Covid has exposed the damage caused to families by a decade of austerity | Ray Jones

The pandemic has shown the impact of increased deprivation, difficulties for families and greater risks for vulnerable children

The coronavirus pandemic is having awful health, social and economic consequences, but amid the threat and fear, it should provide an opportunity to reflect and learn. This is especially urgent in assessing its impact on children’s welfare and safety.

The pandemic has demonstrated the impact of removing safeguards for children and help for families that had been embedded in the welfare state and public services. There have been concerns about the effects of lockdown on the mental health of children and adults, increasing domestic violence, and online grooming and exploitation of children and vulnerable adults.

These concerns are amplified by the anxiety that what is happening within families is now less known, especially as children are less seen and heard outside their homes, which presents real dangers for children receiving poor care and facing threats and violence from their parents and carers. For example, a study in Birmingham found the number of children referred for child protection medical examinations during February to June this year was 40% lower than in the same period in 2018, and 37% less than 2019.

At the same time, however, another study found a surge in domestic child abuse during the first UK lockdown, with an increase in children aged 17 days to 13 months old admitted to hospital with abusive head trauma. The researchers noted that “the infants’ families all lived in areas of significant social and economic deprivation”, and that “socioeconomic deprivation and parental vulnerability [are] significant risk factors for abuse, both of which may be exacerbated as a result of the stresses imposed by quarantine measures”.

Ofsted, meanwhile, reports a 20% increase in babies and toddlers killed or seriously harmed in England during the first lockdown. The explanation given by the regulator’s chief inspector is that “the pandemic has brought difficult and stressful times [with] financial hardship, loss of employment, isolation, and close family proximity [having] put extra pressure on families that were already struggling”.

Yet at the same time as families faced increasing struggles and stressors, the opportunity to know where and when children are being abused and neglected has reduced due to the closure of nurseries, schools and family centres, as well as the need for children’s professionals to socially distance and self-isolate. As Jenny Coles, president of the Association of Directors of Children’s Services, has commented: “The pandemic has seriously disrupted a key line of sight into the lives and homes of many families.”

So what lessons can be drawn from the effect of the measures taken to control the pandemic in England? First, there has been a disproportionate impact on deprived children and families. The stress they experience has intensified, with financial poverty even more severe and with them being locked down in poor, overcrowded and insecure housing. The link between deprivation and it being more difficult to parent well has been highlighted by numerous studies but for the past 10 years, the government has chosen to target politically chosen austerity on families already immersed in deprivation. Policies such as poverty-creating universal credit, reductions in benefit payments and the two-child benefit cap have had terrible consequences, and need to be urgently reviewed and reversed.

The second lesson is that the distancing and withdrawal of those who work to assist children and families – such as early years workers, teachers, youth workers, health professionals, and social workers – leaves children more vulnerable and families stranded without help. This has magnified the impact of what has been in train for many years. For example, the number of health visitors in England reduced by a third between 2015 and 2019, and government funding for family centres and youth services was cut by more than half from 2010 to 2018, with the Local Government Association expressing concern that children had disappeared from view.

The consequence of 10 years of austerity targeting poor families and public services had greatly undermined the capacity to provide help. Families have to be in severe crisis before they receive much of a response, and that response has increasingly been monitoring and surveillance through child protection procedures, which heightens the fear for families.

Local authority children’s services across the country have significant and increasing overspends. There are difficulties in retaining experienced social workers, with almost a fifth of roles in statutory children’s services being filled by short-term, interim agency workers. A third of councils have had a change in their children’s services leadership in 2019-20. The difficulties created by cuts, churn and change have been compounded by the increasing complexity of services such as foster and children’s residential care not being provided by local authorities but at a distance by commercial companies, with opaque owners taking big profits.

The pandemic has shown the consequences of increased deprivation and difficulties for families, greater risks for vulnerable children, and the drawing back from help for families and protection for children. As its impact hopefully reduces in the future, there are lessons that should lead to the reshaping and reprioritising of government policies for the longer term.


Ray Jones

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Austerity has pushed families into crisis and then thrown away the lifelines | Richard Vize
Relentless cuts have put more children at risk of violence, poverty and homelessness, with no end in sight whatever politicians promise

Richard Vize

08, Nov, 2019 @11:10 AM

Article image
How many children at risk? UK health visitors count the cost of lockdown
Professionals supporting families worry they may not be picking up issues such as mental ill health and domestic abuse

Sarah Johnson

07, Jul, 2020 @7:30 AM

Article image
A fair start for every child in England? Not under this punitive government | Richard Vize
Families desperately need joined-up support, but ministers refuse to see how their policies set up poor children to fail

Richard Vize

01, Mar, 2019 @9:44 AM

Article image
I wept after hearing women's stories. A decade of austerity has wrecked lives | Mary O'Hara
Ten years of suffering has normalised hardship. As millions more are impoverished by coronavirus, we need an exit strategy, says social affairs writer Mary O’Hara

Mary O’Hara

22, Jun, 2020 @2:34 PM

Article image
UK faith leaders unite to challenge welfare penalties on larger families
Christian churches and Jewish groups urge House of Lords to block government’s plans to limit tax credits to first two children

Harriet Sherwood Religion correspondent

10, Nov, 2015 @1:40 PM

Article image
My working week: 'I cry after hearing one domestic abuse survivor's story. She is lucky to be alive'
My job is to make women who suffer domestic violence safer. I wonder if they know how I wish I could do more


14, Sep, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
'I needed to fix myself for my kids': breaking the cycle of domestic abuse
Families with complicated lives are being helped by a project that supports both parents during their child’s first two years

Sarah Johnson

28, Oct, 2020 @8:19 AM

Article image
'Cass's ex is a gang member and child trafficker who hit her': my job in social work
Supporting women who have been caught up in the drugs trade and gang culture is exhausting but rewarding


29, Jul, 2019 @6:30 AM

Article image
Alison Michalska: ‘In Britain, we don’t seem to really like children’ | Patrick Butler
Not only does poverty blight youngsters’ lives says Alison Michalska, president of the Association of Directors of Children’s Services, but it’s getting worse

Patrick Butler

11, Oct, 2017 @6:59 AM

Article image
Austerity policy blamed for record numbers of children taken into care
Fragmented approach to public services is damaging communities in England and punishing the poor, say council leaders

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

11, Oct, 2017 @5:36 PM