Simon Schama’s History of Now review – this highly personal show is simplistic and outdated

The academic’s look at truth, democracy and art has its heart very much in the right place. But too often it’s fighting old battles rather than grasping the modern reality of untruths

‘I came into the world to the soundtrack of history,” says Simon Schama as his new series begins, explaining that he was born on 13 February 1945, when Nazi rockets were falling on London and allied bombs were devastating Dresden. If that sounds like a Partridgean piece of self-aggrandisement, it’s forgivable: the three-part Simon Schama’s History of Now (BBC Two) is unabashedly a personal overview of the postwar era, and the art and literature that shaped it.

Episode one, subtitled Truth and Democracy, deals with what Schama sees as an era-defining battle between totalitarianism’s suppression of truth and artists’ unextinguishable yearning to tell it. An admiring glance at Picasso’s Guernica leads into an assessment of the disinformation battle running alongside the Spanish civil war, and how being on the wrong end of Stalinist lies inspired George Orwell to turn propaganda into dystopian fiction. Then, as the hot war of the 1930s and 40s turns cold, we’re in the Soviet Union in the late 50s, where Boris Pasternak knew the dissident sentiments within his epic novel Doctor Zhivago would lead to it being censored, but persevered and, following an exciting series of incidents involving smuggled manuscripts and CIA-backed publications abroad, won the Nobel prize.

Schama, never shy about mentioning his own connection to events, observes that one of those contraband copies was handled by Isaiah Berlin, who would later be Schama’s mentor at Oxford. But the presenter’s visit to Prague in 1965 gives him a more direct investment into the struggle for freedom that forms the centrepiece of the hour. “The ice was cracking: if you went there you could hear it … we did hear it,” says Schama of his time in the Czech capital, before recounting how the Soviet crushing of the Prague Spring in 1968 prompted a period of resistance by writers and musicians, chief among them Václav Havel, whose Charter 77 manifesto and 1978 essay The Power of the Powerless helped his countrymen’s rebel spirit to remain aflame.

Near the episode’s end, Schama holds back tears as he stands on the balcony in Wenceslas Square from which Havel addressed a vast crowd in 1989, with the iron curtain finally falling and with the new Czech Republic, of which Havel would be the founding president, on its way. “That’s why I’m so upset about what’s happening now, with Ukraine,” says Schama, explaining why the memory makes him so emotional. “We cannot afford the liquidation of democracy.”

Schama has clearly been deeply affected by the heinous Russian invasion. Who hasn’t, you might justifiably ask, but in a programme spanning nine decades, Vladimir Putin’s Russia does come up rather a lot. Guernica reminds Schama of the horror in Ukraine, while Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four prompts comparison to Putin’s rewriting of Russian history, and the oppression of Pasternak is deemed more piquant given that “darkness and terror is descending on writers in Russia again”, a sentiment that leads into an interview with Nadya Tolokonnikova of the anti-Putin punk band Pussy Riot.

Putin’s kleptocratic capitalism is treated as essentially the same as the communist Soviet Union, his invasion of a sovereign neighbour analogous to the Soviet crushing of dissent within the eastern Bloc. Russia, in whatever form, is the big authoritarian bogeyman: in a programme about the wielding of misinformation and the undermining of democracy, the idea that the west might also be guilty of those things is, aside from a couple of brief citations of Donald Trump as a toxic anomaly, absent.

A lack of nuance also makes it hard to glean anything significant from Schama’s appreciation of his favoured individual works. Passages from Pasternak and Havel receive awestruck readings, but the specific paragraphs chosen amount to little more than a repetition of the basic idea that repressive governments tell porkies. Schama’s rallying cry, inspired by Havel, that the people’s will to “live in truth” must prevail feels – in an era in which outright top-down censorship has been replaced by subtler methods of bending reality, not least more and more citizens seeming to revel in the spreading of untruths – simplistic and outdated.

On occasion, he veers fully into fan-boy banality. In the section on Nineteen Eighty-Four, Schama praises Orwell for recognising that his message “would only find a mass audience if his book was truly great fiction”, as if this were a piercing insight on Orwell’s part, and not just every author’s natural desire to write the best book they can. Poring over a document in the Orwell archive that shows how the novel’s opening page was extensively redrafted, Schama concludes that this unremarkable process was “the writing, fashioning mind at its most brilliant best”.

Schama’s heart is, of course, in the right place. His championing of dissent and freedom over repression and mendacity is correct and admirable. But so far, his History of Now is fighting old battles.

• This article was amended on 1 December 2022. An earlier version described George Orwell as “being on the wrong end of fascist lies”, when Stalinist lies was meant.

Contributor

Jack Seale

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
1899 review – this painfully slow sci-fi show is absolutely agonising
The horror-mystery from the creators of German hit Dark follows the steamship Cerberus on a voyage beset by bizarre happenings. It’s dour, obtuse and oppressive – enjoy!

Leila Latif

17, Nov, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
That ’90s Show review – this spin-off comedy is like revisiting a childhood classic
The sequel to That ‘70s Show very much takes an approach of ‘If it ain’t broke … ’ As we revisit the Wisconsin basement, even new characters have the old ones’ traits

Lucy Mangan

19, Jan, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
National Treasure: Edge of History review – the mindless days of the 90s are back!
Freemasons, albino monk assassins, Harvey Keitel … this youth-focused spin-off of Jerry Bruckheimer’s adventure movie franchise is loads of daft fun

Lucy Mangan

14, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Without Sin review – Vicky McClure is fantastic in this heavyweight thriller
The Line of Duty star is predictably great as she wrestles with the grief of her daughter’s murder in a top-notch conspiracy drama

Rebecca Nicholson

28, Dec, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Fight the Power: How Hip-Hop Changed the World review – Chuck D is a brilliant history teacher
Some of the greatest pop music ever made gets the respectful, rigorous sociological treatment it deserves – thanks to this documentary series from the Public Enemy star

Jack Seale

21, Jan, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Emily in Paris season three review – there’s no point fighting this nonsense any more
The plot lurches from melodrama to high farce, it’s frequently baffling and the supposedly luxury marketing could have come from a task on The Apprentice. But – whisper it – it’s really fun …

Rebecca Nicholson

21, Dec, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
The Traitors review – Claudia Winkleman’s new show is sick, twisted … and totally addictive
Paranoia, guilt and sociopathy plague the 22 strangers collaborating to win cash – because the Strictly host is secretly ordering some of them to ‘murder’ at night. You’ll be hooked

Lucy Mangan

29, Nov, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Stonehouse review – Matthew Macfadyen is a brilliantly bad baddie in this fun, death-faking romp
Macfadyen and Keeley Hawes are a cheeky, campy delight in the endlessly entertaining story of the inept MP – and worst spy ever – who disappeared from a Miami beach

Rebecca Nicholson

02, Jan, 2023 @10:05 PM

Article image
The Last of Us review – one of the finest TV shows you will see this year
This desperately moving drama set in a zombie-ravaged US is a phenomenal blend of horror and heart, with a cast that could not be more perfect

Rebecca Nicholson

16, Jan, 2023 @10:35 PM

Article image
Riches review – prepare to be addicted to this Jackie Collins-esque drama
Soapy, slick and thoroughly enjoyable, this series about the battle to inherit a Black beauty brand is like Empire meets Dynasty meets Footballers’ Wives. It’s confident, escapist fun

Rebecca Nicholson

22, Dec, 2022 @1:00 PM