Power Slap: is this the most stomach-churning reality TV show ever?

This series about face-smacking contestants has been described as a ‘horrible idea that needs to be stopped’. But at least no one drinks donkey urine – unlike on other shows …

If you have your ear to the ground, there is a good chance you will be aware of a new TV show called Power Slap. If you haven’t heard of it, allow me to explain it. But strap yourself in, because hoo boy.

Power Slap is a televised “sport” in which two people slap one other as hard as they can, with the aim of incapacitating their opponent to the point of unconsciousness. The players take turns unloading slaps so hard that it is uncomfortable to watch, while the opponent must stand with their arms by their side, since the rules forbid any form of defence (or even flinching).

Power Slap has no British broadcaster, but in the US, where it is shown on TBS, it has caused a firestorm, not least because it is objectively stupid and dangerous, with slap fighters often ending up swollen and disfigured, and neurologists condemning the potential injuries they could sustain through repeated concussive impact to the head. And the people who run the league aren’t exactly lovely either. The show’s premiere was delayed, in fact, due to a video of Power Slap producer Dana White hitting his wife.

A recent New Yorker piece did a good job of corralling the outrage. The boxer Ryan Garcia said: “Power slap is a horrible idea and it needs to be stopped.” Ariel Helwani, a sports journalist who reports on mixed martial arts, took aim at the state from which Power Slap is broadcast, saying: “Shame on Nevada for sanctioning that.” Even JT Tilley, who operates his own slap-fight league, admits that “90% of people can’t stand this sport”.

But Power Slap is not just a sport. It is also a reality show, with the fighters all living together in a nice house, like the contestants on The Apprentice. The difference is that when the fighters leave the house, it is to hit each other as hard as they can.

Does this make Power Slap the most awful reality show in the history of television? Not by a long shot. It sounds awful and exploitative, but is it any more awful and exploitative than Cheaters? That was the show in which members of the public could spy on their partners to see if they were unfaithful, before catching them in the act and – more often than not – having a screaming, knock-down fight with them. There was nothing about Cheaters that didn’t turn the stomach, yet it ran for more than 20 years.

Is it worse than Fear Factor, a gameshow in which contestants had to commit to some of the most stomach-churning acts imaginable to win some cash? One episode, queasily titled Hee Haw! Hee Haw!, was so hideous that it was only shown on TV once, thanks to a challenge in which guests had to chug donkey semen and urine.

But the most gruesome reality show of all time is probably The Moment of Truth, a 2008 US gameshow so sickening that 15 of its episodes were never aired.

The premise? A subject is strapped to a polygraph and asked 100 questions of increasing intimacy. The more of these questions they agree to answer on air, the more money they win. In one episode, introduced by its own host as a piece of TV that didn’t deserve to see the light of day, a woman admitted to stealing money from work, to wishing she had married someone other than her husband (who was in the audience with his head in his hands), and to having sex with other men since being married. She was eliminated for answering yes to the question “Are you a good person?”. It was unimaginably horrible from start to finish.

In fact, Power Slap may not even qualify as the worst reality show of the moment. Netflix is producing Squid Game: The Challenge, in which the fictional lethal knockout game is played for real by members of the public. While the reality version draws a line at killing the participants, there have been reports that multiple contestants have required medical assistance during filming, with others likening it to a war zone. It certainly sounds as if it will be very difficult to watch.

Does Power Slap sound good? No. But the worst ever? Let’s retain some perspective.

Contributor

Stuart Heritage

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Squid Game: The Challenge review – the most gripping reality TV since The Traitors
The real-life version of the Netflix drama is a grandiose, addictive spectacle that will have you shouting at your TV before the end of episode one. Expect treachery, hilarity and a $4.5m jackpot

Rebecca Nicholson

20, Nov, 2023 @8:01 AM

Article image
‘Watch through your fingers’ – Squid Game: The Challenge is the guiltiest TV pleasure of all time
Impossible to resist and with a revelatory cast, this is the absolute apex of brutal, addictive competition shows. Even if, ultimately, the joke is on us

Phil Harrison

07, Dec, 2023 @3:50 PM

Article image
Tinkling the ivories and tugging the heart strings: is The Piano the most uplifting TV talent show ever?
Railway station pianists from 11 to 92 get a surprise shot at fame in this Claudia Winkleman-hosted Channel 4 hit, where even the judges find something nice to say

Joel Snape

23, Feb, 2023 @5:10 PM

Article image
100% ruthless: why the nasty US Traitors ruins the reality show
It’s full of reality TV stars, packed with mean competitiveness and has none of the charming sincerity of the UK version. Hopefully it’s not a warning sign for series two …

Rebecca Nicholson

19, Jan, 2023 @11:30 AM

Article image
Hot Mess Summer: this misery-packed reality show is a total waste of Rylan’s dazzling charisma
The magic of holiday romance has left reality TV as eight young adults with rib tattoos are punished for silly misdemeanours and get bored in a lavish villa

Joel Golby

03, Feb, 2024 @7:00 AM

Article image
Jerrod Carmichael Reality Show review – the most astonishing, emotionally raw reality TV ever made
The comedian’s tell-all show reveals gobsmacking things most people would take to the grave. It may be masochistic – but it’s impossible to look away

Leila Latif

24, May, 2024 @9:40 PM

Article image
Scared of the Dark review – the stupidest reality show of all time
Boring, derivative and occasionally downright horrible, this series convinces celebrities to spend a week fumbling around a pitch-black bunker. It’s tedious in the extreme

Lucy Mangan

16, Apr, 2023 @9:15 PM

Article image
The Underdog: Josh Must Win review – this sham reality show is like old-school Big Brother, but better
Nick Grimshaw and his celebrity pals need to make sure an ‘underdog’ wins a fake reality competition. It’s a fun, canny spectacle that completely shakes up the genre

Rebecca Nicholson

25, Mar, 2024 @10:00 PM

Article image
Hot Mess Summer review – Rylan’s new reality dating show is an absolute shambles
Eight unlikable twentysomethings are duped into working in a Greek bar they hate – and end up spitting in a customer’s mouth. It’s nauseating, boring and even Rylan can’t save it

Rachel Aroesti

07, Feb, 2024 @11:52 AM

Article image
I’m 100% faithful: The Traitors is the most exquisite reality TV of the year
On paper, it sounds a bit tepid. In reality, I am devouring each episode with multiple text chats on the go. This is White Lotus meets Big Brother 1 – the most addictive show in ages

Rebecca Nicholson

19, Dec, 2022 @12:01 PM