The Secret Agent review – worryingly one-dimensional

So much is lost from Conrad’s strange, complex and deeply ironic novel. This adaptation reduces it to a psychological thriller – and proves the curse of TV

It is a brave screenwriter who takes on Joseph Conrad’s The Secret Agent (BBC1, Sunday), which film critic Roger Ebert called “perhaps the least filmable novel he ever wrote”. Ebert made that remark in a review – a fairly devastating one accompanied by the dreaded one star – of the 1996 film version, directed by Christopher Hampton and with an all-star cast including Bob Hoskins as the eponymous agent Verloc, Patricia Arquette as his comely wife Winnie, and Christian Bale as her half-witted brother Stevie.

Ebert’s grouse was that the novel (written in 1907) is a “character study”, but “the movie deals more with externals and, since there are few of any interest, it drags and finally sighs and expires”. The solution, if that’s the word, adopted by writer Tony Marchant and director Charles McDougall for the TV version, is to create some externals – fun stuff to keep us watching for the full hour of part one of this three-part series.

We know immediately that liberties have been taken with the novel (nothing inherently wrong with that, of course) when we begin with a Guy Fawkes’ night firework display in the back garden of Verloc’s shop in London’s Soho. Fireworks do feature in the novel but in a very different context – Stevie gets sacked when he sets them off at the office in which he is supposed to be working. The fireworks party – a way of introducing the family to us and spelling out Stevie’s mental infirmity – is an invention.

All the time you can hear the programme-makers saying: “We really have to liven this up a bit.” There is a great scene in the book where Verloc, who is in the pay of a foreign embassy (we assume it to be Russian), has to meet the first secretary – a withering anglophile called Vladimir – in his office. The meeting goes badly, and you can feel Verloc getting angrier as it progresses, the office becoming more and more claustrophobic. In this adaptation, the meeting begins in the office, but Vladimir then suggests they go for a ride – cue smart hansom cab, busy street scenes, vistas of London. The claustrophobia is lost. But, worse, Vladimir is taking Verloc to the Royal Observatory in Greenwich, which he thinks would be the perfect target for a terrorist attack. The embassy employs Verloc as an agent provocateur to encourage anarchists to commit atrocities that will in turn lead to a police crackdown in the UK (this is 1886 and Tsarist Russia is looking for reactionary allies).

In the book, the first secretary makes a brilliant, witty, scathing case for attacking science – indeed, attacking time itself, since Greenwich marks the prime meridian – but on TV we have to be shown it. The mystery, the enigma, the idea that an attack on the very idea of time is all that will shock the English middle class is lost.

That, in essence, is the problem here: all the workings must be shown. Conrad’s great, strange, tonally complex novel is reduced to a psychological thriller. You would never know from watching it that The Secret Agent is in some respects a funny book, certainly a deeply ironic one. Conrad based Verloc’s attempt to bomb the observatory on a real incident in which a half-baked anarchist blew himself up, and his description of it in a later preface to the novel should be the starting point for any treatment. He called the ill-fated terrorist attack “a blood-stained inanity of so fatuous a kind that it was impossible to fathom its origin by any reasonable or even unreasonable process of thought”.

Much of Conrad’s oddness as a novelist resides in his unwillingness to explain. We don’t really understand Verloc in the book, other than as a study in indolence and narcissism. So to have to start pinning everything down – his sense of being tortured because he is a double (indeed treble) agent, how Winnie feels about working in a 19th-century porn shop, the reason Winnie’s mother feels she has to move – undermines the Conradian worldview: that none of us knows anything, least of all about ourselves.

So much is lost: the competitive, distrustful relationship between Chief Inspector Heat and the Met’s assistant commissioner; Vladimir’s icy humour; Verloc’s French background (I find Toby Jones’s Hoskins-type London accent irritating); the physical grotesqueness of the characters (in the book, Winnie’s mother’s legs are so fat she is completely immobilised, but on screen she is a young-looking, birdlike middle-aged woman); the laziness of the anarchists and their love of domestic order (hinted at in the series, but not made as explicit as in the book); the comedy around the “great personage” at the Home Office and his dislike of being burdened with details.

I’ve only seen the first episode, but I worry for the one-dimensionality of the series. Verloc has so far been treated as the central character and the bomb plot as the hinge of the drama, but Conrad was explicit that the novel’s moral centre was Winnie, and the way she had accepted a loveless marriage to provide for her brother Stevie. The novel achieves the shift of focus from Verloc to Winnie quite brilliantly, but that relies on us gradually discovering what really happened in Greenwich Park. The series seems to be opting for literalness and linearity – plus some invented business involving a manhunt for the bomb-making “professor” – and I wonder if the shock of the conclusion will be muffled. Winnie’s tragedy steals up on you through the London fog – everywhere in the book, not yet seen on screen. Without the fog – real and metaphorical – will it have the same impact? Having to show everything clearly, not being able to trust the mind of the viewer, is the curse of TV.

Contributor

Stephen Moss

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Capital review – a complicated and brilliant portrait of London life
The eponymous novel by John Lanchester is transported to an all-too-recognisable suburban street, unfolding the lives of its complex residents, where somebody wants what they have

Sam Wollaston

24, Nov, 2015 @10:00 PM

Article image
Marvellous; Your Home in their Hands review – two Neil Baldwins meet real Lou Macari and real Gary Lineker
Sam Wollaston: Toby Jones gives a lovely, very human, performance in Peter Bowker’s film of Neil Baldwin’s life story. If this film were a body part, it would be a heart, and a big one

Sam Wollaston

26, Sep, 2014 @5:00 AM

Article image
Detectorists Christmas Special review – the best thing you will watch all festive period
This special isn’t quite as perfect as the original, but revisiting Mackenzie Crook and Toby Jones’s precious sitcom is pure pleasure. It beats all other yuletide TV hands down

Jack Seale

26, Dec, 2022 @10:15 PM

Article image
Strike: Lethal White review – daft, dark hokum from JK Rowling
Believability is not the strongest element of the latest adaptation of the author’s private detective series – but when has that ever been a prerequisite of TV crimefighters?

Stuart Jeffries

30, Aug, 2020 @9:00 PM

Article image
Us review – divorce drama offers warmth and wanderlust
Based on the novel by David Nicholls, this gentle series about a family embarking on one last holiday proves especially poignant with travel largely off-limits

Rebecca Nicholson

20, Sep, 2020 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Durrells review – a welcome vacation from our island of nightmares
It’s one last push for the cockle-warming Corfu Brits as a barn owl, an ‘idle walrus’ and the ever-wonderful Keeley Hawes kick off the drama’s final series

Chitra Ramaswamy

07, Apr, 2019 @8:00 PM

Article image
The Handmaid’s Tale season four review – hope at last in the most harrowing show on TV
Elisabeth Moss has always made this impressive if horrifying TV. But as the new series turns June into queen of the rebels, it has a shot of new life

Rebecca Nicholson

20, Jun, 2021 @9:10 PM

Article image
Crime review – Irvine Welsh’s first TV drama is a dreich and plodding affair
This Edinburgh cop show is disappointingly conventional stuff from the author known for his exuberance and excess – and its dialogue is deathly

Lucy Mangan

18, Nov, 2021 @12:54 PM

Article image
The Ipcress File review – a working-class hero takes on the might of Russia
ITV’s reboot of Len Deighton’s cold war spy thriller has Joe Cole as Harry Palmer sorting out the mess left by public school boys. Sound familiar?

Stuart Jeffries

06, Mar, 2022 @10:00 PM

Article image
Derry Girls finale review – absolutely cracker
This perfectly proportioned ending tugs at the heartstrings, and delivers the funniest TV scene of the year bar none. Rarely does a comedy bow out on such a high

Rebecca Nicholson

18, May, 2022 @9:04 PM