Steve Baker wants to renegotiate Brexit agreement over Northern Ireland

Northern Ireland minister’s proposal comes after PM denied plans for Swiss-style relationship with EU

The Northern Ireland minister, Steve Baker, is proposing reopening the Brexit trade agreement David Frost struck with the EU as a means of fixing the problems caused by the Northern Ireland protocol.

The proposal comes after Rishi Sunak moved to quell a rebellion in the Conservative party over suggestions Downing Street was mulling a Swiss-style relationship with the EU to ease wider trade barriers on food and agricultural products.

In a confidential paper circulating in the Northern Ireland Office, Baker outlines potential ways of removing the role of the European court of justice in disputes, something both unionists and the Eurosceptic European Research Group are demanding.

The proposals essentially revisit a sequencing argument the UK lost in 2017 while the Conservative party was in disarray over whether to stay in the EU customs union and single market.

When it did not get the necessary commitment from Theresa May, the EU decided that the Northern Ireland protocol should be placed in the legally binding withdrawal agreement and not the trade deal.

In the paper Baker suggests reversing that sequencing in retrospect to end the row over the Northern Ireland protocol.

He suggests updating the trade agreement by adding a “customs cooperation chapter” and changing the protocol to include a dispute mechanism that does not involve the ECJ.

But experts say it could be an insurmountable challenge.

“All of this is theoretically possible but whether the EU would agree to it is another issue,” said Catherine Barnard, professor of EU law at Cambridge University and deputy director of the UK in a Changing Europe thinktank.

She said the EU has “taken a very strong line” that the ECJ has to have a role in the protocol if Northern Ireland is to remain in a halfway house – following both UK and EU rules on trade.

“The EU will say until it is blue in the face that because Northern Ireland remains in the customs union, because everything from packaging to things as rarefied as animal semen is subject to EU law the ECJ has to have a role as it is the only arbiter of its own law,” she said.

Katy Hayward, professor of political sociology at Queen’s University Belfast, said it was difficult to see the EU revisiting deals that took four tumultuous years of negotiation.

“The terms of trade between the UK and EU directly affect the challenges for post-Brexit Northern Ireland, caught as it is between Britain and Ireland. So recognition that the TCA has ramifications for the protocol’s operation is welcome. However, if [vice-president of the European Commission’] Maroš] Šefčovič doesn’t have a mandate to rewrite the withdrawal agreement to fix the protocol, he most certainly doesn’t have one to revise the TCA too.

“Although there is scope in both agreements for adjustment by mutual decision between Šefčovič and [UK foreign secretary James] Cleverly, it wouldn’t be enough make substantive changes or add new chapters,” Hayward said.

But Baker has been arguing that while it is a “narrow and steep” path, the political will to find a solution to the Northern Ireland Brexit question is there given that the US president, Joe Biden, the EU, Ireland and the British governments have expressed their determination to find a negotiated solution by the 25th anniversary of the Good Friday agreement next April.

Under the present arrangements, businesses sending goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland must comply with EU laws and regulations on customs and standards.

The EU has suggested a light-touch express lane for goods that remain in Northern Ireland such as sausages, ready meals and horticultural products including seed potatoes and trees for supermarkets, and garden and farming outlets.

The UK has been demanding a similar system with “green lanes” for trucks laden with goods for Northern Ireland and “red lanes” for those with goods destined for the Republic of Ireland and the EU.

Šefčovič has recently said this system would reduce checks to a couple of lorries a day.

Last year Šefčovič said a Swiss-stye trading arrangement would get rid of 80% of the checks as it would mean food and agriculture standards in the UK were legally aligned with the UK.

However, Sunak pushed back on reports that he was now considering this as an option on the wider UK-EU stage, saying earlier this week that having “regulatory freedom” to diverge on EU standards was a key advantage, insisting it would not be sacrificed in any future talks.


Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rishi Sunak plans US trip with Northern Ireland high on agenda
UK officials in flurry of diplomacy seeking agreement with EU over protocol, but play down talk that deal is close

Kiran Stacey, Lisa O'Carroll, Pippa Crerar and Jennifer Rankin

01, Feb, 2023 @6:34 PM

Article image
Northern Ireland secretary optimistic on resolving Brexit standoff with EU
Chris Heaton-Harris also repeated that he would call an election on 28 October if power sharing is not restored

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

07, Oct, 2022 @4:02 PM

Article image
UK ends standoff with EU as hopes rise for Northern Ireland Brexit deal
Talks between Irish foreign minister and UK counterpart announced amid change in ‘mood music’

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

05, Oct, 2022 @4:35 PM

Article image
New HMRC data raises UK hopes of end to Northern Ireland Brexit trade checks
Analysis of database tailored to EU needs shows 85% of GB exports stay in the region’s factories and shops

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

05, Dec, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
UK to unilaterally continue suspending Northern Ireland border checks
Move likely further to antagonise EU but leaders hope Queen’s death may help bring about reconciliation

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

15, Sep, 2022 @10:29 AM

Article image
Liz Truss faces Lords’ Northern Ireland protocol rebellion
Peers from all parties seeking to stop bill getting on statute books amid hope of more optimistic talks

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

10, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Sinn Féin wants Northern Ireland vote in event of no-deal Brexit
Party leader Mary Lou McDonald to tell Theresa May ‘not to hitch herself’ to DUP

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

15, Oct, 2018 @1:37 PM

Article image
EU offers to reduce Northern Ireland border checks to ‘a couple of lorries a day’
Brexit chief extends olive branch in effort to bring UK back to negotiating table in long-running dispute

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

12, Sep, 2022 @2:52 PM

Article image
Northern Ireland businesses ‘must get Brexit compensation’
MPs say government should pay millions to cover cost of trading with Great Britain

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

13, Jul, 2020 @11:07 PM

Article image
Tory MP Steve Baker apologises to Ireland and EU for behaviour during Brexit
Northern Ireland minister says he and colleagues had not always respected others’ ‘legitimate interests’

Lisa O'Carroll Brexit correspondent

02, Oct, 2022 @6:23 PM