful fart gags
The best thing about Death in Paradise was always its tropical setting. Now it moves to Devon for a Doc Martin-aping, unfunny sister show featuring one of its ex stars

Jack Seale

24, Feb, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
Swarm review – Donald Glover’s Beyoncé-inspired serial killer satire is cold and dull
The Atlanta creator is clearly targeting Knowles obsessives in this menacing series about the dark side of music fandom. But its point is obvious and its lead character totally unengaging

Jack Seale

17, Mar, 2023 @1:00 PM

Article image
Stonehouse review – Matthew Macfadyen is a brilliantly bad baddie in this fun, death-faking romp
Macfadyen and Keeley Hawes are a cheeky, campy delight in the endlessly entertaining story of the inept MP – and worst spy ever – who disappeared from a Miami beach

Rebecca Nicholson

02, Jan, 2023 @10:05 PM

Article image
Happy Valley review – Sally Wainwright’s masterwork is back!
From its impeccable acting talent to a writer who captures the female experience like no one else, this drama’s final series is as excellent as ever

Lucy Mangan

01, Jan, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Better review – this moreish bent copper show gets stronger and stronger
Ignore the anti-climactic intro to this police drama. Its tale of a dodgy detective who wants to change really starts to blossom as it goes on

Rebecca Nicholson

13, Feb, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Unforgotten series five review – still cracking crime drama, even without Nicola Walker
The much-loved gaffer was killed off at the end of the last series, but Chris Lang’s show is as taut and tense and pleasurable as ever

Rebecca Nicholson

27, Feb, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Funny Woman review – Gemma Arterton is absolutely captivating in this Nick Hornby adaptation
The actor exudes star power in this take on the popular novel. It blossoms into a colourful romp through the swinging 60s that is very much TV as comfort food

Rebecca Nicholson

09, Feb, 2023 @10:00 PM